Topic: Where in the Genesis is Jesus
CowboyGH's photo
Thu 12/01/11 04:42 PM






What does the rib being taken from Adam and free will have ANYTHING to do with one another?


Cowboy....did God ask Adam if he wasn't to give his rib to create his child Eve...if the answer is no....then that is why Adam didn't have any "Free WIll"




God taking one of Adam's ribs didn't cause Adam to do anything though. Again after again, free-will pertains to an action or a thought. God taking one of Adam's ribs did not restrict any action or thought or make Adam do an action or thought. Taking the rib effected Adam's free will not one bit.


Cowboy...your definition of "Free Will" appears to be sort of vague so I decide to pull up one of your previous "Free Will" definitions


POSTED BY COWBOY:

That is all free will is, is the ability to choose what to do

http://mingle2.com/topic/show/307199?page=2... post 11



so now Cowboy going with your definition of "Free Will"....did God give Adam a choice to choose what to do before God put him asleep and took his rib


Again, the rib being taken out of Adam was not an action Adam took. He was not forced to take any action, therefore his free will was not taken away.


nope...you said that Free Will was the ability to choose.....when did Adam get to choose to lose his rib?


Choose as in choose to do something or not do something. The rib being taken out of Adam did not cause him to do an action or restrict him from doing an action. Therefore again, no free will was taken away.

CowboyGH's photo
Thu 12/01/11 04:45 PM






What does the rib being taken from Adam and free will have ANYTHING to do with one another?


Cowboy....did God ask Adam if he wasn't to give his rib to create his child Eve...if the answer is no....then that is why Adam didn't have any "Free WIll"




God taking one of Adam's ribs didn't cause Adam to do anything though. Again after again, free-will pertains to an action or a thought. God taking one of Adam's ribs did not restrict any action or thought or make Adam do an action or thought. Taking the rib effected Adam's free will not one bit.


Cowboy...your definition of "Free Will" appears to be sort of vague so I decide to pull up one of your previous "Free Will" definitions


POSTED BY COWBOY:

That is all free will is, is the ability to choose what to do

http://mingle2.com/topic/show/307199?page=2... post 11



so now Cowboy going with your definition of "Free Will"....did God give Adam a choice to choose what to do before God put him asleep and took his rib


Again, the rib being taken out of Adam was not an action Adam took. He was not forced to take any action, therefore his free will was not taken away.


nope...you said that Free Will was the ability to choose.....when did Adam get to choose to lose his rib?


Notice in my definition of free will, it is not just choose alone.


That is all free will is, is the ability to choose what to do


Choose what to do. You have a choice to do something or not do something. The rib being taken out was not an action Adam took. It had nothing to do with Adam other then it was being taken out of him. It didn't restrict him, did not force him to do something.

no photo
Thu 12/01/11 04:45 PM







What does the rib being taken from Adam and free will have ANYTHING to do with one another?


Cowboy....did God ask Adam if he wasn't to give his rib to create his child Eve...if the answer is no....then that is why Adam didn't have any "Free WIll"




God taking one of Adam's ribs didn't cause Adam to do anything though. Again after again, free-will pertains to an action or a thought. God taking one of Adam's ribs did not restrict any action or thought or make Adam do an action or thought. Taking the rib effected Adam's free will not one bit.


Cowboy...your definition of "Free Will" appears to be sort of vague so I decide to pull up one of your previous "Free Will" definitions


POSTED BY COWBOY:

That is all free will is, is the ability to choose what to do

http://mingle2.com/topic/show/307199?page=2... post 11



so now Cowboy going with your definition of "Free Will"....did God give Adam a choice to choose what to do before God put him asleep and took his rib


Again, the rib being taken out of Adam was not an action Adam took. He was not forced to take any action, therefore his free will was not taken away.


nope...you said that Free Will was the ability to choose.....when did Adam get to choose to lose his rib?


Choose as in choose to do something or not do something. The rib being taken out of Adam did not cause him to do an action or restrict him from doing an action. Therefore again, no free will was taken away.


God put Adam to sleep so didn't God take away Adam's ability to choose?

CowboyGH's photo
Thu 12/01/11 05:03 PM








What does the rib being taken from Adam and free will have ANYTHING to do with one another?


Cowboy....did God ask Adam if he wasn't to give his rib to create his child Eve...if the answer is no....then that is why Adam didn't have any "Free WIll"




God taking one of Adam's ribs didn't cause Adam to do anything though. Again after again, free-will pertains to an action or a thought. God taking one of Adam's ribs did not restrict any action or thought or make Adam do an action or thought. Taking the rib effected Adam's free will not one bit.


Cowboy...your definition of "Free Will" appears to be sort of vague so I decide to pull up one of your previous "Free Will" definitions


POSTED BY COWBOY:

That is all free will is, is the ability to choose what to do

http://mingle2.com/topic/show/307199?page=2... post 11



so now Cowboy going with your definition of "Free Will"....did God give Adam a choice to choose what to do before God put him asleep and took his rib


Again, the rib being taken out of Adam was not an action Adam took. He was not forced to take any action, therefore his free will was not taken away.


nope...you said that Free Will was the ability to choose.....when did Adam get to choose to lose his rib?


Choose as in choose to do something or not do something. The rib being taken out of Adam did not cause him to do an action or restrict him from doing an action. Therefore again, no free will was taken away.


God put Adam to sleep so didn't God take away Adam's ability to choose?


Not specifically. "Sleeping" is not an action one takes. One lays down to sleep, yes this is an action one takes, but one doesn't choose when they "fall" asleep.

