Topic: Is the cross an Idol?
SkyHook5652's photo
Sun 09/28/08 07:22 PM
a religious cross or a nazi smybol has no meaning except meaning be given it, so HOW ONE ACTS and SPEAKS that wear anything, show what the symbol worn means to the bearer.............
Amen brothu! :thumbsup: :smile:

tribo's photo
Sun 09/28/08 07:40 PM

But how much do you believe in any of it Tribo?

It is a symbol of death and destruction,of murders. Nothing good has come from the cross going back to where it came from...

If i put a swastika on a chain and hanging from my rear view mirror and put a big one in my front yard for people to see. What do you think would happen? Blessings...Miles


not much my friend but i keep searching.

but here you are talking of or about symbols [the Nazi cross] that have a particular meaning for people of a particular mind set and historical time. would moses have looked on it as a "evil" symbol? and again we are talking symbols here not graven images. if i wear a peace symbol it could mean different things to different people from different historical view points true? Chritians wear and put fish stickers on there cars, etc., but the symbol is much older than christianity - you know that. so symbols only serve the purpose intended for the historical time as to having that particular meaning for those of that time. The pentagram is another example - it was not always looked upon as some satanic symbol, and the list goes on - but on the other hand how can you say that the cross is a graven image? Do you mean because it was carved or cast as the bull was in exodus? I can understand if it was for the purpose of worship you speak of, but i don't think anyone worships the cross, at least not that i know of, not even the catholics.

Milesoftheusa's photo
Sun 09/28/08 07:58 PM
Edited by Milesoftheusa on Sun 09/28/08 08:37 PM
Go to a cemetary and what do you see. Better yet go to Arlington. It represents a diety and it is not the messiah. As i wrote to you in an email. That is the picture. 3 points to many saying who they belong to. as equal but 1john 5:7 has been proven was added. So the symbolism comes down to rev 13..Shalom...Miles

tribo's photo
Sun 09/28/08 08:08 PM
Edited by tribo on Sun 09/28/08 08:11 PM

Go to a cemetary and what do you see. Better yet go to Arlington. It represents a diety and it is not the messiah. As i wrote to you in an email. That is the picture. 3 points to many saying who they belong to. as equal but john 5:7 has been proven was added. So the symbolism comes down to rev 13..Shalom...Miles


I'll check that out and get back miles - shalom.

PS: did the cross not exsist before christ?

Milesoftheusa's photo
Sun 09/28/08 08:29 PM
only for an instriment of torture for the Romans.. miles p. s. check your email

MirrorMirror's photo
Sun 09/28/08 08:36 PM
:smile: Congregation, please be seated:smile:


Belushi's photo
Sun 09/28/08 08:41 PM
Its like wearing a badge for your favourite football team.

Bit of advertising, if you like.

Eljay's photo
Sun 09/28/08 11:53 PM

Ex 20:4-6
Thou dost not make to thyself a graven image, or any likeness which [is] in the heavens above, or which [is] in the earth beneath, or which [is] in the waters under the earth.

5 Thou dost not bow thyself to them, nor serve them: for I, Yahweh your Elohim, [am] a zealous Elohim, charging iniquity of fathers on sons, on the third [generation], and on the fourth, of those hating Me,

6 and doing kindness to thousands, of those loving Me and keeping My commands.
YLT

A Graven Image.. It is the only one that is on the land. all others, heaven,earth beneath,or waters.


So this graven Image is on the earth that we are not to make or worship.


Is or was not the cross an instrument of torture?

If this cross was used th kill our messiah. Are we not putting on our churches, on the walls of our houses and around our necks a symbol of Death?

A symbol of torture that happened not only to our messiah but to 1000's of others.

Would you put a swaskika from Hitler around your neck to remind you of 6 million jews who died?

What is the difference?

Shalom...Miles


Perception.

To you, the cross is an instrument of torture - so your perspective of it isone of a graven image.
Therefore, I would recommend that you do not wear one about your neck, nor hang one on the wall of your living room.

For myself - I do not see the cross in this manner. I don't pray to it, nor do I genuflect before it. These would be meaningless for me. However - when I recognise that someone is wearing one, I know that they are doing so as a preofession of their faith in the finished work of christ on the cross. Else, what's the point of wearing it? So - it is not worshopping the cross, but He who was nailed upon it.

