1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 12 Next
Topic: NO Contradictions in the Bible .....
Eljay's photo
Mon 06/30/08 10:51 PM


Before this thread runs amok (like it hasn't already) I think everyone here can agree that the taking of another life is generally not going to be God's first choice for anyone. However - there are varying degree's quantifying the "wrong" as it were. In a eutopia, there would never be a circumstance that would warrent "killing" anyone. It is only under degree's of extreme agression that justification is even considered. These are exceptions to the commandment. These would be self-defense, those who go off to war, or human error in a dangerous environment. (driving in a car, getting a flat tire and causing a fatal accident comes to mind)

As with any commandment - God isn't necessarily forbidding the choice to break the "law", just making man aware that for any wrong action there is going to be a consequence. Despite the level of justification - the degree of "pre-meditation" is going to be met with the degree of consequence. However, the consequence is not necessarily swift, nor immediate. But God is not mocked. He's fully aware of the intent, and expects man to face the reality of their own actions.

This - to me - is the intention of the commandment in the first place. I'm more than willing to adress or consider alternative interpretations here - but it seems petty to try and equate a soldier going to war with an unrepentant serial killer.


Just wanted to give my input on this issue. I am formerly a born again Christian myself...turned atheist, just so you know. I just wanted to point out, that I disagree with what you have just said. A sin, is a sin, is a sin. As you well know, if you are as versed in the bible as you say. There were many more commandments than just 10! According to God's word, even thinking about committing a sin, is the same as acting it out. It does not matter what your intent is, sin, is sin and all sins are weighted equally in God's eyes. Once again, according to the bible.

For all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God!




It wasn't a discussion about how many commandments there are - or whether or not all have sinned and fallen short of the glory of God. It was a direct reference to Funches concerning his leagalistic fundamentalist view of a commandment, and his lack of understanding about the exegesis involved in his analogies.

Did you read the post?

oldsage's photo
Tue 07/01/08 03:17 PM
If you can not debate politely, this will bw locked down.


no photo
Tue 07/01/08 04:05 PM
oops sorry if I wasn't being polite enough..."Eljay" I politely ask you can I answer your response to me politely ..

God said thou shalt not kill ...but God told Moses to politely kill ...

this is clearly a contradiction but I'm sure it's a polite contradiction

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 12 Next