CowboyGH's photo
Thu 12/01/11 05:10 PM
Edited by CowboyGH on Thu 12/01/11 05:12 PM








And I'm certain it wasn't against Adam's will to be asleep with this happened. I know I personally would absolutely not want to be awake enduring this pain he would have been in.

The only way it would have been taking away Adams free will or doing something against his will is if he did not want God to do this. We have no information on if he didn't want this to happen. All we know is Adam was a lonely person and wanted someone to share his life with. So with that, God was doing his will and creating a spouse for him.
What does the rib being taken from Adam and free will have ANYTHING to do with one another?


Cowboy....did God ask Adam if he wasn't to give his rib to create his child Eve...if the answer is no....then that is why Adam didn't have any "Free WIll"




God taking one of Adam's ribs didn't cause Adam to do anything though. Again after again, free-will pertains to an action or a thought. God taking one of Adam's ribs did not restrict any action or thought or make Adam do an action or thought. Taking the rib effected Adam's free will not one bit.


Cowboy...your definition of "Free Will" appears to be sort of vague so I decide to pull up one of your previous "Free Will" definitions


POSTED BY COWBOY:

That is all free will is, is the ability to choose what to do

http://mingle2.com/topic/show/307199?page=2... post 11



so now Cowboy going with your definition of "Free Will"....did God give Adam a choice to choose what to do before God put him asleep and took his rib


Again, the rib being taken out of Adam was not an action Adam took. He was not forced to take any action, therefore his free will was not taken away.


nope...you said that Free Will was the ability to choose.....when did Adam get to choose to lose his rib?


Choose as in choose to do something or not do something. The rib being taken out of Adam did not cause him to do an action or restrict him from doing an action. Therefore again, no free will was taken away.


God put Adam to sleep so didn't God take away Adam's ability to choose?


Not specifically. "Sleeping" is not an action one takes. One lays down to sleep, yes this is an action one takes, but one doesn't choose when they "fall" asleep.


And I'm certain it wasn't against Adam's will to be asleep when this happened. I know I personally would absolutely not want to be awake enduring this pain he would have been in.

The only way it would have been taking away Adam's free will or doing something against his will is if he did not want God to do this. We have no information on if he didn't want this to happen. All we know is Adam was a lonely person and wanted someone to share his life with. So with that, God was doing his will and creating a spouse for him.

no photo
Thu 12/01/11 05:11 PM









What does the rib being taken from Adam and free will have ANYTHING to do with one another?


Cowboy....did God ask Adam if he wasn't to give his rib to create his child Eve...if the answer is no....then that is why Adam didn't have any "Free WIll"




God taking one of Adam's ribs didn't cause Adam to do anything though. Again after again, free-will pertains to an action or a thought. God taking one of Adam's ribs did not restrict any action or thought or make Adam do an action or thought. Taking the rib effected Adam's free will not one bit.


Cowboy...your definition of "Free Will" appears to be sort of vague so I decide to pull up one of your previous "Free Will" definitions


POSTED BY COWBOY:

That is all free will is, is the ability to choose what to do

http://mingle2.com/topic/show/307199?page=2... post 11



so now Cowboy going with your definition of "Free Will"....did God give Adam a choice to choose what to do before God put him asleep and took his rib


Again, the rib being taken out of Adam was not an action Adam took. He was not forced to take any action, therefore his free will was not taken away.


nope...you said that Free Will was the ability to choose.....when did Adam get to choose to lose his rib?


Choose as in choose to do something or not do something. The rib being taken out of Adam did not cause him to do an action or restrict him from doing an action. Therefore again, no free will was taken away.


God put Adam to sleep so didn't God take away Adam's ability to choose?


Not specifically. "Sleeping" is not an action one takes. One lays down to sleep, yes this is an action one takes, but one doesn't choose when they "fall" asleep.


Adam didn't put himself to sleep, God was the one that put Adam to sleep beofre he took his rib.....you said that "Free Will" is the ability to choose .....so point out where Adam got to choose

CowboyGH's photo
Thu 12/01/11 05:15 PM










What does the rib being taken from Adam and free will have ANYTHING to do with one another?


Cowboy....did God ask Adam if he wasn't to give his rib to create his child Eve...if the answer is no....then that is why Adam didn't have any "Free WIll"




God taking one of Adam's ribs didn't cause Adam to do anything though. Again after again, free-will pertains to an action or a thought. God taking one of Adam's ribs did not restrict any action or thought or make Adam do an action or thought. Taking the rib effected Adam's free will not one bit.


Cowboy...your definition of "Free Will" appears to be sort of vague so I decide to pull up one of your previous "Free Will" definitions


POSTED BY COWBOY:

That is all free will is, is the ability to choose what to do

http://mingle2.com/topic/show/307199?page=2... post 11



so now Cowboy going with your definition of "Free Will"....did God give Adam a choice to choose what to do before God put him asleep and took his rib


Again, the rib being taken out of Adam was not an action Adam took. He was not forced to take any action, therefore his free will was not taken away.


nope...you said that Free Will was the ability to choose.....when did Adam get to choose to lose his rib?


Choose as in choose to do something or not do something. The rib being taken out of Adam did not cause him to do an action or restrict him from doing an action. Therefore again, no free will was taken away.


God put Adam to sleep so didn't God take away Adam's ability to choose?


Not specifically. "Sleeping" is not an action one takes. One lays down to sleep, yes this is an action one takes, but one doesn't choose when they "fall" asleep.


Adam didn't put himself to sleep, God was the one that put Adam to sleep beofre he took his rib.....you said that "Free Will" is the ability to choose .....so point out where Adam got to choose


Adam wanted a mate and God gave him one. Adam wanting the mate permitted God to do what was needed to bring this to be. Adam didn't put any speculations on how he was to get this mate.

no photo
Thu 12/01/11 05:18 PM
Edited by MorningSong on Thu 12/01/11 06:17 PM




You have a quite interesting view of Christianity MorningSong.