I don't believe that those who own crosses are substituting these items for their worship of Jesus. But for those who's interpretation of that is such - for them, ownership is falling short of what they believe for themselves is right - and therefore, a sin. To project that interprestation or perception onto another without knowing what the purpose for it is in their heart - is actually passing judgement on that person - for as men, we know not what is in the heart of another. We merely percieve through words and actions what may be in their heart. But we know by the text that all men sin and fall short of the glory of God.

arkdanimal's photo
Mon 09/29/08 01:18 AM
Edited by arkdanimal on Mon 09/29/08 01:20 AM
To some it probably is, but then again, anything can be an Idol! For some its money, or sex, or houses, or even their religion, or personal beliefs!

SharpShooter10's photo
Mon 09/29/08 10:54 PM
Nothing is an idol unless you worship it

Milesoftheusa's photo
Tue 09/30/08 10:31 AM
Did not all those look upon Yahshua as he was diening in pain. Telling him let Yahweh save him. Yet this did not happen. Apperently Yahweh or the disciples want anything to do with this cross.. why have you forsaken me..he cried. We reason umoungst our self this is ok or that is or and then the things in the Book you are COMMANDEED TO DO you blow off as nothing. He does not want that now. Yet in the kingdom they are done and the feasts if you do not come to them you will be punished. DO you not believe Yahweh is the same yeasterday, today and tommorrow? If you do then all these practices throw out the door and start over. Then Life ,true life will enter you.. Blessings...Miles

tribo's photo
Tue 09/30/08 01:28 PM
Now there stood by the cross of Jesus his mother, and his mother’s sister, Mary the wife of Cleophas, and Mary Magdalene. {Cleophas: or, Clopas}
26 When Jesus therefore saw his mother, and the disciple standing by, whom he loved, he saith unto his mother, Woman, behold thy son!
27 Then saith he to the disciple, Behold thy mother! And from that hour that disciple took her unto his own home.

John the deciple and the women were at the cross, not all fled.

If we go by your interpretation then all the symbols that god put into the temple and the the ark of the covenant should also be concidered graven images. they are not - neither by god or his people at that time. so nothing has changed - look at the elaborate costuming of the high priest adorned with jewels and the golden breatplate and all else. your reading to much into this my friend i believe.

shalom.

davidben1's photo
Tue 09/30/08 06:58 PM
there is no wisdom less a man worship his neighbors words as important as his own dying words........

tribo's photo
Tue 09/30/08 10:43 PM

there is no wisdom less a man worship his neighbors words as important as his own dying words........


And who is my neighbor? Someone who lives next door to me or on my street or in my "neighbor"HOOD? LOL

Milesoftheusa's photo
Wed 10/01/08 04:50 AM
[edit] Etymology
The word cross was introduced to English in the 10th century as the term for the instrument of the torturous execution of Christ (gradually replacing the earlier word rood), ultimately from Latin crux, via Old Irish cros. The word can nowadays refer to the geometrical shape unrelated to its Christian significance. The Latin Crux (translating Greek stauros) was a Roman torture device used for crucifixion.


[edit] History
It is not known when the first cross image was made; after circles, crosses are one of the first symbols drawn by children of all cultures. There are many cross-shaped incisions in European cult caves, dating back to the earliest stages of human cultural development in the stone age. Like other symbols from this period, their use continued in the Celtic and Germanic cultures in Europe. For example, celtic coins minted many centuries before the Christian era may have an entire side showing this type of cross, sometimes with the five cardinal points marked by concave depressions in the same style as in stoneage carvings. Other coins may be showing the cross held by a rider on a horse and springing forth a fern leaf, sometimes identified as a Tree of Life symbol.


[edit] As markings
Written crosses are used for many different purposes, particularly in mathematics.

The Roman numeral for ten is X.
In the Latin alphabet, the letter X and the minuscule form of t are crosses.
The Chinese character for ten is 十; (see Chinese numerals).
The dagger or obelus (†)
The addition (or plus) sign (+) and the multiplication (or times) sign (×).
A cross is often used as a check mark because it can be clearer, easier to create with an ordinary pen or pencil, and less obscuring of the text or image that is already present than a large dot. It also allows marking a position more accurately than a large dot.

A large cross through a text often means that it is wrong or should be considered deleted.


[edit] As emblems and symbols
Cross Name Description Picture
Christian cross Also known as the Latin cross or crux ordinaria. It is the most common symbol of Christianity, intended to represent the death of Jesus when he was crucified on the True Cross and his resurrection in the New Testament.

Ankh Also known as the Key of the Nile, the Looped Tau Cross, and the Ansated Cross. It was an Ancient Egyptian symbol of life and fertility. Sometimes given a Latin name if it appears in specifically Christian contexts, such as the crux ansata ("handled cross").

