Topic: My Challenge to Creationists
Seamonster's photo
Thu 11/27/08 07:50 PM




realy? because he has killed thoughout the bible.
Do you want actual scripture? because I can show you god killing many many many times.
And ordering others to kill.


I bet everyone involved in those killings had a hard heart against God or were otherwise evil. So in essence, they didn't choose God. And since He could see they never would.. He was probably just taking them out of the way so that He could help those who DID choose Him.


realy even the old man that god commanded to be stoned to death because he was picking up sticks on the sabbath?
Of the childern that god had torn apart by bears because thay made fun of a bald guy?
I'm sorry but he's just not a nice guy no matter how you spin it.

no photo
Thu 11/27/08 07:58 PM

ok so answer me this does god have the knowledge of wether we are going to go to hell or not before we are even born?
if not then how is he all knowing.
and if so then he creates people with the foreknolledge that they will go to hell.
and how is that not cruel?


Life is a gift from God. When our life begins (as in when the sperm and egg unite) we are given a life. At the moment we begin to live, God knows our entire life from beginning to end.

So say God creates Hitler and realizes what Hitler is going to do. Does God destroy Hitler? No, because Hitler is just a little baby, he's innocent. God doesn't punish the innocent. Besides, God couldn't kill baby Hitler without changing events of which God was already aware. Paradox, remember? So baby Hitler gets his chance at life to live, love and make mistakes. In the end, Hitler will be punished according to his actions.

God isn't "all knowing". God knows everything that has, is or will happen. If something will never happen, God doesn't know about it.

Overcoming paradox isn't a matter of power. A paradox cannot exist, therefore God cannot create a paradox. In 1909, God knew the Holocaust would happen, but ONLY because the Holocaust was going to happen. God cannot change what he knows will happen.

Skad's photo
Thu 11/27/08 07:59 PM
As for those who were killed, only God can see the heart; past present and future.

At any rate, Seamonster, and Abra for that matter.. I can't speak for any other Creationists or Christians, but I'm not out to prove anything to you.

The Bible says I'll be held accountable for people I hold the truth from. But it also says that if I try and the truth is not accepted, I'm supposed to kick the dust from my shoes (walk away, forget about it).

So, I've spoken the truth, and now I'll leave you with your own choice to make.

Seamonster's photo
Thu 11/27/08 08:23 PM


ok so answer me this does god have the knowledge of wether we are going to go to hell or not before we are even born?
if not then how is he all knowing.
and if so then he creates people with the foreknolledge that they will go to hell.
and how is that not cruel?


Life is a gift from God. When our life begins (as in when the sperm and egg unite) we are given a life. At the moment we begin to live, God knows our entire life from beginning to end.

So say God creates Hitler and realizes what Hitler is going to do. Does God destroy Hitler? No, because Hitler is just a little baby, he's innocent. God doesn't punish the innocent. Besides, God couldn't kill baby Hitler without changing events of which God was already aware. Paradox, remember? So baby Hitler gets his chance at life to live, love and make mistakes. In the end, Hitler will be punished according to his actions.

God isn't "all knowing". God knows everything that has, is or will happen. If something will never happen, God doesn't know about it.

Overcoming paradox isn't a matter of power. A paradox cannot exist, therefore God cannot create a paradox. In 1909, God knew the Holocaust would happen, but ONLY because the Holocaust was going to happen. God cannot change what he knows will happen.


I see your point and either it makes sense or I'm tierd, either way I can't or should'nt rebut until tomorrow when I'm brain fresh.

Seamonster's photo
Thu 11/27/08 08:26 PM

As for those who were killed, only God can see the heart; past present and future.

At any rate, Seamonster, and Abra for that matter.. I can't speak for any other Creationists or Christians, but I'm not out to prove anything to you.

The Bible says I'll be held accountable for people I hold the truth from. But it also says that if I try and the truth is not accepted, I'm supposed to kick the dust from my shoes (walk away, forget about it).

So, I've spoken the truth, and now I'll leave you with your own choice to make.


so he kills children and you say well they may have been wicked children.

yeah ok
yes, this is dust you realy should kick off.
There is no defence for the slaughter of children and it's incredible that you would even try.

martymark's photo
Thu 11/27/08 11:27 PM
Edited by martymark on Thu 11/27/08 11:35 PM
Well, I can see not much has changed around here. I'd ask why, but why ask why, especially when I know the answere already. You guys/gals enjoy. When you come up with a way to actually prove anything about the orgin of man, please start a new thread stating so, Thanks, see ya! PS: where the hell do people, even those who wrote the "Bible", get the idea that God kills anyone! this is just a bunch of crap. This is a perfect example of why Jesus made his first appearance on earth, to try and get people to quit lying about things. They killed him instead of quiting the lying, hell man, they even lied to get the job done of killing him. When anyone out there in the world is ready to take on the position of being able to judge what is a lie and what is not, you be sure and let me know. I will be the first to go to bat for you. Otherwise keep your silly ass opinions in the right context, that they are just opinions, creationism and evolutionism alike!

no photo
Fri 11/28/08 11:00 AM
An ounce of truth withstands time.