I truly wish all Christianity believed like you do. Then there would be absolutely no need to proselytize or evangelize the religion because only God can draw people in. Evangelizing and proselytizing would be totally futile if that's the case.

And, by the way, I actually feel that your views here make far more sense. I believe that if there is a God who judges people, he certainly wouldn't need the help of proselytizers and/or evangelists.

So I support your view of Christianity MorningSong. It certainly allows for a far more righteous God than a religion that requires proselyting and evangelizing of individuals to believe in something that doesn't make any sense to them.

I accept MorningSongianity. drinker

I reject Cowboyianity. laugh





Abra...when GOD said to GO and TELL the GOOD

NEWS,God meant just that !!!!flowerforyou


Just because God is the One Who does the DRAWING first,, doesn't

mean His Body of Believers are to just Sit on our Blessed

Assurance, and Do Nothing !!!laugh

Amen?!!!



TELLING THE GOOD NEWS ( notice, I did not say arguing, or

discussing ,or pushing the Good News) is for the purpose

of GETTING THE WORD of GOD OUT ....SO PEOPLE CAN HEAR !!!


FAITH comes by HEARING AND HEARING BY THE WORD OF GOD.


FAITH CANNOT COME WITHOUT HEARING THE WORD, AND HEARING ABOUT

GOD....AMEN?


IT'S THE POWER of GOD THAT DRAWS....but GOD ALSO WORKS

THRU HIS WORD GOING FORTH.....TO BRING FORTH FAITH IN GOD.


AGAIN.. ...NO man can come to God on his own....except God DRAW

him first, and CONVICT him of his NEED for a Saviour....

but we ALSO do our part, by TELLING THE GOOD NEWS.


GOD DOES THE DRAWING....BUT THEN FAITH COMES BY HEARING ,AND

HEARING BY THE WORD OF GOD.



flowerforyou:heart:flowerforyou





CowboyGH's photo
Thu 12/01/11 05:28 PM





You have a quite interesting view of Christianity MorningSong.

I truly wish all Christianity believed like you do. Then there would be absolutely no need to proselytize or evangelize the religion because only God can draw people in. Evangelizing and proselytizing would be totally futile if that's the case.

And, by the way, I actually feel that your views here make far more sense. I believe that if there is a God who judges people, he certainly wouldn't need the help of proselytizers and/or evangelists.

So I support your view of Christianity MorningSong. It certainly allows for a far more righteous God than a religion that requires proselyting and evangelizing of individuals to believe in something that doesn't make any sense to them.

I accept MorningSongianity. drinker

I reject Cowboyianity. laugh





Abra...when GOD said to GO and TELL the GOOD

NEWS,God meant just that !!!!flowerforyou


TELLING THE GOOD NEW(notice, I did not say arguing, or

discussing or pushing) is for the purpose of GETTING THE

WORD of GOD OUT ....SO PEOPLE CAN HEAR !!!


FAITH comes by HEARING AND HEARING BY THE WORD OF GOD.


FAITH CANNOT COME WITHOUT HEARING THE WORD, AND HEARING ABOUT

GOD....AMEN?


IT'S THE POWER of GOD THAT DRAWS....but GOD ALSO WORKS

THRU HIS WORD GOING FORTH.....


AGAIN.. ...NO man can come to God on his own....except God DRAW

him first, and CONVICT him of his NEED for a Saviour....

but we ALSO do our part, by TELLING THE GOOD NEWS.



"How sweet are the feet of those who bring GOOD NEWS...


flowerforyou:heart:flowerforyou








FAITH CANNOT COME WITHOUT HEARING THE WORD, AND HEARING ABOUT

GOD....AMEN?


Very true. If they have not heard the word of God, how then can they put faith in it or not? They can't. So out of love, we are to spread the word of God and let God work with the people after they have come to know about God.

no photo
Thu 12/01/11 05:31 PM











What does the rib being taken from Adam and free will have ANYTHING to do with one another?


Cowboy....did God ask Adam if he wasn't to give his rib to create his child Eve...if the answer is no....then that is why Adam didn't have any "Free WIll"




God taking one of Adam's ribs didn't cause Adam to do anything though. Again after again, free-will pertains to an action or a thought. God taking one of Adam's ribs did not restrict any action or thought or make Adam do an action or thought. Taking the rib effected Adam's free will not one bit.


Cowboy...your definition of "Free Will" appears to be sort of vague so I decide to pull up one of your previous "Free Will" definitions


POSTED BY COWBOY:

That is all free will is, is the ability to choose what to do

http://mingle2.com/topic/show/307199?page=2... post 11



so now Cowboy going with your definition of "Free Will"....did God give Adam a choice to choose what to do before God put him asleep and took his rib


Again, the rib being taken out of Adam was not an action Adam took. He was not forced to take any action, therefore his free will was not taken away.


nope...you said that Free Will was the ability to choose.....when did Adam get to choose to lose his rib?


Choose as in choose to do something or not do something. The rib being taken out of Adam did not cause him to do an action or restrict him from doing an action. Therefore again, no free will was taken away.


God put Adam to sleep so didn't God take away Adam's ability to choose?


Not specifically. "Sleeping" is not an action one takes. One lays down to sleep, yes this is an action one takes, but one doesn't choose when they "fall" asleep.