Coptic ankh The Coptic ankh is the Ankh related pre Original Coptic cross of the early Gnostic Christians in Egypt.

Original Coptic Cross The original Coptic cross used by early Gnostic Christians in Egypt.

Sun cross Also known as the Sunwheel, solar cross or Odin's cross, because Odin's symbol in Norse mythology was a cross in a circle. Used throughout Native American culture to represent the great Medicine Wheel of life. It's also the symbol used by the Gnostic Movements.

High cross Free-standing Celtic crosses commonly found in Ireland and to a lesser extent in Great Britain, very common in churches and graveyards.

Coptic Cross A small circle from which emanate four arms of equal length, with angled T shapes in the corner, cross-pieces outward, representing the nails used in Jesus' crucifixion. This cross receives its name from Coptic Christianity, which centered around Alexandria, Egypt.

Canterbury cross Used in the Anglican Churches. It has four arms of equal length, each widening at the outer end in a hammer shape so that their rims form a near circle. Each arm bears a triangular panel incised with a triquetra symbolizing the Trinity. In the center of the cross is a small square. The Anglo-Saxon original, as a brooch, dates from c. 850 A.D. and was excavated in 1867 in Canterbury, England. A stone replica can be found in Canterbury Cathedral and in many other Anglican cathedrals around the world. [1]

Greek cross Used especially by Eastern Orthodoxy and Early Christianity Also known as the crux immissa quadrata. Has all arms of equal length. Often the arms curve wider as they go out.

Eastern cross Used in the Eastern Orthodox Church. The top line is said to represent the headboard, and the bottom, slanted line represents the footrest, wrenched loose by Jesus' writhing in intense agony. It is raised to the left side, because that was the side of the righteous criminal who said to Jesus: "remember me when you come into your kingdom". This symbolises the victory of good over evil. The letters IC XC found at the end of the main arm of most Eastern Orthodox Crosses are a Christogram, representing the name of Jesus Christ.

St. Brigid's Cross This cross is found throughout Ireland. It is told that the cross was made by Brigid, daughter of a Pagan King from reeds to be used as an instrument of conversion. However, Brigid's name is derived from Brigit (also spelled Brigid, Brìghde, Brìde, and Bríde), a Celtic Goddess of fire, poetry, and smithcraft, and today the cross is used to protect houses from fire. This is an example of the integration of religious traditions. The cross itself derives from the Indo-European Swastika, or Solar Wheel

Labarum Constantine I's Labarum is also known as a Chrismon, Chi-Rho (from the two Greek letters that make it up) or monogram of the first two letters of the name Christ. Several other forms of Chrismons exist.

Lorraine Cross Used in heraldry. It is similar to a patriarchal cross, but usually has one bar near the bottom and one near the top, rather than having both near the top. Is part of the heraldic arms of Lorraine in eastern France. It was originally held to be a symbol of Joan of Arc, renowned for her perseverance against foreign invaders of France.

Marian Cross Etched on the casket of Pope John Paul II, the Marian Cross is a Catholic adaptation of the traditional Latin cross to emphasize Catholic devotion to Mary.

Nordic Cross Used in flags descended from the Dannebrog.

Occitan cross Based on the counts of Toulouse's traditional coat of arms, it soon became the symbol of Occitania as a whole.

Papal Cross The three cross-bars represent the Roman Catholic Pope's triple role as Bishop of Rome, Patriarch of the West, and successor of St. Peter, Chief of the Apostles.

Patriarchal cross Similar to a traditional Christian cross, but with an additional, smaller crossbar above the main one meant to represent all the Orthodox Christian Archbishops and Patriarchs. In the Eastern Orthodox Church, this cross is sometimes seen with an additional, slanted bar near the foot of the cross (see Byzantine Cross). This cross is similar to the Lorraine Cross and the Caravaca Cross.

Presbyterian Cross Used by Presbyterian denominations.
Red Cross Used as a symbol for medical care in most of the world, the Red Crescent being used in Islamic countries and the Magen David Adom in Israel.

Cross of Sacrifice A Latin cross with a superimposed sword, blade down. It is a symbol used by the Commonwealth War Graves Commission at the site of many war memorials.

Royal Flag of Georgia Used in Georgia as national flag, first used by Georgian King Vakhtang Gorgasali in the 5th century and later adopted by Queen Tamar of Georgia in the 13th century. The flag depicts a Jerusalem cross, adopted during the reign of George V of Georgia who drove out the Mongols from Georgia in 1334.

