1 2 15 16 17 19 21 22 23 36 37
Topic: american idol
steelersgirltina's photo
Tue 04/22/08 05:56 PM
DAVID AND PHANTOM

beccalee1980's photo
Tue 04/22/08 06:06 PM
i totally called david doing phantom!! wooohooo!!! that was awesome :) :) bottom three predictions anyone? i say brooke, jason, and syesha.
Becca

steelersgirltina's photo
Tue 04/22/08 06:07 PM
i would have to agree.

i dont like david a he is not working with the audience... do you think that the little girls will notice soon that he is not paying attention to who he is singing for?

no photo
Tue 04/22/08 06:09 PM
I say the top two are going to be the two Davids unfortunately noway David Cook totally deserves to be there...not the other one.

Syesha totally rocked it tonight though!

Okay anyone else get creeped out from the story of The Phantom of the Opera? I for real think he was a pedophile. lol

steelersgirltina's photo
Tue 04/22/08 06:10 PM

I say the top two are going to be the two Davids unfortunately noway David Cook totally deserves to be there...not the other one.

Syesha totally rocked it tonight though!

Okay anyone else get creeped out from the story of The Phantom of the Opera? I for real think he was a pedophile. lol


nope he was not ...
just in love with someone he could not have..

no photo
Tue 04/22/08 06:12 PM
who was half his age (16 or 17 right?) noway


I think the bottom three will be jason, brooke (toss up between those two as to who will go home), and I think Syesha because I don't think she has a strong following.

no photo
Tue 04/22/08 06:13 PM
Edited by brandynicole on Tue 04/22/08 06:14 PM
I'm thinking ....

Top 3 :
David C.
Carly
David A.

Bottom 3:
Syesha
Jason
Brooke


I'm thinking Brooke will go .... I liked her earlier in the competition but shes lost all her magic .

steelersgirltina's photo
Tue 04/22/08 06:14 PM
if brook does not go home i will be shocked.
that was a huge mistake that she made.


yep so phantom was just obsessed with christine.

dont make it sumin it is not

no photo
Tue 04/22/08 06:17 PM
I agree...I think that Jason has a stronger following than brooke but I could be wrong. He was awful tonight!

steelersgirltina's photo
Tue 04/22/08 06:19 PM
he did look like he was really struggling with all of it

beccalee1980's photo
Tue 04/22/08 06:24 PM
yeah i was really disappointed in jason...he really had a good opportunity to do something amazing with a great song, and he totally messed it up!
Becca

steelersgirltina's photo
Tue 04/22/08 06:30 PM
wow i got to vote after 30min

bastet126's photo
Wed 04/23/08 04:32 AM
i got *chills* when david cook sang -- i :heart: him! :smile:

arcadefan's photo
Wed 04/23/08 08:11 AM

I'm thinking ....

Top 3 :
David C.
Carly
David A.

Bottom 3:
Syesha
Jason
Brooke


I'm thinking Brooke will go .... I liked her earlier in the competition but shes lost all her magic .

what i have heard over radio is brook stoped & lost the lyrics & time for her to go home.. i agree brandy

whereuat85's photo
Wed 04/23/08 01:10 PM
castro was horrible randy called it a train wreck

no photo
Wed 04/23/08 01:42 PM
dam I missed it, I have it tivo at work so I wont get to see it till tomorrowfrown

steelersgirltina's photo
Wed 04/23/08 06:27 PM
david is safe!!

no photo
Wed 04/23/08 06:38 PM
omfg ......... noway ! BROOKE is safe . noway

steelersgirltina's photo
Wed 04/23/08 06:39 PM
Edited by steelersgirltina on Wed 04/23/08 06:39 PM
what the F***


i cant believe that!!!!!!

beccalee1980's photo
Wed 04/23/08 06:43 PM
wth?? there is no freakin way that should have happened..brooke is safe??? no way!!

1 2 15 16 17 19 21 22 23 36 37