Adam didn't put himself to sleep, God was the one that put Adam to sleep beofre he took his rib.....you said that "Free Will" is the ability to choose .....so point out where Adam got to choose


Adam wanted a mate and God gave him one. Adam wanting the mate permitted God to do what was needed to bring this to be. Adam didn't put any speculations on how he was to get this mate.


nope...Adam didn't put himself to sleep the bible states that God put Adam to sleep,,,also the bible states nothing about Adam wanting a mate...Adam had no clue what a woman or a human mate was since none had been created yet

so again....you said that "Free Will" is the ability to choose .....so point out where Adam got to choose to lose his rib


CowboyGH's photo
Thu 12/01/11 05:35 PM












What does the rib being taken from Adam and free will have ANYTHING to do with one another?


Cowboy....did God ask Adam if he wasn't to give his rib to create his child Eve...if the answer is no....then that is why Adam didn't have any "Free WIll"




God taking one of Adam's ribs didn't cause Adam to do anything though. Again after again, free-will pertains to an action or a thought. God taking one of Adam's ribs did not restrict any action or thought or make Adam do an action or thought. Taking the rib effected Adam's free will not one bit.


Cowboy...your definition of "Free Will" appears to be sort of vague so I decide to pull up one of your previous "Free Will" definitions


POSTED BY COWBOY:

That is all free will is, is the ability to choose what to do

http://mingle2.com/topic/show/307199?page=2... post 11



so now Cowboy going with your definition of "Free Will"....did God give Adam a choice to choose what to do before God put him asleep and took his rib


Again, the rib being taken out of Adam was not an action Adam took. He was not forced to take any action, therefore his free will was not taken away.


nope...you said that Free Will was the ability to choose.....when did Adam get to choose to lose his rib?


Choose as in choose to do something or not do something. The rib being taken out of Adam did not cause him to do an action or restrict him from doing an action. Therefore again, no free will was taken away.


God put Adam to sleep so didn't God take away Adam's ability to choose?


Not specifically. "Sleeping" is not an action one takes. One lays down to sleep, yes this is an action one takes, but one doesn't choose when they "fall" asleep.


Adam didn't put himself to sleep, God was the one that put Adam to sleep beofre he took his rib.....you said that "Free Will" is the ability to choose .....so point out where Adam got to choose


Adam wanted a mate and God gave him one. Adam wanting the mate permitted God to do what was needed to bring this to be. Adam didn't put any speculations on how he was to get this mate.


nope...Adam didn't put himself to sleep the bible states that God put Adam to sleep,,,also the bible states nothing about Adam wanting a mate...Adam had no clue what a woman or a human mate was since none had been created yet

so again....you said that "Free Will" is the ability to choose .....so point out where Adam got to choose to lose his rib




Sure the bible states that Adam was lonely. Why else would God have known it not good for man to be alone? Why would it not have been good if it wasn't cause the man needed companionship. And again, would you rather be awake when God took a rib out? Or would you rather had been in a deep sleep where you didn't feel the pain? Same reason people are put to sleep in operations.

18And the LORD God said, It is not good that the man should be alone; I will make him an help meet for him.

no photo
Thu 12/01/11 05:48 PM
Edited by MorningSong on Thu 12/01/11 06:36 PM
FAITH CANNOT COME WITHOUT HEARING THE WORD, AND HEARING ABOUT

GOD....AMEN?



Very true. If they have not heard the word of God, how then can they put faith in it or not? They can't. So out of love, we are to spread the word of God and let God work with the people after they have come to know about God.





Exactly Cowboy.flowerforyou


Faith Comes by HEARING and HEARING BY THE WORD OF GOD.

NOTICE HOW IT SAYS , HEARING AND HEARING BY THE WORD...

IF THE WORD ISN'T BEING PREACHED SO THAT ONE CAN HEAR THE WORD,

THERE IS NO POWER AT WORK TO CREATE FAITH IN GOD IN THE FIRST

PLACE.

GOD DRAWS, BUT THEN CREATES THE GOD KIND OF FAITH IN US, WHICH

COMES BY THE HEARING OF HIS WORD.


THAT IS WHY GOD'S WORD IS SO POWERFUL.....THEY ARE GOD

INSPIRED , GOD BREATHED .....WORDS THAT WHEN RECEIVED,

ARE ABLE TO BRING FORTH NEW LIFE TO ALL THOSE WHO HEAR.



:heart::heart::heart:






no photo
Thu 12/01/11 05:52 PM













What does the rib being taken from Adam and free will have ANYTHING to do with one another?


Cowboy....did God ask Adam if he wasn't to give his rib to create his child Eve...if the answer is no....then that is why Adam didn't have any "Free WIll"




God taking one of Adam's ribs didn't cause Adam to do anything though. Again after again, free-will pertains to an action or a thought. God taking one of Adam's ribs did not restrict any action or thought or make Adam do an action or thought. Taking the rib effected Adam's free will not one bit.


Cowboy...your definition of "Free Will" appears to be sort of vague so I decide to pull up one of your previous "Free Will" definitions


POSTED BY COWBOY:

That is all free will is, is the ability to choose what to do

http://mingle2.com/topic/show/307199?page=2... post 11



so now Cowboy going with your definition of "Free Will"....did God give Adam a choice to choose what to do before God put him asleep and took his rib


Again, the rib being taken out of Adam was not an action Adam took. He was not forced to take any action, therefore his free will was not taken away.


nope...you said that Free Will was the ability to choose.....when did Adam get to choose to lose his rib?


Choose as in choose to do something or not do something. The rib being taken out of Adam did not cause him to do an action or restrict him from doing an action. Therefore again, no free will was taken away.


God put Adam to sleep so didn't God take away Adam's ability to choose?


Not specifically. "Sleeping" is not an action one takes. One lays down to sleep, yes this is an action one takes, but one doesn't choose when they "fall" asleep.