St. Nino's Cross Also known as a "Grapevine cross" and traditionally ascribed to Saint Nino, the 4th-century female baptizer of the Georgians, it is used as a symbol of the Georgian Orthodox Church.

St. Thomas Cross Also known as a "Mar Thoma Cross" and traditionally ascribed to Saint Thomas,the Apostole of India, it is used as a symbol of the Syro Malabar Catholic Church and venerated by all Saint Thomas Christians denominations.

Saint Andrew's Cross Used in Scotland's national flag and the naval ensign of the Russian Navy, it is also called the Saltire, the Boundary Cross (because it was used by the Romans as a barrier) and the crux decussata. Saint Andrew is believed to have suffered a martyr's death on such a cross, hence its name. The cross does not have to be at this particular angle to qualify as a saltire; the symbol X can also be considered a St. Andrew's Cross.

St George's Cross Used in England's national flag.

Saint Peter's Cross/Inverted Cross An upside-down Latin cross, based on a tradition that holds that Saint Peter was martyred by being crucified upside-down. Today it is often associated with anti-Christian or Satanic groups.

Skull and crossbones Not a cross as such, but a saltire made of bones, with an overlaid skull. While traditionally associated with pirates, it was actually relatively rarely used by them, each ship having its own design, often involving an hourglass.

Tau Cross Also known as Saint Anthony's Cross, the Egyptian Cross and the crux commissa. It is shaped like the letter T. Francis of Assisi used it as his signature.

Thieves' Cross Also known as the Furka Cross. The fork, shaped like the letter Y. [2]

Mariner's Cross The Mariner's Cross is a stylized cross in the shape of an anchor. The Mariner's Cross is also referred to as St. Clement's Cross in reference to the way he was martyred.

Order of Christ Cross Cross originally used by the Portuguese Order of Christ. Since then it has become a symbol of Portugal, used on the sails of the carracks during the Discoveries Era, and currently by the Portuguese Air Force.

Extreme-right variant of the Celtic Cross Some white nationalist and neo-fascist groups adopted this variation of the Celtic cross, made up of simple lines, without any of the ornamental complexity of traditional Celtic crosses. It is thought that this basic variation's minor resemblance to the swastika[citation needed] is the reason it has become popular in such circles.



[edit] In heraldry
These crosses are ones used primarily or exclusively in heraldry and do not necessarily have any special meanings commonly associated with them. Not all the crosses of heraldry and the crosses with commonly known contexts are listed below.

Cross name Description Picture
The cross as heraldic "ordinary" A simple heraldic cross (the default if there are no additional specifying words) has arms of roughly equal length, artistically proportioned to the particular shape of the shield, which extend to the edges of the shield. Illustrated is the blazon "Azure, a cross Or" (i.e. a gold cross on a blue shield).

A cross which does not extend to the edges of the shield is humetty, in heraldic terminology.

Cross anchry A stylized cross in the shape of an anchor. Also known as the anchored cross or mariner's cross.

Cross barbée Also known as the cross barby or arrow cross, this symbol consists of two double-ended arrows in a cross configuration. Best known today for its use by the fascist Arrow Cross Party in the 1930s, the symbol actually dates to ancient times and was used by Hungarian tribes in the Middle Ages. In Christian use, the ends of this cross resemble the barbs of fish hooks, or fish spears. This alludes to the Ichthys symbol of Christ, and is suggestive of the "fishers of men" theme in the Gospel.

Cross bottony A cross with the ends of the arms bottony (or botonny), i.e. shaped like an architectural trefoil. It occurs counterchanged on the flag of Maryland.

Cross cercelée A cross which, opening at the ends, turns round both ways, like a ram's horns.

Cross crosslet A cross with the ends of each arm crossed.

Crusaders' cross Also known as the Jerusalem cross. This cross was the symbol of the Crusader Kingdom of Jerusalem, which existed for almost two hundred years after the First Crusade. The four smaller crosses are said to symbolize either the four books of the Gospel or the four directions in which the Word of Christ spread from Jerusalem. Alternately, all five crosses can symbolize the five wounds of Christ during the Passion. This symbol is also used in the flag of Georgia.

Cross fleury A cross with the ends of the arms fleury (or flory), having a shape like a fleur-de-lys.

Cross fourchee One form of the heraldic cross fourchee (fourchée, fourchy) or cross fourche (meaning "forked").

Cross fylfot Upright cross with truncated bent arms

Jerusalem cross A variant of the Crusaders' cross with cross potent. It is also the logo for the Knights and Dames of the Holy Sepulcher of Jerusalem as well as the Franciscan order's Custody of the Holy Land. The Kairos retreat bestows this cross on its participants.

