Topic: Should men be "manly"?
no photo
Tue 01/10/12 10:36 AM




I think a wide verity of skills are lacking on a lot of people of both genders.

I do not however think assigning certain tasks to certain genders is really a 21st century winning strategy.

My mom was a doit yourselfer, and while my dad was my tools/shop/carpenter/tech extreme she was seriously awesome in her ability to figure stuff out . . .

I think everyone should work to be like that. No one should say . . . well I am __________ gender I dont/cant do that, its just an excuse not to learn something and develop skills.

No one is born with these skills.



It surprises me that there are still so many people in this day that think men and women should have clearly defined roles/tasks. That a man needs to do certain things to be manly and a woman needs to behave in a certain way to be feminine.
I think most people probably fall into a middle ground were they do favor certain gender assigned roles, but are accepting of the other gender filling that role. I think on the flip however that at least among men(where I have experience) it is quite common to mess with each other over a man doing what was traditionally a womens role, or being seen as less than the "man of the house".

It is a traditionalist mindset for sure, however the bravado hasn't really changed has it?


I notice it a lot on a site like this when people think men should be making the first move/contact/whatever when it comes to dating. And that the woman should sit back and wait for them to come to her.

But, I guess it does have a lot to do with how you were brought up. It can be hard to change that mindset when it comes to gender related roles.


At my age, old school is the norm...Guess I am not normal because if I feel an attraction or an interest in a man who has not contacted me, I will make the first move...It doesn't take long to find out if there is mutual interest and it beats the helium out of the "what if's"...You just have to be brave, not be afraid of rejection....flowerforyou Remember, this is a dating site...I say let's date!bigsmile

Optomistic69's photo
Tue 01/10/12 10:42 AM
Oh my your a sparky..lol.Anyways your work is the kind where people shouldn't lie just to get their foot in the door.I'm now a commercial superintendent and most of our jobs require 3 phase and yes you better know what you are doing cause if that main is turned on and sparks go flying...mucho money just wasted.


I connected street lighting to live cable in the ground when I was 21 years old.

I worked with qualified Electricians years later and none of them believed that I had done it.

I earned very good money but I had no qualifications in electrical work.

Saying that ...no unqualified person should be allowed to touch electric....drinker

actionlynx's photo
Tue 01/10/12 10:54 AM
Edited by actionlynx on Tue 01/10/12 10:55 AM

Oh my your a sparky..lol.Anyways your work is the kind where people shouldn't lie just to get their foot in the door.I'm now a commercial superintendent and most of our jobs require 3 phase and yes you better know what you are doing cause if that main is turned on and sparks go flying...mucho money just wasted.


Most definitely.

Residential work is much easier than commercial or industrial, not only knowledge-wise but physically too. Running pipe 20 ft above the floor when it weighs 10 lbs. per foot, and then having to pull cable that weighs 3 lbs. per foot, can be pretty grueling - even when you're using plenty of grease. With 3 phase, that means pulling 5 cables at once, effectively making it 15 lbs. per foot.

If you use some kind a winch instead, you really better know what your doing. If that cable gets damaged... Throw in all the machinery and computer systems that might be affected by shoddy workmanship, and the cost of a mistake rises exponentially. You don't want a $20k job to end up costing you $60k because the cable was damaged or your hook up was wrong.

Yet there are some guys that just want to bull right through rather than take time to analyze the situation. I'll never forget the time someone decided to use a shop vac to suck a mole through 700 ft. of PVC pipe without blowing out the pipe first. Fwoosh! Flames shooting out of the shop vac from the glue fumes reaching the hot vacuum motor. The best part was the guy who did it was a volunteer fireman. laugh

patsfan64's photo
Tue 01/10/12 11:06 AM



I dont think its a male/female thing with regard to who contacts first. I think its a question of m/f energy there. Not skillsets, but personality traits.


That doesn't make sense to me. Not a male/female thing, yet it has to do with male/female energy?


Sing, havent we talked about this before?

Its not the 'man' who makes contact/asks for date, but the one with 'masculine energy'.

Can you imagine how lonely lesbians would have to be if it was the 'man' that asks ya out?


I ask lesbians out ALL the time and not one ever returns my messages!

no photo
Tue 01/10/12 11:07 AM



I dont think its a male/female thing with regard to who contacts first. I think its a question of m/f energy there. Not skillsets, but personality traits.