Adam didn't put himself to sleep, God was the one that put Adam to sleep beofre he took his rib.....you said that "Free Will" is the ability to choose .....so point out where Adam got to choose


Adam wanted a mate and God gave him one. Adam wanting the mate permitted God to do what was needed to bring this to be. Adam didn't put any speculations on how he was to get this mate.


nope...Adam didn't put himself to sleep the bible states that God put Adam to sleep,,,also the bible states nothing about Adam wanting a mate...Adam had no clue what a woman or a human mate was since none had been created yet

so again....you said that "Free Will" is the ability to choose .....so point out where Adam got to choose to lose his rib




Sure the bible states that Adam was lonely. Why else would God have known it not good for man to be alone? Why would it not have been good if it wasn't cause the man needed companionship. And again, would you rather be awake when God took a rib out? Or would you rather had been in a deep sleep where you didn't feel the pain? Same reason people are put to sleep in operations.

18And the LORD God said, It is not good that the man should be alone; I will make him an help meet for him.


the passage you provide states what the Lord said...so far you have provide nothing about what Adam said pertaining to his choice of having or not having his rib taken out....... can you provide such a passage or not

CowboyGH's photo
Thu 12/01/11 05:55 PM














What does the rib being taken from Adam and free will have ANYTHING to do with one another?


Cowboy....did God ask Adam if he wasn't to give his rib to create his child Eve...if the answer is no....then that is why Adam didn't have any "Free WIll"




God taking one of Adam's ribs didn't cause Adam to do anything though. Again after again, free-will pertains to an action or a thought. God taking one of Adam's ribs did not restrict any action or thought or make Adam do an action or thought. Taking the rib effected Adam's free will not one bit.


Cowboy...your definition of "Free Will" appears to be sort of vague so I decide to pull up one of your previous "Free Will" definitions


POSTED BY COWBOY:

That is all free will is, is the ability to choose what to do

http://mingle2.com/topic/show/307199?page=2... post 11



so now Cowboy going with your definition of "Free Will"....did God give Adam a choice to choose what to do before God put him asleep and took his rib


Again, the rib being taken out of Adam was not an action Adam took. He was not forced to take any action, therefore his free will was not taken away.


nope...you said that Free Will was the ability to choose.....when did Adam get to choose to lose his rib?


Choose as in choose to do something or not do something. The rib being taken out of Adam did not cause him to do an action or restrict him from doing an action. Therefore again, no free will was taken away.


God put Adam to sleep so didn't God take away Adam's ability to choose?


Not specifically. "Sleeping" is not an action one takes. One lays down to sleep, yes this is an action one takes, but one doesn't choose when they "fall" asleep.


Adam didn't put himself to sleep, God was the one that put Adam to sleep beofre he took his rib.....you said that "Free Will" is the ability to choose .....so point out where Adam got to choose


Adam wanted a mate and God gave him one. Adam wanting the mate permitted God to do what was needed to bring this to be. Adam didn't put any speculations on how he was to get this mate.


nope...Adam didn't put himself to sleep the bible states that God put Adam to sleep,,,also the bible states nothing about Adam wanting a mate...Adam had no clue what a woman or a human mate was since none had been created yet

so again....you said that "Free Will" is the ability to choose .....so point out where Adam got to choose to lose his rib




Sure the bible states that Adam was lonely. Why else would God have known it not good for man to be alone? Why would it not have been good if it wasn't cause the man needed companionship. And again, would you rather be awake when God took a rib out? Or would you rather had been in a deep sleep where you didn't feel the pain? Same reason people are put to sleep in operations.

18And the LORD God said, It is not good that the man should be alone; I will make him an help meet for him.


the passage you provide states what the Lord said...so far you have provide nothing about what Adam said pertaining to his choice of having or not having his rib taken out....... can you provide such a passage or not


Why do you think the LORD would say such a thing if Adam didn't want a mate?

The LORD knows what we want, regardless if we have publicly said it, said it to one other, or even said it at all. God knows our hearts.

no photo
Thu 12/01/11 06:08 PM
Edited by funches on Thu 12/01/11 06:09 PM















What does the rib being taken from Adam and free will have ANYTHING to do with one another?


Cowboy....did God ask Adam if he wasn't to give his rib to create his child Eve...if the answer is no....then that is why Adam didn't have any "Free WIll"




God taking one of Adam's ribs didn't cause Adam to do anything though. Again after again, free-will pertains to an action or a thought. God taking one of Adam's ribs did not restrict any action or thought or make Adam do an action or thought. Taking the rib effected Adam's free will not one bit.


Cowboy...your definition of "Free Will" appears to be sort of vague so I decide to pull up one of your previous "Free Will" definitions


POSTED BY COWBOY:

That is all free will is, is the ability to choose what to do

http://mingle2.com/topic/show/307199?page=2... post 11



so now Cowboy going with your definition of "Free Will"....did God give Adam a choice to choose what to do before God put him asleep and took his rib


Again, the rib being taken out of Adam was not an action Adam took. He was not forced to take any action, therefore his free will was not taken away.


nope...you said that Free Will was the ability to choose.....when did Adam get to choose to lose his rib?


Choose as in choose to do something or not do something. The rib being taken out of Adam did not cause him to do an action or restrict him from doing an action. Therefore again, no free will was taken away.


God put Adam to sleep so didn't God take away Adam's ability to choose?


Not specifically. "Sleeping" is not an action one takes. One lays down to sleep, yes this is an action one takes, but one doesn't choose when they "fall" asleep.