At first the strong ruled the earth until the weak invented the gun which made the weak stronger. Then the brains ruled the earth. Thou say not steal thou shall not murder. Guns are bad.

Is conscience taught or is it something we are born with?

Conscience Vs. Survival of the fittest.

------------
I'll add to the above.

According to Paul God had chosen His people before the foundation of the world (Ephesians 1:3-4)

According to Jesus these chosen where in Heaven before there fleshly birth. (John 17:15-19)

Job also explains (Job 4- Where wast thou when I laid the foundations of the earth? declare, if thou hast understanding......

According to Paul's writings either you where born with the Spirit of God or you wheren't. ex. (Romans 8:9)

According to Jesus "I pray for them: I pray not for the world", "But ye believe not, because ye are not of my sheep..."

------------

Eljay's photo
Fri 11/28/08 03:20 PM



Ir someone is going to push for something to be taught in school, or even want it to be takin seriously at all they should be able to show some evidence of it.


Then please explain to me why Evolution is taught in schools? The only evidence we have is of fossel records. No proof what-so-ever of the origin of those fossels - just a theory of it.

So - why shouldn't both ID and Evolution be taught in schools for what they are - theories, and let the student decide for themselves whether or not they wish to pursue further studies.


ID is not a theory. It is not science, and should not be taught in a science class.
If they want to teach it in a class that deals with mythology ok, but it's not science.
ID is just a way to sneek religion into the classrooms. ID ends debate and thought, it makes people stupid.
If you just say that we got here becouse an outside sorce put us here then thats it we do not need to go any farther.
Eveolution is as sound a theory as the earth revolving around the sun, it does not disprove a god, you can't prove a negitive.



Nonsense. There is no more "evidence" of the validity of evolution as an eplination of the origin of the species than there is of the account of Genesis. Every "stated fact" you could presume to offer to support "Evolution" as a viable science stands in support of ID as well. Plain and simple - you can do no more to disprove ID than you will ever be able to "prove" evolution. Stop claiming it as "fact" - there is nothing factual about "evolution" as an origin of species. There is so much evidence that disproves it - that it makes the discussion about it moot.

Attempt if you will to explain to me how hummingbirds have survived given "evolutionary fact".

Then think about Giraffes - after that move on to firefly's - then woodpeckers - the list goes on and on. The fact of the matter is that there isn't an evolutionist on the planet who can explain how the woodpecker managed to develop it's anatomy, let alone how it has survived.

Wake up - and realize that you have swallowed a myth. You believe it is "fact" because somewhere in some classroom you were told that it is - witohut the semblence of any evidence or proof to support it. You were certainly not introduced to the "difficulties" with evolutionary theory. Those creatures which defy evolution by their mere existance.

Seamonster's photo
Fri 11/28/08 03:37 PM




Ir someone is going to push for something to be taught in school, or even want it to be takin seriously at all they should be able to show some evidence of it.


Then please explain to me why Evolution is taught in schools? The only evidence we have is of fossel records. No proof what-so-ever of the origin of those fossels - just a theory of it.

So - why shouldn't both ID and Evolution be taught in schools for what they are - theories, and let the student decide for themselves whether or not they wish to pursue further studies.


ID is not a theory. It is not science, and should not be taught in a science class.
If they want to teach it in a class that deals with mythology ok, but it's not science.
ID is just a way to sneek religion into the classrooms. ID ends debate and thought, it makes people stupid.
If you just say that we got here becouse an outside sorce put us here then thats it we do not need to go any farther.
Eveolution is as sound a theory as the earth revolving around the sun, it does not disprove a god, you can't prove a negitive.



Nonsense. There is no more "evidence" of the validity of evolution as an eplination of the origin of the species than there is of the account of Genesis. Every "stated fact" you could presume to offer to support "Evolution" as a viable science stands in support of ID as well. Plain and simple - you can do no more to disprove ID than you will ever be able to "prove" evolution. Stop claiming it as "fact" - there is nothing factual about "evolution" as an origin of species. There is so much evidence that disproves it - that it makes the discussion about it moot.

