Topic: Why Say No To Amnesty? | |
---|---|
Why say no to drugs, fraud, or any number of other crimes?
How about because it's illegal? http://www.fromthetrenchesworldreport.com/why-say-no-to-amnesty-illegal-aliens-get-better-government-care-while-war-veterans-needs-are-ignored/45265 |
|
|
|
Edited by
msharmony
on
Sat 05/25/13 04:30 PM
|
|
not exactly illegal
in the legal system we call it 'plea bargaining' and 'immunity' depends upon balancing whats to be gained and whats to be lost,,,, |
|
|
|
btw
Im not for a complete amnesty I am , however, for not penalizing the children of the adults who chose to break the law and include them all companies and employers knowingly hiring undocumented should be fined the going wage for that position (not the weak wage they could scam the desperate illegal to accept),,,this would deter them from hiring illegals the difference between what they paid and what they SHOULD have paid should be used to deport the adult back home WITH a stipend of whatever is left over from their hard earned money children of adults who trespass should have the option of legal adoption by family or sponsor in the states.... |
|
|
|
Edited by
Sojourning_Soul
on
Sun 05/26/13 06:01 AM
|
|
We are a nation of laws! When we allow those laws to only be used against us, what does that say for our nation or it's leaders and enforcers?!
I can only think of two things..... lack of patriotism or corruption is at the wheel! We didn't force any of them to break the law, we shouldn't be forced to allow them to now get away with it! |
|
|
|
btw Im not for a complete amnesty I am , however, for not penalizing the children of the adults who chose to break the law and include them all companies and employers knowingly hiring undocumented should be fined the going wage for that position (not the weak wage they could scam the desperate illegal to accept),,,this would deter them from hiring illegals the difference between what they paid and what they SHOULD have paid should be used to deport the adult back home WITH a stipend of whatever is left over from their hard earned money children of adults who trespass should have the option of legal adoption by family or sponsor in the states.... The children of adults that you mention are called "anchor babies", only by an archaic law they are called US citizens. |
|
|
|
I think she means the children that were born elsewhere and dragged here with mommy and daddy.
|
|
|
|
The children of adults that you mention are called "anchor babies", only by an archaic law they are called US citizens.
Uh, that "archaic law" that you mention is called the U.S. Constitution. |
|
|
|
I think she means the children that were born elsewhere and dragged here with mommy and daddy. "Dragged" is correct. Those children didn't have a choice. |
|
|
|
I believe that was an amendment to the constitution passed for the protection of children of former slaves. Not for the children of illegal immigrants.
|
|
|
|
btw Im not for a complete amnesty I am , however, for not penalizing the children of the adults who chose to break the law and include them all companies and employers knowingly hiring undocumented should be fined the going wage for that position (not the weak wage they could scam the desperate illegal to accept),,,this would deter them from hiring illegals the difference between what they paid and what they SHOULD have paid should be used to deport the adult back home WITH a stipend of whatever is left over from their hard earned money children of adults who trespass should have the option of legal adoption by family or sponsor in the states.... The children of adults that you mention are called "anchor babies", only by an archaic law they are called US citizens. whatever the term, since they truly didnt have choice in being here, I still feel they should have an additional option to be raised or cared for by an american sponsor or legal citizen relative,,,,as opposed to automatic deportation |
|
|
|
Edited by
Sojourning_Soul
on
Sun 05/26/13 03:24 PM
|
|
btw Im not for a complete amnesty I am , however, for not penalizing the children of the adults who chose to break the law and include them all companies and employers knowingly hiring undocumented should be fined the going wage for that position (not the weak wage they could scam the desperate illegal to accept),,,this would deter them from hiring illegals the difference between what they paid and what they SHOULD have paid should be used to deport the adult back home WITH a stipend of whatever is left over from their hard earned money children of adults who trespass should have the option of legal adoption by family or sponsor in the states.... The children of adults that you mention are called "anchor babies", only by an archaic law they are called US citizens. whatever the term, since they truly didnt have choice in being here, I still feel they should have an additional option to be raised or cared for by an american sponsor or legal citizen relative,,,,as opposed to automatic deportation In other words we are supposed to feel responsible for children that the parents didn't? Citizen babies are taken from criminals all the time and placed in temp homes, but if the child is not a citizen or a green carded student..... they are just as guilty, and if the parents didn't think to consider that..... maybe they will next time. We have to abide by the laws, and I'm sorry for them, but they have less rights than a citizen.... being criminal they should suffer the law. |
|
|
|