Adam didn't put himself to sleep, God was the one that put Adam to sleep beofre he took his rib.....you said that "Free Will" is the ability to choose .....so point out where Adam got to choose


Adam wanted a mate and God gave him one. Adam wanting the mate permitted God to do what was needed to bring this to be. Adam didn't put any speculations on how he was to get this mate.


nope...Adam didn't put himself to sleep the bible states that God put Adam to sleep,,,also the bible states nothing about Adam wanting a mate...Adam had no clue what a woman or a human mate was since none had been created yet

so again....you said that "Free Will" is the ability to choose .....so point out where Adam got to choose to lose his rib




Sure the bible states that Adam was lonely. Why else would God have known it not good for man to be alone? Why would it not have been good if it wasn't cause the man needed companionship. And again, would you rather be awake when God took a rib out? Or would you rather had been in a deep sleep where you didn't feel the pain? Same reason people are put to sleep in operations.

18And the LORD God said, It is not good that the man should be alone; I will make him an help meet for him.


the passage you provide states what the Lord said...so far you have provide nothing about what Adam said pertaining to his choice of having or not having his rib taken out....... can you provide such a passage or not


Why do you think the LORD would say such a thing if Adam didn't want a mate?

The LORD knows what we want, regardless if we have publicly said it, said it to one other, or even said it at all. God knows our hearts.


you keep telling about God's "Free Will"..I've ask you to provide a passage where Adam had the Free Will" to choose pertaining to his rib being taken out

can you provide this passage or not ...if you can't ....then simply admit it

CowboyGH's photo
Thu 12/01/11 06:13 PM
















What does the rib being taken from Adam and free will have ANYTHING to do with one another?


Cowboy....did God ask Adam if he wasn't to give his rib to create his child Eve...if the answer is no....then that is why Adam didn't have any "Free WIll"




God taking one of Adam's ribs didn't cause Adam to do anything though. Again after again, free-will pertains to an action or a thought. God taking one of Adam's ribs did not restrict any action or thought or make Adam do an action or thought. Taking the rib effected Adam's free will not one bit.


Cowboy...your definition of "Free Will" appears to be sort of vague so I decide to pull up one of your previous "Free Will" definitions


POSTED BY COWBOY:

That is all free will is, is the ability to choose what to do

http://mingle2.com/topic/show/307199?page=2... post 11



so now Cowboy going with your definition of "Free Will"....did God give Adam a choice to choose what to do before God put him asleep and took his rib


Again, the rib being taken out of Adam was not an action Adam took. He was not forced to take any action, therefore his free will was not taken away.


nope...you said that Free Will was the ability to choose.....when did Adam get to choose to lose his rib?


Choose as in choose to do something or not do something. The rib being taken out of Adam did not cause him to do an action or restrict him from doing an action. Therefore again, no free will was taken away.


God put Adam to sleep so didn't God take away Adam's ability to choose?


Not specifically. "Sleeping" is not an action one takes. One lays down to sleep, yes this is an action one takes, but one doesn't choose when they "fall" asleep.


Adam didn't put himself to sleep, God was the one that put Adam to sleep beofre he took his rib.....you said that "Free Will" is the ability to choose .....so point out where Adam got to choose


Adam wanted a mate and God gave him one. Adam wanting the mate permitted God to do what was needed to bring this to be. Adam didn't put any speculations on how he was to get this mate.


nope...Adam didn't put himself to sleep the bible states that God put Adam to sleep,,,also the bible states nothing about Adam wanting a mate...Adam had no clue what a woman or a human mate was since none had been created yet

so again....you said that "Free Will" is the ability to choose .....so point out where Adam got to choose to lose his rib




Sure the bible states that Adam was lonely. Why else would God have known it not good for man to be alone? Why would it not have been good if it wasn't cause the man needed companionship. And again, would you rather be awake when God took a rib out? Or would you rather had been in a deep sleep where you didn't feel the pain? Same reason people are put to sleep in operations.

18And the LORD God said, It is not good that the man should be alone; I will make him an help meet for him.


the passage you provide states what the Lord said...so far you have provide nothing about what Adam said pertaining to his choice of having or not having his rib taken out....... can you provide such a passage or not


Why do you think the LORD would say such a thing if Adam didn't want a mate?

The LORD knows what we want, regardless if we have publicly said it, said it to one other, or even said it at all. God knows our hearts.


you keep telling about God's "Free Will"..I've ask you to provide a passage where Adam had the Free Will" to choose pertaining to his rib being taken out

can you provide this passage or not ...if you can't ....then simply admit it


Your body is not your own. Your body is the temple of God. It belongs to God, he can do with it what he wishes.

CowboyGH's photo
Thu 12/01/11 06:14 PM

















What does the rib being taken from Adam and free will have ANYTHING to do with one another?


Cowboy....did God ask Adam if he wasn't to give his rib to create his child Eve...if the answer is no....then that is why Adam didn't have any "Free WIll"




God taking one of Adam's ribs didn't cause Adam to do anything though. Again after again, free-will pertains to an action or a thought. God taking one of Adam's ribs did not restrict any action or thought or make Adam do an action or thought. Taking the rib effected Adam's free will not one bit.


Cowboy...your definition of "Free Will" appears to be sort of vague so I decide to pull up one of your previous "Free Will" definitions


POSTED BY COWBOY:

That is all free will is, is the ability to choose what to do

http://mingle2.com/topic/show/307199?page=2... post 11



so now Cowboy going with your definition of "Free Will"....did God give Adam a choice to choose what to do before God put him asleep and took his rib


Again, the rib being taken out of Adam was not an action Adam took. He was not forced to take any action, therefore his free will was not taken away.


nope...you said that Free Will was the ability to choose.....when did Adam get to choose to lose his rib?


Choose as in choose to do something or not do something. The rib being taken out of Adam did not cause him to do an action or restrict him from doing an action. Therefore again, no free will was taken away.


God put Adam to sleep so didn't God take away Adam's ability to choose?


