Topic: illegal immigration in numbers
msharmony's photo
Sun 02/17/19 12:27 PM

To me it just defies all logic to even consider the possibility of flinging the borders wide open and start allowing everyone Under the Sun to come flooding in without checking to see if they're wanted criminals first.

Will America ever wake up from their slumber?


I would agree, allowing 'everyone under the Sun' to come flooding in would defy logic. That is why we have immigration processes, and regulated borders, and walls, and fences, and agents .... et cetera, et cetera, et cetera ...

msharmony's photo
Sun 02/17/19 12:34 PM

The numbers seem to have changed a little! From the Border Patrol: The first 4 months o FY2019 = 201,497 apprehensions. At that pace, I would think FY2019 totals in the area of 500k to 700k.

https://www.cbp.gov/newsroom/stats/sw-border-migration


only if the pace is consistent and not seasonal or temporary , only time will tell. But I am doubtful it will be very far off the average three or four hundred thou that has been consistent in the last decade and still far less than the 1.6 mill we were seeing even two decades ago.

msharmony's photo
Sun 02/17/19 12:36 PM



The report reflected reality: Border Patrol apprehensions along the Southwest border plummeted by approximately 80%, from a high of over 1.6 million in FY 2000, to around 300,000 in FY 2017. (Apprehensions are considered a proxy for illegal entry, so the fewer apprehensions, the less illegal entry.)

https://www.forbes.com/sites/stuartanderson/2018/06/25/there-is-no-crisis-at-the-border-and-dhs-stats-prove-it/#411c7374112a

numbers have already declined SHARPLY over the decades, the 'CRISIS' may be overstated ...






And you really can't figure out why apprehensions are down? Let me make easier for you: They know they won't be getting in so they stopped coming in huge caravans like they did under Bush and Obama.

There are approximately 3.7 million unlawful immigrant households in the U.S. These households impose a net fiscal burden of around $54.5 billion per year. That is an additional 1,000 per year in taxes to a LEGAL family.

Why is it my responsibility to pay for the medical needs of foreigners when I can't even afford health insurance for my own family? We shell out 135 BILLION every year to 12.5 illegal immigrants and another 4.2 million children of theirs.

Why are we housing the criminals of other countries? They are 22% of ALL PRISONERS now.

And how about all the crimes committed by the ones who keep coming back?

I don't really think you care about them, btw. I think you only want a reason to complain about Trump. There are better issues you could choose, because he is 100% correct on this. He was elected to do this and he better keep his promise, no matter how much you disrespect the voters.









No. I do care about people in general, regardless of the legal labels (slave was once a label) on a document.


There are better issues, I agree, which is what makes him 100% WRONG to make this THE issue of priority.



dust4fun's photo
Sun 02/17/19 12:40 PM




I find your comment comparing people who are deeply concerned about the flood of criminals coming into our country illegally with anti abolitionists who would have returned slaves to their owners to be extremely offensive, racist and uncalled for and if I was a moderator here you would be chastised immediately!



misdirection, ridicule, humiliation...that's the only tools the Open Border Society has since neither truth nor fact is in their corner. Basically they are blasting Trump for the exact same thing they supported when it was Obama or Hillary proposing it.




Yeah, the hypocrisy is astounding isn't it? What gets me is that none of their arguments hold water and yet they still cling to their illogical, irrational beliefs, mantras and narratives. I'd say the brainwashing of America was nearly complete about the time Trump took office and began revealing the truth.
I've been here on and off for years and as you can see I have never really participated in any of the forums. Do the moderators ever jump in when people start hurling racist insinuations Etc?