Attempt if you will to explain to me how hummingbirds have survived given "evolutionary fact".

Then think about Giraffes - after that move on to firefly's - then woodpeckers - the list goes on and on. The fact of the matter is that there isn't an evolutionist on the planet who can explain how the woodpecker managed to develop it's anatomy, let alone how it has survived.

Wake up - and realize that you have swallowed a myth. You believe it is "fact" because somewhere in some classroom you were told that it is - witohut the semblence of any evidence or proof to support it. You were certainly not introduced to the "difficulties" with evolutionary theory. Those creatures which defy evolution by their mere existance.



wrong,

There is evidence of evolution.

There is 0 evidence of an invisible magic man.

Evolution is not even debated in the scientific community.
How evolution works is, but evolution itself is not, (except maybe amungst televangalists looking for a buck).
There is as much evidence of the god poseidon ruling the ocean as there is for the biblical god.


Krimsa's photo
Fri 11/28/08 05:27 PM


Ir someone is going to push for something to be taught in school, or even want it to be takin seriously at all they should be able to show some evidence of it.


school - i can see your point.

adults? how can you prove whats taken on faith?


you either believe in whats stated as proof or not, and follow it or not.


it's been debated to death on here, no one wins - you can not debate FAITH vs SCIENCE and have a definitive outcome. sorry.


Are you joking? Its been debated to death but it basically comes down to the proponents of the theory of evolution have a SUBSTANTIAL amount of credible evidence to support it's claims.

What have the Creationists been able to show Sam?

Not a dam thing. You are confusing their whining and faith based beliefs in mythology as fact.

Pfft.

tribo's photo
Fri 11/28/08 06:56 PM




ok so answer me this does god have the knowledge of wether we are going to go to hell or not before we are even born?
if not then how is he all knowing.
and if so then he creates people with the foreknolledge that they will go to hell.
and how is that not cruel?


Life is a gift from God. When our life begins (as in when the sperm and egg unite) we are given a life. At the moment we begin to live, God knows our entire life from beginning to end.

So say God creates Hitler and realizes what Hitler is going to do. Does God destroy Hitler? No, because Hitler is just a little baby, he's innocent. God doesn't punish the innocent. Besides, God couldn't kill baby Hitler without changing events of which God was already aware. Paradox, remember? So baby Hitler gets his chance at life to live, love and make mistakes. In the end, Hitler will be punished according to his actions.

God isn't "all knowing". God knows everything that has, is or will happen. If something will never happen, God doesn't know about it.

Overcoming paradox isn't a matter of power. A paradox cannot exist, therefore God cannot create a paradox. In 1909, God knew the Holocaust would happen, but ONLY because the Holocaust was going to happen. God cannot change what he knows will happen.


then he is "finite" and not worthy to be called god or worshipped as god.

And yet he interferes throughout the old testament - that's ignorant spider - you cant say he can interfere with Pharaoh and other kings and rulers and other peoples and then turn around and state he cant interfere with Hitler- WTF??

he "knew what Pharaoh would do when he grew up supposedly, and the others also and the ways of Sodom and Gomorrah and the tribes he destroyed [Canaanites etc..] yet you say he was powerless to interfere with Hitler or Mussolini or Japan, or Korea or Vietnam or or now - BS!!

martymark's photo
Fri 11/28/08 07:01 PM
Hey sea, maybe God does what he does just to piss you off. Maybe it's to get you to think. why ever he does what he does I'm sure it's all about you!

tribo's photo
Fri 11/28/08 07:06 PM



Ir someone is going to push for something to be taught in school, or even want it to be takin seriously at all they should be able to show some evidence of it.


school - i can see your point.

adults? how can you prove whats taken on faith?


you either believe in whats stated as proof or not, and follow it or not.


it's been debated to death on here, no one wins - you can not debate FAITH vs SCIENCE and have a definitive outcome. sorry.


Are you joking? Its been debated to death but it basically comes down to the proponents of the theory of evolution have a SUBSTANTIAL amount of credible evidence to support it's claims.

What have the Creationists been able to show Sam?

Not a dam thing. You are confusing their whining and faith based beliefs in mythology as fact.

Pfft.


i agree - what i should have said is it will never change anyone's mind no matter how much evidence or lack there of is posted it always ends with no clear gain for either side. and it continues ad nauseum - is that better?

Krimsa's photo
Fri 11/28/08 07:06 PM
Getting back on topic here, how do you religious folks explain the similarities in genetic profiles between humans and chimpanzees if its all so terribly random as you seem to feel confident in proclaiming?