Not specifically. "Sleeping" is not an action one takes. One lays down to sleep, yes this is an action one takes, but one doesn't choose when they "fall" asleep.


Adam didn't put himself to sleep, God was the one that put Adam to sleep beofre he took his rib.....you said that "Free Will" is the ability to choose .....so point out where Adam got to choose


Adam wanted a mate and God gave him one. Adam wanting the mate permitted God to do what was needed to bring this to be. Adam didn't put any speculations on how he was to get this mate.


nope...Adam didn't put himself to sleep the bible states that God put Adam to sleep,,,also the bible states nothing about Adam wanting a mate...Adam had no clue what a woman or a human mate was since none had been created yet

so again....you said that "Free Will" is the ability to choose .....so point out where Adam got to choose to lose his rib




Sure the bible states that Adam was lonely. Why else would God have known it not good for man to be alone? Why would it not have been good if it wasn't cause the man needed companionship. And again, would you rather be awake when God took a rib out? Or would you rather had been in a deep sleep where you didn't feel the pain? Same reason people are put to sleep in operations.

18And the LORD God said, It is not good that the man should be alone; I will make him an help meet for him.


the passage you provide states what the Lord said...so far you have provide nothing about what Adam said pertaining to his choice of having or not having his rib taken out....... can you provide such a passage or not


Why do you think the LORD would say such a thing if Adam didn't want a mate?

The LORD knows what we want, regardless if we have publicly said it, said it to one other, or even said it at all. God knows our hearts.


you keep telling about God's "Free Will"..I've ask you to provide a passage where Adam had the Free Will" to choose pertaining to his rib being taken out

can you provide this passage or not ...if you can't ....then simply admit it


Your body is not your own. Your body is the temple of God. It belongs to God, he can do with it what he wishes.


He created it, so it is his privilege to change it, alter it, destroy it, renew it, or do whatever he wishes with it.

CowboyGH's photo
Thu 12/01/11 06:16 PM
Edited by CowboyGH on Thu 12/01/11 06:17 PM


















What does the rib being taken from Adam and free will have ANYTHING to do with one another?


Cowboy....did God ask Adam if he wasn't to give his rib to create his child Eve...if the answer is no....then that is why Adam didn't have any "Free WIll"




God taking one of Adam's ribs didn't cause Adam to do anything though. Again after again, free-will pertains to an action or a thought. God taking one of Adam's ribs did not restrict any action or thought or make Adam do an action or thought. Taking the rib effected Adam's free will not one bit.


Cowboy...your definition of "Free Will" appears to be sort of vague so I decide to pull up one of your previous "Free Will" definitions


POSTED BY COWBOY:

That is all free will is, is the ability to choose what to do

http://mingle2.com/topic/show/307199?page=2... post 11



so now Cowboy going with your definition of "Free Will"....did God give Adam a choice to choose what to do before God put him asleep and took his rib


Again, the rib being taken out of Adam was not an action Adam took. He was not forced to take any action, therefore his free will was not taken away.


nope...you said that Free Will was the ability to choose.....when did Adam get to choose to lose his rib?


Choose as in choose to do something or not do something. The rib being taken out of Adam did not cause him to do an action or restrict him from doing an action. Therefore again, no free will was taken away.


God put Adam to sleep so didn't God take away Adam's ability to choose?


Not specifically. "Sleeping" is not an action one takes. One lays down to sleep, yes this is an action one takes, but one doesn't choose when they "fall" asleep.


Adam didn't put himself to sleep, God was the one that put Adam to sleep beofre he took his rib.....you said that "Free Will" is the ability to choose .....so point out where Adam got to choose


Adam wanted a mate and God gave him one. Adam wanting the mate permitted God to do what was needed to bring this to be. Adam didn't put any speculations on how he was to get this mate.


nope...Adam didn't put himself to sleep the bible states that God put Adam to sleep,,,also the bible states nothing about Adam wanting a mate...Adam had no clue what a woman or a human mate was since none had been created yet

so again....you said that "Free Will" is the ability to choose .....so point out where Adam got to choose to lose his rib




Sure the bible states that Adam was lonely. Why else would God have known it not good for man to be alone? Why would it not have been good if it wasn't cause the man needed companionship. And again, would you rather be awake when God took a rib out? Or would you rather had been in a deep sleep where you didn't feel the pain? Same reason people are put to sleep in operations.

18And the LORD God said, It is not good that the man should be alone; I will make him an help meet for him.


the passage you provide states what the Lord said...so far you have provide nothing about what Adam said pertaining to his choice of having or not having his rib taken out....... can you provide such a passage or not


Why do you think the LORD would say such a thing if Adam didn't want a mate?

The LORD knows what we want, regardless if we have publicly said it, said it to one other, or even said it at all. God knows our hearts.


you keep telling about God's "Free Will"..I've ask you to provide a passage where Adam had the Free Will" to choose pertaining to his rib being taken out

can you provide this passage or not ...if you can't ....then simply admit it


Your body is not your own. Your body is the temple of God. It belongs to God, he can do with it what he wishes.


He created it, so it is his privilege to change it, alter it, destroy it, renew it, or do whatever he wishes with it.


1 Corinthians 6:19-20

19What? know ye not that your body is the temple of the Holy Ghost which is in you, which ye have of God, and ye are not your own?

20For ye are bought with a price: therefore glorify God in your body, and in your spirit, which are God's.

no photo
Thu 12/01/11 06:26 PM



















What does the rib being taken from Adam and free will have ANYTHING to do with one another?


