1 2 11 12 13 15 17 18 19 36 37
Topic: american idol
no photo
Fri 04/11/08 08:24 PM
I think Michael may have gotten fewer votes because of his lack of family in the US ??

Without an entire family or home town voting for you it may just not be enough .

What is everyones problem w/Brooke ? I really like her and think she will be one of the final 3 .

arcadefan's photo
Fri 04/11/08 08:33 PM



Michael's gone!! sad sad sad sad



hello justagirlin :smile: flowerforyou

Hi arcade fan, thanks for the flower blushing happy

your welcome justagirlin :smile:

no photo
Fri 04/11/08 08:36 PM

I think Michael may have gotten fewer votes because of his lack of family in the US ??

Without an entire family or home town voting for you it may just not be enough .



Like I've said on the previous page, America voted for natural born Americans and not for naluralized Americans huh . That made Carly (Irish girl), Michael (Australian guy) and S'yesha (Black-Mexican girl) on the bottom 3.glasses

arcadefan's photo
Fri 04/11/08 08:39 PM

America voted for natural born Americans not for naturalized Americans huh

well that is a different way of putting it friend from work don't like michael & carly bec they are not natural born americans.. to me they are fine

carly had her chance in season 5 but could not make it bec of her visa

arcadefan's photo
Fri 04/11/08 08:42 PM


I think Michael may have gotten fewer votes because of his lack of family in the US ??

Without an entire family or home town voting for you it may just not be enough .



Like I've said on the previous page, America voted for natural born Americans and not for naluralized Americans huh . That made Carly (Irish girl), Michael (Australian guy) and S'yesha (Black-Mexican girl) on the bottom 3.glasses

i still think that syesha can be either in 2nd or 3rd spot depending on how she does her song selction from now on & i agree that david cook is this yr winner

no photo
Fri 04/11/08 08:53 PM


America voted for natural born Americans not for naturalized Americans huh

well that is a different way of putting it friend from work don't like michael & carly bec they are not natural born americans.. to me they are fine

carly had her chance in season 5 but could not make it bec of her visa


Well I was talking about last night's result, putting those bottom 3 obviously shows that America voted more on popularity and not basing on performance quality, though I am a solid David Cook fan :tongue:

And my Top 3 goes:

1. Kristy Lee Cook
2. David Archuleta
3. David Cook

(in descending order) bigsmile

Otherwise, its either Simon or Ryan will take the title laugh


arcadefan's photo
Fri 04/11/08 09:01 PM



America voted for natural born Americans not for naturalized Americans huh

well that is a different way of putting it friend from work don't like michael & carly bec they are not natural born americans.. to me they are fine

carly had her chance in season 5 but could not make it bec of her visa


Well I was talking about last night's result, putting those bottom 3 obviously shows that America voted more on popularity and not basing on performance quality, though I am a solid David Cook fan :tongue:

And my Top 3 goes:

1. Kristy Lee Cook
2. David Archuleta
3. David Cook

(in descending order) bigsmile

Otherwise, its either Simon or Ryan will take the title laugh



laugh laugh on last comment

i don't think that kristy will get 3rd place look at next week them mariah carey #1 hits..

no photo
Sat 04/12/08 04:44 AM

I think Michael may have gotten fewer votes because of his lack of family in the US ??

Without an entire family or home town voting for you it may just not be enough .

What is everyones problem w/Brooke ? I really like her and think she will be one of the final 3 .



That is and always has been the problem with AI it's not REALLY about the best talent.I always thought if they only accepted one call from every number the results would be totally differant.
The part that's great is Michael just moved on to opening his careeer here ,,thanks to the publicity AI gave him happy

dolphin14's photo
Sat 04/12/08 12:43 PM
I thought the top three or four last week was david a, kristi cook(still not a lover but she did good ), brooke and the corn roll guy. All the others really didn't do a great job on their sounds and all fair to go... I didn't think it would have been michael johns but his song wasnt the greatest.

steelersgirltina's photo
Sat 04/12/08 01:00 PM

I thought the top three or four last week was david a, kristi cook(still not a lover but she did good ), brooke and the corn roll guy. All the others really didn't do a great job on their sounds and all fair to go... I didn't think it would have been michael johns but his song wasnt the greatest.


do you mean the dread lock guy jason?

no photo
Sat 04/12/08 09:20 PM
Jason can go home, Im not feelin his style at all. Next week is going to be a hot mess...there are only about 4 people who might be able to pull it off....

arcadefan's photo
Sun 04/13/08 04:11 PM

Jason can go home, Im not feelin his style at all. Next week is going to be a hot mess...there are only about 4 people who might be able to pull it off....

who is the 4 ppl can pull it off? for next week..

no photo
Sun 04/13/08 04:18 PM


Jason can go home, Im not feelin his style at all. Next week is going to be a hot mess...there are only about 4 people who might be able to pull it off....

who is the 4 ppl can pull it off? for next week..


I think maybe it's David Cook,David Archilete, the tatoo chick & Brooke

steelersgirltina's photo
Sun 04/13/08 04:29 PM
does ms mariah write her own music> maybe then they would have a chance with the songs.

David Cook
is the one to beat!

arcadefan's photo
Sun 04/13/08 04:44 PM



Jason can go home, Im not feelin his style at all. Next week is going to be a hot mess...there are only about 4 people who might be able to pull it off....

who is the 4 ppl can pull it off? for next week..


I think maybe it's David Cook,David Archilete, the tatoo chick & Brooke

do you think S'yesha can pull it off & not be back on the floor?

no photo
Mon 04/14/08 09:30 AM



Jason can go home, Im not feelin his style at all. Next week is going to be a hot mess...there are only about 4 people who might be able to pull it off....

who is the 4 ppl can pull it off? for next week..


I think maybe it's David Cook,David Archilete, the tatoo chick & Brooke
haha my choice exactlybigsmile

no photo
Mon 04/14/08 09:31 AM




Jason can go home, Im not feelin his style at all. Next week is going to be a hot mess...there are only about 4 people who might be able to pull it off....

who is the 4 ppl can pull it off? for next week..


I think maybe it's David Cook,David Archilete, the tatoo chick & Brooke

do you think S'yesha can pull it off & not be back on the floor?
oh yeah I forgot about her, she has a pretty good chance to.

steelersgirltina's photo
Mon 04/14/08 08:49 PM
man david cook better be ready for a kick a$$ performance!!

karma5066's photo
Tue 04/15/08 02:20 AM
I think David cook is quite good.
he will be the one survived

arcadefan's photo
Tue 04/15/08 04:47 AM

does ms mariah write her own music> maybe then they would have a chance with the songs.

David Cook
is the one to beat!


not sure.. but i think kristy lee cook will finally get kicked off the show this week.. what i have read on her 1st 3 albums she has writen some songs

1 2 11 12 13 15 17 18 19 36 37