Well there would be far fewer blacks in this country if it wasn't for slavery, and therefore many of these people who like to bring up slavery would actually not even exist if it weren't for slavery. However if you consider the pay and living conditions of some of these illegal emigrants it isn't all that better than some of the slaves. Honestly the illegal emigrants probably cost the US less than the legal ones that live in poverty and receive money from programs and assistance. Clearly there is a wide range of people here illegally, while a small portion commit violent crimes, others petty crimes, it comes down to ALL of them are guilty of a crime just by being here illegally. That doesn't mean I still don't enjoy the fruit and vegetables they pick, enjoy the food they cook for me at restaurants, or their skills doing landscaping and roofing. The problem is we can't have the best of both worlds.

msharmony's photo
Sun 02/17/19 12:46 PM
Edited by msharmony on Sun 02/17/19 12:46 PM





I find your comment comparing people who are deeply concerned about the flood of criminals coming into our country illegally with anti abolitionists who would have returned slaves to their owners to be extremely offensive, racist and uncalled for and if I was a moderator here you would be chastised immediately!



misdirection, ridicule, humiliation...that's the only tools the Open Border Society has since neither truth nor fact is in their corner. Basically they are blasting Trump for the exact same thing they supported when it was Obama or Hillary proposing it.




Yeah, the hypocrisy is astounding isn't it? What gets me is that none of their arguments hold water and yet they still cling to their illogical, irrational beliefs, mantras and narratives. I'd say the brainwashing of America was nearly complete about the time Trump took office and began revealing the truth.
I've been here on and off for years and as you can see I have never really participated in any of the forums. Do the moderators ever jump in when people start hurling racist insinuations Etc?


Well there would be far fewer blacks in this country if it wasn't for slavery, and therefore many of these people who like to bring up slavery would actually not even exist if it weren't for slavery. However if you consider the pay and living conditions of some of these illegal emigrants it isn't all that better than some of the slaves. Honestly the illegal emigrants probably cost the US less than the legal ones that live in poverty and receive money from programs and assistance. Clearly there is a wide range of people here illegally, while a small portion commit violent crimes, others petty crimes, it comes down to ALL of them are guilty of a crime just by being here illegally. That doesn't mean I still don't enjoy the fruit and vegetables they pick, enjoy the food they cook for me at restaurants, or their skills doing landscaping and roofing. The problem is we can't have the best of both worlds.


and cops would not have a job without criminals, should they somehow be grateful for crime or not bring it up then?

and doctors would not have a job without sickness, should they be less concerned about that too?

There is not really a problem except where we make it one. Our immigration is obviously not set up around the ideals on the symbolic statue of liberty, immigration relies profoundly on financial status or being in a network of financial status. For those truly in NEED of help and who have no network to take on their financial responsibility, they are SCREWED. And I don't view people as dispensable or dangerous or unworthy of basic respect and decency for not wanting to starve gracefully.

What we have works as well as our 'justice system'. It is always going to have room for improvement, but drastic fear tactics are what causes the division, when genuine attempts at humility AND progress would be much more effective. Making enemies out of the desperate is a desperate ploy.




T.Roy 's photo
Sun 02/17/19 12:49 PM
Why is it MY responsibilty to pay (with increased property taxes, etc.) for a football stadium I will never use?


that's a local issue. You shouldn't


Why is it MY responsibilty to pay taxes/ have my taxes go for things I despise and am against?


Like abortion on demand as the baby is coming out? Yea, I agree. Totally wrong for me to pay for blood, but that happened because of liberal judges forcing their will on the American people, whereas MOST taxes are actually voted on by our representatives in DC



Give the people already here social security numbers, therefore, they can be taxed on their income, and *your* problem/ gripe goes away..

Pick an arbitrary date...say..January 2019.
If you can prove you were here by that date and haven't commited any crime...then give them a social security number, and start collecting taxes from them..
Then start a program from *that* date with the new people to work on the imnmigration program/ problem.


What's wrong with allowing our legal system to work and do it's job so every American has a voice in the process?

Oh yea...because you know that most Americans would never agree so you have deceive and go around them.





Hispanics, as a group, have the lowest crime statistic..


The legal ones, yes. But have you heard of M13? They beat people into a little bloody pulp on the sidewalk with iron pipes. Nice people you support there.




I don't recall the uproar a couple decades ago when all the Asian gangs were such a problem in different cities (Nashville being one of them).