That doesn't make sense to me. Not a male/female thing, yet it has to do with male/female energy?


Sing, havent we talked about this before?

Its not the 'man' who makes contact/asks for date, but the one with 'masculine energy'.

Can you imagine how lonely lesbians would have to be if it was the 'man' that asks ya out?


Didn't make much sense to me then, either. :tongue:

I never said a man has to ask anyone out. I said I notice the outdated gender role in this forum when people talk about dating.

actionlynx's photo
Tue 01/10/12 11:11 AM

I ask lesbians out ALL the time and not one ever returns my messages!


I've had a lesbian invite me to a baseball game....but that was with her partner present. Does it still count? :tongue:


Shy_Emo_chick's photo
Tue 01/10/12 11:17 AM


If I had a dime for every time someone told me "my [grand]father built this house himself..." only to cut into a wall to find a hidden disaster....well, I'd be well on my way to retirement.

oops



rofl My grandad is the same. He's so obssessed with D.I.Y and decorating, that he practically has a new looking lounge every year. It just gets tedious though, having to force a smile and pretend you're so impressed by his latest decorating. I don't mean that to sound as nasty as it sounds. I just mean, if you don't like the colour scheme or whatever else, you kinda have to act, and pretend you DO like it. lol. You force a smile so badly, that your mouth ends up hurting. laugh. I do find it admirable though, cos it takes a lot of effort all the same. I'm just saying, basically, that he was way obssessed with D.I.Y. He would bleed radiators, also. The guy needs to breathe. laugh

patsfan64's photo
Tue 01/10/12 11:17 AM





I dont think its a male/female thing with regard to who contacts first. I think its a question of m/f energy there. Not skillsets, but personality traits.


That doesn't make sense to me. Not a male/female thing, yet it has to do with male/female energy?


Sing, havent we talked about this before?

Its not the 'man' who makes contact/asks for date, but the one with 'masculine energy'.

Can you imagine how lonely lesbians would have to be if it was the 'man' that asks ya out?

I ask lesbians out ALL the time and not one ever returns my messages!




lesbians are SO mean!laugh


And discriminatory against men!

no photo
Tue 01/10/12 11:28 AM
Edited by singmesweet on Tue 01/10/12 11:36 AM





I dont think its a male/female thing with regard to who contacts first. I think its a question of m/f energy there. Not skillsets, but personality traits.


That doesn't make sense to me. Not a male/female thing, yet it has to do with male/female energy?


Sing, havent we talked about this before?

Its not the 'man' who makes contact/asks for date, but the one with 'masculine energy'.

Can you imagine how lonely lesbians would have to be if it was the 'man' that asks ya out?


Didn't make much sense to me then, either. :tongue:

I never said a man has to ask anyone out. I said I notice the outdated gender role in this forum when people talk about dating.


Its the understanding that men can have more feminine energy as women can have more masculine energy. Its not about 'outdated' or 'old fashioned' its just who we all are.

A perspective you either dont get, or disagree with. Just an idea thats available to you. you dont have to agree.


As I said, it just doesn't make much sense to me. In my mind, we're talking about the same thing, but you're saying it's not. That's cool.

Also, me saying something is old fashioned or outdated, that's not meant as an insult. Just as some of the other stuff in this thread seem a bit old fashioned as well - for example assuming someone is manly because they know how to use tools. As we can see from this thread, many women can do that as well.

no photo
Tue 01/10/12 11:56 AM
Its not the 'man' who makes contact/asks for date, but the one with 'masculine energy'.
So being confident, assertive, and knowing what you want is masculine?


no photo
Tue 01/10/12 11:57 AM

I was watching a tv show recently and this married couple were arguing over the fact that the wife thought her husband should be able to build a diy porch. Her arguement was that he's a man, he should be able to do it.

Now as ridiculous as this sounded, I could see her point. I do expect a man to be manly. I grew up around cousins who built their mother's house by hand, can fix everything, work hard on a farm plus they can all cook, iron etc. Actually one of them taught me how to bake bread, but all that cooking stuff was just me bragging. What I want to know is do we still expect men to be "manly"? Should he only cry if his favourite soccer team loses? Must he atleast own a couple of tools and know what they are for? Should he only go to the mechanic when his engine is beyond repair?