Maltese cross With arms which narrow towards the center, and are indented at the ends. The "eight-pointed cross" (with no curved lines).

Cross moline In a cross moline, the ends of the arms are split and curved back.

Cross patonce A cross patonce is more or less intermediate between a cross pattée and a cross flory (or fleury).

Cross pattée A cross pattee (pattée, patty) has arms narrowing towards the centre, but with non-indented ends. See also Iron Cross.

Cross pommee A cross pommee (pommée, pommy) has a circular knob at the end of each arm.

Cross potent This cross has a crossbar at the end of each of its arms. "Potent" is an old word for a crutch, and is used in heraldic terminology to describe a T shape. This cross was used as a crest by Konishi Yukinaga, a Christian daimyo under Toyotomi Hideyoshi. It is used by many, mostly Roman Catholic, Scouting and Guiding organisations in their logo's and insignia

Quadrate A cross with a square at the intersection point.

Cross triple parted and fretted In heraldry, a "cross triple parted and fretted" (or "treble parted and fretted") is interlaced. Here, a version which is "Or on an Azure field" (gold on blue) is shown.

Cross voided A "cross voided throughout", also known as the Gammadia, can be seen as a Greek cross with its centre lines removed, or as composed of four angles (L shapes) separated by a thin space. So the name "gammadia" refers to its being made up of four shapes similar to a capital Greek letter gamma; the word gammadion can also refer to a swastika.

Cross fitchy A cross fitchy is a variation where the lower part is fashioned as a sword blade. This can be combined with other variations, e.g. cross crosslet fitchy.
Cross of St James The Cross of St. James, similar to a Cross Flory Fitch, is formed by a Cross Flory, where the lower part is fashioned as a sword blade (fitched)—making this a cross of a warrior. It is most frequently depicted in red. (The version depicted here is the one used by the order of Santiago.)


There are numerous other variations on the cross in heraldry. See heraldry for background information.

The semi-classic book A Glossary of Terms Used in Heraldry by James Parker (1894) is online, and contains much information about variants of crosses used in heraldry.



Ex 20:4-5
You shall not make for yourself a carved image — any likeness of anything that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth; 5 you shall not bow down to them nor serve them.
NKJV

Any Likeness.. Now which cross do you pick?

The swatchka is also a cross. I found else where to where believers did not start to where them untill the 8th or 9th century.

They apperently for 800 years did not want anything to do with the heathon crosses across Europe or Eypyt.

Just what is Likeness? shalom...Miles





http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cross











tribo's photo
Wed 10/01/08 09:23 AM
I think the LXX says it best Miles:


4 Thou shalt not make to thyself an idol, nor likeness of anything, whatever things are in the heaven above, and whatever are in the earth beneath, and whatever are in the waters under the earth.
5 Thou shalt not bow down to them, nor serve them; for I am the Lord thy God, a jealous God, recompensing the sins of the fathers upon the children, to the third and fourth generation to them that hate me,

To me what's being stated is that god does not want anything made so as to be worship as an ""idol"" - otherwise he would not have continued with verse 5 to show why he stated verse 4, it was to let them know not to continue in there adulteress practices they had observed in Egypt. Thus - the command.

In all fairness i again say i know of no true believer that worships the cross or thinks of it as an idol or worthy of any kind of worship whatsoever. I could be wrong, for i don't know every branch of Christianity, but i doubt it is the case. The cross to me is a symbol not a graven image or idol [not that i wear one] and if god is so set against symbols then why are the prophecies set in such symbolic language? Why does Jesus himself use them?

But i do agree with Eljay - if this offends you and you see it as sin or against god, then by all means it is not something you should do.

guitaedreams's photo
Wed 10/01/08 09:37 AM
lets just say that "if" jesus comes back, do you think he wants to see all of these crosses everywhere? its no different than showing JFK a sniper rifle

tribo's photo
Wed 10/01/08 10:13 AM

lets just say that "if" jesus comes back, do you think he wants to see all of these crosses everywhere? its no different than showing JFK a sniper rifle


"IF" he comes back the last thing on his or anybodies mind is going to be crosses or medals or other such paraphernalia - laugh

Milesoftheusa's photo
Wed 10/01/08 10:37 AM
Tribo.. I believe it is the mark that everyone will be for..Miles

tribo's photo
Wed 10/01/08 11:37 AM

Tribo.. I believe it is the mark that everyone will be for..Miles


?? - that everyone will be fore what?? you lost me there my friend?what