Then you have selective listening...which was already obvious.



My other comment was about principle...
It was a "crime" to harbor a runaway or assist them in getting north..
They had no rights here, therefore weren't legal citizens.
Yet abolitionsist saw the way they were living/ being treated, and decided to help them.


And if it had not been for Christians with a conscience it would have never happened. Just like Christians today who want to put the brakes on abortion.



Period.
If you want to make more of that than what i said..that's on ypou.




I'll sleep just fine knowing that innocent Americans are safer. Thank you for giving me that.






.

FeelYoung's photo
Sun 02/17/19 12:49 PM
It's time to forget about slaves and what happened over 100 years ago. Its time to focus on keeping our country safe. I don't care if its Hondurans or Swiss people, we need to keep known criminals out of our country. We have enough home-grown bad people without these huge caravans.

msharmony's photo
Sun 02/17/19 12:54 PM

It's time to forget about slaves and what happened over 100 years ago. Its time to focus on keeping our country safe. I don't care if its Hondurans or Swiss people, we need to keep known criminals out of our country. We have enough home-grown bad people without these huge caravans.



So, you support gun regulation? to keep us 'safer'? I dont care if its criminals or mentally ill, we need to keep semi automatics out of the hands of people without coping skills.

Do you support mandatory building of cars that go no faster than our top speed limits? speed kills plenty of people every year too.

oh, and how about criminals that have not been caught in a crime yet? How will we prevent them from being in this country?


we can do better, but will never eliminate violence and crime. Scapegoating the border is only a distraction and a band aid to true attempts at curbing either one substantially.



Toodygirl5's photo
Sun 02/17/19 01:16 PM
What we can do is eliminate illegals crossing US borders by the thousands.

T.Roy 's photo
Sun 02/17/19 03:00 PM



we can do better, but will never eliminate violence and crime. Scapegoating the border is only a distraction and a band aid to true attempts at curbing either one substantially.






I realize it's easier to act like you "care" about the (presumed) poor immigrants who want a better life, but what you're actually saying is that you don't care what happens to innocent people that live here.

The facts are that legal immigrants are welcome. Criminals don't do legal.

But you support criminals, which explains why you'd listen to the Democrats and think they "care" about you. All they want is their power back and they will use lies on you or anyone else to get it

Someday soon you will regret believing them. I can wait.

;-)






FeelYoung's photo
Sun 02/17/19 03:04 PM
I support ICE, the BORDER PATROL and the NRA - Every one of those groups can report numbers Truthfully.

FeelYoung's photo
Sun 02/17/19 03:05 PM


Well there would be far fewer blacks in this country if it wasn't for slavery, and therefore many of these people who like to bring up slavery would actually not even exist if it weren't for slavery. However if you consider the pay and living conditions of some of these illegal emigrants it isn't all that better than some of the slaves. Honestly the illegal emigrants probably cost the US less than the legal ones that live in poverty and receive money from programs and assistance. Clearly there is a wide range of people here illegally, while a small portion commit violent crimes, others petty crimes, it comes down to ALL of them are guilty of a crime just by being here illegally. That doesn't mean I still don't enjoy the fruit and vegetables they pick, enjoy the food they cook for me at restaurants, or their skills doing landscaping and roofing. The problem is we can't have the best of both worlds.


Thank you for posting Truth.

no photo
Sun 02/17/19 05:29 PM

Why is it my responsibility to pay for the medical needs of foreigners when I can't even afford health insurance for my own family?


Why is it MY responsibilty to pay (with increased property taxes, etc.) for a football stadium I will never use?

Why is it MY responsibilty to pay taxes/ have my taxes go for things I despise and am against? (and there are quite a few)

Give the people already here social security numbers, therefore, they can be taxed on their income, and *your* problem/ gripe goes away..

Pick an arbitrary date...say..January 2019.
If you can prove you were here by that date and haven't commited any crime...then give them a social security number, and start collecting taxes from them..
Then start a program from *that* date with the new people to work on the imnmigration program/ problem.