Cowboy....did God ask Adam if he wasn't to give his rib to create his child Eve...if the answer is no....then that is why Adam didn't have any "Free WIll"




God taking one of Adam's ribs didn't cause Adam to do anything though. Again after again, free-will pertains to an action or a thought. God taking one of Adam's ribs did not restrict any action or thought or make Adam do an action or thought. Taking the rib effected Adam's free will not one bit.


Cowboy...your definition of "Free Will" appears to be sort of vague so I decide to pull up one of your previous "Free Will" definitions


POSTED BY COWBOY:

That is all free will is, is the ability to choose what to do

http://mingle2.com/topic/show/307199?page=2... post 11



so now Cowboy going with your definition of "Free Will"....did God give Adam a choice to choose what to do before God put him asleep and took his rib


Again, the rib being taken out of Adam was not an action Adam took. He was not forced to take any action, therefore his free will was not taken away.


nope...you said that Free Will was the ability to choose.....when did Adam get to choose to lose his rib?


Choose as in choose to do something or not do something. The rib being taken out of Adam did not cause him to do an action or restrict him from doing an action. Therefore again, no free will was taken away.


God put Adam to sleep so didn't God take away Adam's ability to choose?


Not specifically. "Sleeping" is not an action one takes. One lays down to sleep, yes this is an action one takes, but one doesn't choose when they "fall" asleep.


Adam didn't put himself to sleep, God was the one that put Adam to sleep beofre he took his rib.....you said that "Free Will" is the ability to choose .....so point out where Adam got to choose


Adam wanted a mate and God gave him one. Adam wanting the mate permitted God to do what was needed to bring this to be. Adam didn't put any speculations on how he was to get this mate.


nope...Adam didn't put himself to sleep the bible states that God put Adam to sleep,,,also the bible states nothing about Adam wanting a mate...Adam had no clue what a woman or a human mate was since none had been created yet

so again....you said that "Free Will" is the ability to choose .....so point out where Adam got to choose to lose his rib




Sure the bible states that Adam was lonely. Why else would God have known it not good for man to be alone? Why would it not have been good if it wasn't cause the man needed companionship. And again, would you rather be awake when God took a rib out? Or would you rather had been in a deep sleep where you didn't feel the pain? Same reason people are put to sleep in operations.

18And the LORD God said, It is not good that the man should be alone; I will make him an help meet for him.


the passage you provide states what the Lord said...so far you have provide nothing about what Adam said pertaining to his choice of having or not having his rib taken out....... can you provide such a passage or not


Why do you think the LORD would say such a thing if Adam didn't want a mate?

The LORD knows what we want, regardless if we have publicly said it, said it to one other, or even said it at all. God knows our hearts.


you keep telling about God's "Free Will"..I've ask you to provide a passage where Adam had the Free Will" to choose pertaining to his rib being taken out

can you provide this passage or not ...if you can't ....then simply admit it


Your body is not your own. Your body is the temple of God. It belongs to God, he can do with it what he wishes.


He created it, so it is his privilege to change it, alter it, destroy it, renew it, or do whatever he wishes with it.


1 Corinthians 6:19-20

19What? know ye not that your body is the temple of the Holy Ghost which is in you, which ye have of God, and ye are not your own?

20For ye are bought with a price: therefore glorify God in your body, and in your spirit, which are God's.


Cowboy,...you keep providing passages pertaining to God's "Free Will"... I'm not disputing that God has "Free WIll" ...

I'm disputing that God gave "Free Will" to Adam pertaining to the taking of his rib and asked you to provide a passage where Adam had any choice in the matter ...

so once again can you provide such a passage ....and if not....grow a pair and admit it

Abracadabra's photo
Thu 12/01/11 06:33 PM
Cowboy wrote:

He created it, so it is his privilege to change it, alter it, destroy it, renew it, or do whatever he wishes with it.


No Cowboy you're wrong.

A religion that claims to have a "righteous" God has limited their God to only be able to do what is "righteous". Otherwise, it would be an "unrighteous" God.

This is a common pitfall that Christians all too often fall into. They act like their supposed "righteous" God can do anything at all that he wishes to do, with nothing restraining him. But that's false. A God who is not restricted by doing only that which is "righteous", cannot be said to be a "righteous" God.

Since the Christians demand that their God is a "righteous" God, then they must also limit their God to only being "righteous".

Now the Greek Zeus, on the other hand could kill you for no good reason. No one claimed that he had to be "righteous" or anything else. They just recognized that he is God and can therefore do anything he so desires, whether it's "righteous" or not.

The Greek God of Zeus was truly unlimited.

But this is not true of the God of Bible. The God of the Bible is restricted by "righteousness" and therefore cannot do "unrighteous" things.

The Biblical God is not free to do whatever he wishes without any need to excuse himself. Because he would then be an "unrighteous" God, but that flies in the face of what the Bible claims God to be.

So you're not paying attention.

You preach total falsehoods that simply cannot be supported by the Bible.

You can't have the Biblical God going around doing "unrighteous" things simply because he can do anything he wises.

He is NOT Zeus!

He doesn't have that kind of freedom.

He's restricted by the character trait of being "righteous".

In fact, if there is anything in the Bible that this God has done that is "unrighteous" then that is a valid reason to question the validity of this religion. And many people, including myself, seem many of the things that this God has done according to the biblical stories as being totally "unrighteous" and thus we have grounds for rejecting the stories as fables because the stories fail to support the premise that this God is supposed to be "righteous".

If you want a God who can do anything without having to excuse himself, you need to turn to Zeus. Because the Biblical God does not have that freedom. The Biblical God is a limited God. He is limited by his very character trait of being a "righteous" God.

He cannot just do anything he so desires, as you suggest.

That's false.

Unless you are rejecting the ideal that he's a "righteous" God.

But then you'd have a religion with an unrighteous God, and you'd be right back with the Greeks and Zeus.