IMO, a manly man is a guy that admits that he can't do DIY or be let anywhere near a power tool. It’s great if he can put up a shelf without electrocuting himself but it's not essential.

no photo
Tue 01/10/12 11:59 AM

Its not the 'man' who makes contact/asks for date, but the one with 'masculine energy'.
So being confident, assertive, and knowing what you want is masculine?




Yeah, that's what doesn't make sense to me. I never realized those traits were masculine.

actionlynx's photo
Tue 01/10/12 12:07 PM
In some cultures and belief systems, they are considered masculine traits. That's why the term "traditional" is an apt description, IMO.

no photo
Tue 01/10/12 12:13 PM

In some cultures and belief systems, they are considered masculine traits. That's why the term "traditional" is an apt description, IMO.


What is the culture and belief system that you feel is being discussed here that says those traits are masculine?

RKISIT's photo
Tue 01/10/12 12:16 PM
A manly man is a man who has a really huge johnson motor on his boat to get him to some nice bass quicker.

no photo
Tue 01/10/12 12:21 PM


Its not the 'man' who makes contact/asks for date, but the one with 'masculine energy'.
So being confident, assertive, and knowing what you want is masculine?



Yes. Surely you realise that women have these traits, so it is not because they are a man, but their comfort with using masculine energy. It doesnt mean a woman is mannish, or butch, just that she is comfortable with masculine energy.

Just like nurturing is feminine energy. You realise that there are men who are quite comfortable with using feminine energy, and nurture their children for example. And some women, alternatively, are not.




Really? So it isn't feminine to know what you want or be confident about yourself? I have to believe that not everyone thinks that way.

actionlynx's photo
Tue 01/10/12 12:27 PM


In some cultures and belief systems, they are considered masculine traits. That's why the term "traditional" is an apt description, IMO.


What is the culture and belief system that you feel is being discussed here that says those traits are masculine?


For one, it describes Yang energy within the context of Yin and Yang.

As another, it also represents the machismo/feminismo inherent in traditional Spanish cultures. It is most visible in traditional Spanish dances like Flamenco where the male dancer tends to be much more rigid and forceful compared to the female dancer who is more fluid.

actionlynx's photo
Tue 01/10/12 12:29 PM




Its not the 'man' who makes contact/asks for date, but the one with 'masculine energy'.
So being confident, assertive, and knowing what you want is masculine?



Yes. Surely you realise that women have these traits, so it is not because they are a man, but their comfort with using masculine energy. It doesnt mean a woman is mannish, or butch, just that she is comfortable with masculine energy.

Just like nurturing is feminine energy. You realise that there are men who are quite comfortable with using feminine energy, and nurture their children for example. And some women, alternatively, are not.




Really? So it isn't feminine to know what you want or be confident about yourself? I have to believe that not everyone thinks that way.


Im talking about the behavior rather than the feelings.
Confident is not what I referred to. I accepted the whole package which included 'assertive'...I recognised it as the 'hunter' behavior he described.

Using feminine energy when you are a man is not an insult
Using masculine energy when you are a woman is not an insult

We all use both unless theres something wrong.



This fits with Yin and Yang.

actionlynx's photo
Tue 01/10/12 12:51 PM
Yang tends to be more "me" oriented, and represents the masculine.

Yin tends to be more "we" oriented, and represents the feminine.


So being assertive and goal-oriented is a Yang energy, but it can be mixed with Yin energy to become more oriented toward family or community. Hence, Yin energy is more nurturing and selfless.

winterblue56's photo
Tue 01/10/12 05:14 PM
I don't go out and specifically look for men that know how to use power tools, can wrench a car or bike or know how to use a hammer; but I do find it admirable when he will take the time to learn how to fix the bathroom sink, change an electrical outlet or change the oil in the car...and those are the simple fix-er-uppers.

It's not so much as having the ability, but wanting to learn something new for the sake of expanding their minds <men and woman alike>. I'm a fix-it person and don't think I would be comfortable in a relationship where I'm up on the roof and my significant other is on the couch eating bon-bons laugh . Nor would I want to be eating bon-bons while my other is in the kitchen cooking. Life is a "give and take" and "share and share alike". It's a "blending" of lives...work together to get the job done flowerforyou .