btw Im not for a complete amnesty I am , however, for not penalizing the children of the adults who chose to break the law and include them all companies and employers knowingly hiring undocumented should be fined the going wage for that position (not the weak wage they could scam the desperate illegal to accept),,,this would deter them from hiring illegals the difference between what they paid and what they SHOULD have paid should be used to deport the adult back home WITH a stipend of whatever is left over from their hard earned money children of adults who trespass should have the option of legal adoption by family or sponsor in the states.... The children of adults that you mention are called "anchor babies", only by an archaic law they are called US citizens. whatever the term, since they truly didnt have choice in being here, I still feel they should have an additional option to be raised or cared for by an american sponsor or legal citizen relative,,,,as opposed to automatic deportation In other words we are supposed to feel responsible for children that the parents didn't? Citizen babies are taken from criminals all the time and placed in temp homes, but if the child is not a citizen or a green carded student..... they are just as guilty, and if the parents didn't think to consider that..... maybe they will next time. We have to abide by the laws, and I'm sorry for them, but they have less rights than a citizen.... being criminal they should suffer the law. yes, adults should feel SOME responsibility towards children, period their own or not citizen criminals have the option to leave their children with other relatives if they become arrested,,,, they dont have them sent away to another country a child has no legal culpability if they are home and the parents kidnap someone,, they are not expected to have any responsibility for their parents choices just because by nature of not having the capacity to care for themself they were forced to be present for this crime,,, people would be up in arms if we put illegal children in the 'temp' homes that citizens get as that involves peoples money here in the states my proposal that a relative or sponsor here take the responsibility saves the expense of deportation, or foster care, or temp homes,, and removes PUNISHMENT from the child for their parents crime,,, |
|
|
|
btw Im not for a complete amnesty I am , however, for not penalizing the children of the adults who chose to break the law and include them all companies and employers knowingly hiring undocumented should be fined the going wage for that position (not the weak wage they could scam the desperate illegal to accept),,,this would deter them from hiring illegals the difference between what they paid and what they SHOULD have paid should be used to deport the adult back home WITH a stipend of whatever is left over from their hard earned money children of adults who trespass should have the option of legal adoption by family or sponsor in the states.... The children of adults that you mention are called "anchor babies", only by an archaic law they are called US citizens. whatever the term, since they truly didnt have choice in being here, I still feel they should have an additional option to be raised or cared for by an american sponsor or legal citizen relative,,,,as opposed to automatic deportation I agree that they are unwitting particpants in criminal behavior therefore not guilty of any crime, but their continued presence here continues a link to criminal parents that is not in the best interests of our country. Plus children should be kept with their parents - families should not be split up - children are mostly going to be too young to make those decisions - those are adult decisions that should be made by adults not children in this situation it has to be the interests of our country that come first, we have put those interests as secondary for too long. that trend needs reversed besides it is usually going to be in the best interests of children to be with their families and knowing that the children cannot stay m ight be a good deterrent |
|
|
|
btw Im not for a complete amnesty I am , however, for not penalizing the children of the adults who chose to break the law and include them all companies and employers knowingly hiring undocumented should be fined the going wage for that position (not the weak wage they could scam the desperate illegal to accept),,,this would deter them from hiring illegals the difference between what they paid and what they SHOULD have paid should be used to deport the adult back home WITH a stipend of whatever is left over from their hard earned money children of adults who trespass should have the option of legal adoption by family or sponsor in the states.... The children of adults that you mention are called "anchor babies", only by an archaic law they are called US citizens. whatever the term, since they truly didnt have choice in being here, I still feel they should have an additional option to be raised or cared for by an american sponsor or legal citizen relative,,,,as opposed to automatic deportation I agree that they are unwitting particpants in criminal behavior therefore not guilty of any crime, but their continued presence here continues a link to criminal parents that is not in the best interests of our country. Plus children should be kept with their parents - families should not be split up - children are mostly going to be too young to make those decisions - those are adult decisions that should be made by adults not children in this situation it has to be the interests of our country that come first, we have put those interests as secondary for too long. that trend needs reversed besides it is usually going to be in the best interests of children to be with their families and knowing that the children cannot stay m ight be a good deterrent I understand the deterrent but I also think being seperated from your children is a deterrent as well so that allowing other LEGAL CITIZEN relatives the option of taking over care of the child seems reasonable to me,,, |
|
|
|
I believe that was an amendment to the constitution passed for the protection of children of former slaves. Not for the children of illegal immigrants. It doesn't matter why it was passed, the 14th Amendment still defines a person born in the USA as being a natural-born U.S. citizen. See United States v. Wong Kim Ark |
|
|
|