Krimsa's photo
Fri 11/28/08 07:11 PM
Edited by Krimsa on Fri 11/28/08 07:12 PM




Ir someone is going to push for something to be taught in school, or even want it to be takin seriously at all they should be able to show some evidence of it.


school - i can see your point.

adults? how can you prove whats taken on faith?


you either believe in whats stated as proof or not, and follow it or not.


it's been debated to death on here, no one wins - you can not debate FAITH vs SCIENCE and have a definitive outcome. sorry.


Are you joking? Its been debated to death but it basically comes down to the proponents of the theory of evolution have a SUBSTANTIAL amount of credible evidence to support it's claims.

What have the Creationists been able to show Sam?

Not a dam thing. You are confusing their whining and faith based beliefs in mythology as fact.

Pfft.


i agree - what i should have said is it will never change anyone's mind no matter how much evidence or lack there of is posted it always ends with no clear gain for either side. and it continues ad nauseum - is that better?


No need to get snippy. I know that you personally do not believe in the theory of evolution and you are somewhat resentful of the concept for whatever reason. You have expressed that to me in the past. So clearly your views of "who's evidence is more factual" is going to be askew.

You can simply deny the data yet that wont somehow render it unsubstantiated. I could believe that I am a vampire and no amount of convincing will dissuade me from that belief. The same would apply here.

tribo's photo
Fri 11/28/08 07:13 PM

Getting back on topic here, how do you religious folks explain the similarities in genetic profiles between humans and chimpanzees if its all so terribly random as you seem to feel confident in proclaiming?


laugh laugh laugh laugh

boy it must be really hard for you to want to debate what you know so well and nobody to debate it with huh? your just chomping at the bit to get into it laugh

oh well - maybe some unknowing newbie will wander into your web and get eaten alive ??? is that before or after sex? i dont remember - laugh

tribo's photo
Fri 11/28/08 07:19 PM
Edited by tribo on Fri 11/28/08 07:38 PM





Ir someone is going to push for something to be taught in school, or even want it to be takin seriously at all they should be able to show some evidence of it.


school - i can see your point.

adults? how can you prove whats taken on faith?


you either believe in whats stated as proof or not, and follow it or not.


it's been debated to death on here, no one wins - you can not debate FAITH vs SCIENCE and have a definitive outcome. sorry.


Are you joking? Its been debated to death but it basically comes down to the proponents of the theory of evolution have a SUBSTANTIAL amount of credible evidence to support it's claims.

What have the Creationists been able to show Sam?

Not a dam thing. You are confusing their whining and faith based beliefs in mythology as fact.

Pfft.


i agree - what i should have said is it will never change anyone's mind no matter how much evidence or lack there of is posted it always ends with no clear gain for either side. and it continues ad nauseum - is that better?


No need to get snippy. I know that you personally do not believe in the theory of evolution and you are somewhat resentful of the concept for whatever reason. You have expressed that to me in the past. So clearly your views of "who's evidence is more factual" is going to be askew.

You can simply deny the data yet that wont somehow render it unsubstantiated. I could believe that I am a vampire and no amount of convincing will dissuade me from that belief. The same would apply here.


snippy? - amazing what people read into another's words huh? i think that's why things at times get so heated on here - it happens to/with me also. but no my lady no "snipping was meant or intended - nor do i consider your thoughts less than mine or anyone Else's. and you surely hold the upper hand when it comes to evolution. i would not dare challenge you, that would be pointless.

although from eljays post above maybe he's up for the challenge!! he seems rather sure of himself on this topic. - laugh :tongue:

Eljay's photo
Fri 11/28/08 11:54 PM





Ir someone is going to push for something to be taught in school, or even want it to be takin seriously at all they should be able to show some evidence of it.


Then please explain to me why Evolution is taught in schools? The only evidence we have is of fossel records. No proof what-so-ever of the origin of those fossels - just a theory of it.

So - why shouldn't both ID and Evolution be taught in schools for what they are - theories, and let the student decide for themselves whether or not they wish to pursue further studies.


ID is not a theory. It is not science, and should not be taught in a science class.
If they want to teach it in a class that deals with mythology ok, but it's not science.
ID is just a way to sneek religion into the classrooms. ID ends debate and thought, it makes people stupid.
If you just say that we got here becouse an outside sorce put us here then thats it we do not need to go any farther.
Eveolution is as sound a theory as the earth revolving around the sun, it does not disprove a god, you can't prove a negitive.