Hispanics, as a group, have the lowest crime statistic..

I don't recall the uproar a couple decades ago when all the Asian gangs were such a problem in different cities (Nashville being one of them).

My other comment was about principle...
It was a "crime" to harbor a runaway or assist them in getting north..
They had no rights here, therefore weren't legal citizens.
Yet abolitionsist saw the way they were living/ being treated, and decided to help them.
Period.
If you want to make more of that than what i said..that's on ypou.





Well, I'll be the first to admit that the American people shouldn't be taxed for building or maintaining football stadiums nor should we be taxed for anyting that the majority of the American people are against but you completely evaded the question regarding the concept of American taxpayers picking up the medical tab for illegal aliens! How can anyone possibly justify that?

Then, instead of apologizing for your offensive analogy comparing law-abiding American citizens who merely want to prevent a massive influx of criminals into this country, with those who captured and return slaves to their owners during the Civil War, you're actually going to try to defend that position? You don't have a leg to stand on and I'll be the first one to point that out to you! It's not a crime nor is it an act of racism to keep criminals from entering our country!

msharmony's photo
Sun 02/17/19 05:51 PM




we can do better, but will never eliminate violence and crime. Scapegoating the border is only a distraction and a band aid to true attempts at curbing either one substantially.






I realize it's easier to act like you "care" about the (presumed) poor immigrants who want a better life, but what you're actually saying is that you don't care what happens to innocent people that live here.

The facts are that legal immigrants are welcome. Criminals don't do legal.

But you support criminals, which explains why you'd listen to the Democrats and think they "care" about you. All they want is their power back and they will use lies on you or anyone else to get it

Someday soon you will regret believing them. I can wait.

;-)









yes, and once, enslaved africans were welcome but those trying to be free werent. they were criminals who didnt 'do' legal. Fortunately, people cared about them too though.

What I support are people trying to survive and do no harm, and people who need a little help. The labels others place upon them dont make them any less human to me, and therefore no less worth caring about.

msharmony's photo
Sun 02/17/19 05:53 PM
Edited by msharmony on Sun 02/17/19 06:25 PM


Why is it my responsibility to pay for the medical needs of foreigners when I can't even afford health insurance for my own family?


Why is it MY responsibilty to pay (with increased property taxes, etc.) for a football stadium I will never use?

Why is it MY responsibilty to pay taxes/ have my taxes go for things I despise and am against? (and there are quite a few)

Give the people already here social security numbers, therefore, they can be taxed on their income, and *your* problem/ gripe goes away..

Pick an arbitrary date...say..January 2019.
If you can prove you were here by that date and haven't commited any crime...then give them a social security number, and start collecting taxes from them..
Then start a program from *that* date with the new people to work on the imnmigration program/ problem.

Hispanics, as a group, have the lowest crime statistic..

I don't recall the uproar a couple decades ago when all the Asian gangs were such a problem in different cities (Nashville being one of them).

My other comment was about principle...
It was a "crime" to harbor a runaway or assist them in getting north..
They had no rights here, therefore weren't legal citizens.
Yet abolitionsist saw the way they were living/ being treated, and decided to help them.
Period.
If you want to make more of that than what i said..that's on ypou.





Well, I'll be the first to admit that the American people shouldn't be taxed for building or maintaining football stadiums nor should we be taxed for anyting that the majority of the American people are against but you completely evaded the question regarding the concept of American taxpayers picking up the medical tab for illegal aliens! How can anyone possibly justify that?

Then, instead of apologizing for your offensive analogy comparing law-abiding American citizens who merely want to prevent a massive influx of criminals into this country, with those who captured and return slaves to their owners during the Civil War, you're actually going to try to defend that position? You don't have a leg to stand on and I'll be the first one to point that out to you! It's not a crime nor is it an act of racism to keep criminals from entering our country!