btw Im not for a complete amnesty I am , however, for not penalizing the children of the adults who chose to break the law and include them all companies and employers knowingly hiring undocumented should be fined the going wage for that position (not the weak wage they could scam the desperate illegal to accept),,,this would deter them from hiring illegals the difference between what they paid and what they SHOULD have paid should be used to deport the adult back home WITH a stipend of whatever is left over from their hard earned money children of adults who trespass should have the option of legal adoption by family or sponsor in the states.... The children of adults that you mention are called "anchor babies", only by an archaic law they are called US citizens. whatever the term, since they truly didnt have choice in being here, I still feel they should have an additional option to be raised or cared for by an american sponsor or legal citizen relative,,,,as opposed to automatic deportation I agree that they are unwitting particpants in criminal behavior therefore not guilty of any crime, but their continued presence here continues a link to criminal parents that is not in the best interests of our country. Plus children should be kept with their parents - families should not be split up - children are mostly going to be too young to make those decisions - those are adult decisions that should be made by adults not children in this situation it has to be the interests of our country that come first, we have put those interests as secondary for too long. that trend needs reversed besides it is usually going to be in the best interests of children to be with their families and knowing that the children cannot stay m ight be a good deterrent I understand the deterrent but I also think being seperated from your children is a deterrent as well so that allowing other LEGAL CITIZEN relatives the option of taking over care of the child seems reasonable to me,,, it is very reasonable, particularly since the children are citizens. but i don't think families should be separated by force hopefully it would deter individuals from having children just to gain entry to the US as that is NOT a good reason to create a human life... there would also be a need to evaluate the parenting....it would have to be a decision based in love and what is best for the children and the family IMO |
|
|
|
btw Im not for a complete amnesty I am , however, for not penalizing the children of the adults who chose to break the law and include them all companies and employers knowingly hiring undocumented should be fined the going wage for that position (not the weak wage they could scam the desperate illegal to accept),,,this would deter them from hiring illegals the difference between what they paid and what they SHOULD have paid should be used to deport the adult back home WITH a stipend of whatever is left over from their hard earned money children of adults who trespass should have the option of legal adoption by family or sponsor in the states.... The children of adults that you mention are called "anchor babies", only by an archaic law they are called US citizens. whatever the term, since they truly didnt have choice in being here, I still feel they should have an additional option to be raised or cared for by an american sponsor or legal citizen relative,,,,as opposed to automatic deportation I agree that they are unwitting particpants in criminal behavior therefore not guilty of any crime, but their continued presence here continues a link to criminal parents that is not in the best interests of our country. Plus children should be kept with their parents - families should not be split up - children are mostly going to be too young to make those decisions - those are adult decisions that should be made by adults not children in this situation it has to be the interests of our country that come first, we have put those interests as secondary for too long. that trend needs reversed besides it is usually going to be in the best interests of children to be with their families and knowing that the children cannot stay m ight be a good deterrent I understand the deterrent but I also think being seperated from your children is a deterrent as well so that allowing other LEGAL CITIZEN relatives the option of taking over care of the child seems reasonable to me,,, it is very reasonable, particularly since the children are citizens. but i don't think families should be separated by force hopefully it would deter individuals from having children just to gain entry to the US as that is NOT a good reason to create a human life... there would also be a need to evaluate the parenting....it would have to be a decision based in love and what is best for the children and the family IMO no argument here, thsts why I think it shold be an option and not a mandate,, as long as it is not requiring anything extra from the american people,, it should be their option to stay with family that is here in the states legally |
|
|
|
Edited by
Sojourning_Soul
on
Mon 05/27/13 07:51 AM
|
|
The law is the law. If you question any of it you must question all of it.
That's not a nut anyone wants to crack! Simply follow the law or put it to a vote for change. Since that has not been done, in either case, deportation is still the law, of all guilty parties, even minor children under laws of "guilt by association". Blame the criminals, not the law or the people who wish to enforce it, pay taxes to enforce it or the programs the illegals benefit from by violating it. Eliminate the benefits and you eliminate the problem |
|
|
|
btw Im not for a complete amnesty I am , however, for not penalizing the children of the adults who chose to break the law and include them all companies and employers knowingly hiring undocumented should be fined the going wage for that position (not the weak wage they could scam the desperate illegal to accept),,,this would deter them from hiring illegals the difference between what they paid and what they SHOULD have paid should be used to deport the adult back home WITH a stipend of whatever is left over from their hard earned money children of adults who trespass should have the option of legal adoption by family or sponsor in the states.... ![]() |
|
|
|
btw Im not for a complete amnesty I am , however, for not penalizing the children of the adults who chose to break the law and include them all companies and employers knowingly hiring undocumented should be fined the going wage for that position (not the weak wage they could scam the desperate illegal to accept),,,this would deter them from hiring illegals the difference between what they paid and what they SHOULD have paid should be used to deport the adult back home WITH a stipend of whatever is left over from their hard earned money children of adults who trespass should have the option of legal adoption by family or sponsor in the states.... ![]() those of the age of consent are getting punished,,,those who are not should not be,,,, there is a difference, for instance, between a child of 10 whose parents make them drink liquor and smoke,, and a child of 17 who CHOSE to do it IM sure the 10 year old would not be PUNISHED for what was forced by their parents,,,there is a significant difference,,, |
|
|