Nonsense. There is no more "evidence" of the validity of evolution as an eplination of the origin of the species than there is of the account of Genesis. Every "stated fact" you could presume to offer to support "Evolution" as a viable science stands in support of ID as well. Plain and simple - you can do no more to disprove ID than you will ever be able to "prove" evolution. Stop claiming it as "fact" - there is nothing factual about "evolution" as an origin of species. There is so much evidence that disproves it - that it makes the discussion about it moot.

Attempt if you will to explain to me how hummingbirds have survived given "evolutionary fact".

Then think about Giraffes - after that move on to firefly's - then woodpeckers - the list goes on and on. The fact of the matter is that there isn't an evolutionist on the planet who can explain how the woodpecker managed to develop it's anatomy, let alone how it has survived.

Wake up - and realize that you have swallowed a myth. You believe it is "fact" because somewhere in some classroom you were told that it is - witohut the semblence of any evidence or proof to support it. You were certainly not introduced to the "difficulties" with evolutionary theory. Those creatures which defy evolution by their mere existance.



wrong,

There is evidence of evolution.

There is 0 evidence of an invisible magic man.

Evolution is not even debated in the scientific community.
How evolution works is, but evolution itself is not, (except maybe amungst televangalists looking for a buck).
There is as much evidence of the god poseidon ruling the ocean as there is for the biblical god.




There is evidence that within a species - things evole. But since your posts tend to compare evolution with ID - I would say you are one to use evolution as an explination for the origin of the species. That being the case - you can offer me no evidence of evolution. Period. If you think you can - you are delusional. Your belief in evolution is a matter of faith. It is a religion in the sense that you speak of it - not a science.

Eljay's photo
Sat 11/29/08 12:00 AM



Ir someone is going to push for something to be taught in school, or even want it to be takin seriously at all they should be able to show some evidence of it.


school - i can see your point.

adults? how can you prove whats taken on faith?


you either believe in whats stated as proof or not, and follow it or not.


it's been debated to death on here, no one wins - you can not debate FAITH vs SCIENCE and have a definitive outcome. sorry.


Are you joking? Its been debated to death but it basically comes down to the proponents of the theory of evolution have a SUBSTANTIAL amount of credible evidence to support it's claims.

What have the Creationists been able to show Sam?

Not a dam thing. You are confusing their whining and faith based beliefs in mythology as fact.

Pfft.


All of the evidence that supports the theory of evolution supports the theory of ID with the same measure of assurity. The evidence is interchangable depending on what one puts their faith in as far as a world view is concerned.

Neither evolution nor ID can be demonstrated as truth using pure science. No one on the planet has ever - or will ever demonstrate evolution as the explination of the origin of a species in a laboratory. All that is done in a lab is to examine fossils - that can be shown to be proof for ID as easily as it can for evolution.

Eljay's photo
Sat 11/29/08 12:04 AM





ok so answer me this does god have the knowledge of wether we are going to go to hell or not before we are even born?
if not then how is he all knowing.
and if so then he creates people with the foreknolledge that they will go to hell.
and how is that not cruel?


Life is a gift from God. When our life begins (as in when the sperm and egg unite) we are given a life. At the moment we begin to live, God knows our entire life from beginning to end.

So say God creates Hitler and realizes what Hitler is going to do. Does God destroy Hitler? No, because Hitler is just a little baby, he's innocent. God doesn't punish the innocent. Besides, God couldn't kill baby Hitler without changing events of which God was already aware. Paradox, remember? So baby Hitler gets his chance at life to live, love and make mistakes. In the end, Hitler will be punished according to his actions.

God isn't "all knowing". God knows everything that has, is or will happen. If something will never happen, God doesn't know about it.

Overcoming paradox isn't a matter of power. A paradox cannot exist, therefore God cannot create a paradox. In 1909, God knew the Holocaust would happen, but ONLY because the Holocaust was going to happen. God cannot change what he knows will happen.


then he is "finite" and not worthy to be called god or worshipped as god.

And yet he interferes throughout the old testament - that's ignorant spider - you cant say he can interfere with Pharaoh and other kings and rulers and other peoples and then turn around and state he cant interfere with Hitler- WTF??

he "knew what Pharaoh would do when he grew up supposedly, and the others also and the ways of Sodom and Gomorrah and the tribes he destroyed [Canaanites etc..] yet you say he was powerless to interfere with Hitler or Mussolini or Japan, or Korea or Vietnam or or now - BS!!


Actually - you are absolutely right on this Sam. It is quite obvious that God intervened in Hitlers plans. Who is to say that that bitter winter in Russia was not the intervention of God and the downfall of the third reich? Though it is not quite evident to us why God does not intervene in the timely manner that we as humans would like - what is evident is that consequences await for those who chose a path of unrightiousness.