If the only thing defining one as criminal is their ability to pay for a document, they may be worthy of 'defending'.

as far as taxing americans, the constitution says taxes are levied for the GENERAL Welfare, not for the Welfare specifically of Jack and John.

there isnt budget to personally go in and direct each individuals taxes to the things they specifically support, which is why they are collected for the GENERAL welfare of the States, which is why people without kids may still ahve taxes go to schools, because generally, the country will fare a bit better with an educated public than an uneducated one, even the people without kids, who may be impacted by policies and actions of those uneducated as they get out in the world.

it is why people who dont vote for the winning politician, still pay the taxes towards their salary like those who did. Tax money cant be used on an individual budget for each individual taxpayer on only what they feel benefits them or only what they want to contribute to.

I_love_bluegrass's photo
Sun 02/17/19 06:13 PM

but you completely evaded the question regarding the concept of American taxpayers picking up the medical tab for illegal aliens! How can anyone possibly justify that?




Do you know how many "American taxpayers" are "picking up the tab" for the thousands of ER visits by the poor, white, working Americans who can't afford health insurance..?




FeelYoung's photo
Sun 02/17/19 06:37 PM
paying for poor white Americans is because they are CITIZENS. Not illegals. I am not concerned with what color someone is... I am concerned that our tax dollars are paying for illegals, let their own country pay. It is not MY fault they don't have quality government.

T.Roy 's photo
Sun 02/17/19 07:00 PM
Edited by T.Roy on Sun 02/17/19 07:03 PM



yes, and once, enslaved africans were welcome but those trying to be free werent. they were criminals who didnt 'do' legal. Fortunately, people cared about them too though.



Do you have any idea how slavery started legally in America?

it was the House of Burgess, the nation-state of Virginia in Newport News in 1704

A BLACK MAN, Anthony Johnson, who came to America as an indentured servant, had some indentured servants who were black and petioned the government to make them chattle property because he was about to die and wanted them to continue working for his family estate.

This proves there were many free black men in the beginning of America. NOT living as slaves, able to own property and petition the government.

So please....stop with all the attempts to guilt white people. It's a lazy substitute for facing reality.




[quote}

What I support are people trying to survive and do no harm, and people who need a little help. The labels others place upon them dont make them any less human to me, and therefore no less worth caring about.




What about the innocent citizens of this country? Why don't you care about them?


face it...you only "care" because you hate Trump.


it's transparent.


Toodygirl5's photo
Sun 02/17/19 07:08 PM






What about the innocent citizens of this country? Why don't you care about them?


face it...you only "care" because you hate Trump.


it's transparent.





:thumbsup:

msharmony's photo
Sun 02/17/19 08:08 PM
Edited by msharmony on Sun 02/17/19 08:12 PM




yes, and once, enslaved africans were welcome but those trying to be free werent. they were criminals who didnt 'do' legal. Fortunately, people cared about them too though.



Do you have any idea how slavery started legally in America?

it was the House of Burgess, the nation-state of Virginia in Newport News in 1704

A BLACK MAN, Anthony Johnson, who came to America as an indentured servant, had some indentured servants who were black and petioned the government to make them chattle property because he was about to die and wanted them to continue working for his family estate.

This proves there were many free black men in the beginning of America. NOT living as slaves, able to own property and petition the government.

So please....stop with all the attempts to guilt white people. It's a lazy substitute for facing reality.




[quote}

What I support are people trying to survive and do no harm, and people who need a little help. The labels others place upon them dont make them any less human to me, and therefore no less worth caring about.




What about the innocent citizens of this country? Why don't you care about them?


face it...you only "care" because you hate Trump.


it's transparent.




smh. The case does not prove there were' many' free blacks because it only involves ONE.


no one is trying to guilt white people by simply making historical references.


and as long as us citizens fall under the category of 'doing no harm and needing a little help" I think they fall under my previous response of caring. I do not make those feelings based on nationality OR race of people.

What is apparent is that often disapproval of Trump is brushed off as hate or conspiracy, by the same people that claimed to not appreciate their disapproval of Obama being brushed off as racism. Ironic much?