Topic: EVERY AMERICAN SHOULD BE OUTRAGED
lulu24's photo
Wed 10/28/09 11:47 AM




If every illegal immigrant got to stay here TAX free for prior earnings, free schooling, free medical, and the ones that got deported and came back can now stay or go home and we the US citizens would foot the bill, well that makes me upset.

WE have several people here, BORN here that need help and the government does little or nothing for them....
why does being born here matter?

and do you honestly think they aren't paying taxes?
If they aren't citizens or aren't here legally they shouldn't be eligible for any benefits.

I work in social services, and have been for over 10 years. In that time frame I've come across many illegals, and only two had social security numbers, and were paying taxes. You can't tell me that they are contributing members of our society.


I worked in social services for years and did not encounter a whole lot of illegals trying to get benefits illegally.


I guess you don't consider sales tax a tax then? Or utilities taxes? Phone taxes? etc...


yep...

and there are those that work under real social security numbers that just don't happen to be theirs. they pay in without a problem...and they can't ever draw it back out.

can't buy anything or use anything any more without paying some sort of tax.

Kitteh_Kat's photo
Wed 10/28/09 11:58 AM




If every illegal immigrant got to stay here TAX free for prior earnings, free schooling, free medical, and the ones that got deported and came back can now stay or go home and we the US citizens would foot the bill, well that makes me upset.

WE have several people here, BORN here that need help and the government does little or nothing for them....
why does being born here matter?

and do you honestly think they aren't paying taxes?
If they aren't citizens or aren't here legally they shouldn't be eligible for any benefits.

I work in social services, and have been for over 10 years. In that time frame I've come across many illegals, and only two had social security numbers, and were paying taxes. You can't tell me that they are contributing members of our society.


I worked in social services for years and did not encounter a whole lot of illegals trying to get benefits illegally.


I guess you don't consider sales tax a tax then? Or utilities taxes? Phone taxes? etc...
They can't get benefits at all anymore unless states enact legislation to do so, and the funding has to come from state funds. That sure worked out well for CA, didn't it?!?

I was referring specifically to payroll taxes as that's what was being discussed.

franshade's photo
Wed 10/28/09 12:00 PM
just one of my wise a$$ comments

Hell, I'll rent out my social security number, I can stay home, watch tv, and file at years end for my income tax return yet never lift a finger, and as person will be paying my payroll taxes no one would be offended :wink:

Dragoness's photo
Wed 10/28/09 12:07 PM





If every illegal immigrant got to stay here TAX free for prior earnings, free schooling, free medical, and the ones that got deported and came back can now stay or go home and we the US citizens would foot the bill, well that makes me upset.

WE have several people here, BORN here that need help and the government does little or nothing for them....
why does being born here matter?

and do you honestly think they aren't paying taxes?
If they aren't citizens or aren't here legally they shouldn't be eligible for any benefits.

I work in social services, and have been for over 10 years. In that time frame I've come across many illegals, and only two had social security numbers, and were paying taxes. You can't tell me that they are contributing members of our society.


I worked in social services for years and did not encounter a whole lot of illegals trying to get benefits illegally.


I guess you don't consider sales tax a tax then? Or utilities taxes? Phone taxes? etc...
They can't get benefits at all anymore unless states enact legislation to do so, and the funding has to come from state funds. That sure worked out well for CA, didn't it?!?

I was referring specifically to payroll taxes as that's what was being discussed.


No, that is not the tax being discussed.

Kitteh_Kat's photo
Wed 10/28/09 12:08 PM




If every illegal immigrant got to stay here TAX free for prior earnings, free schooling, free medical, and the ones that got deported and came back can now stay or go home and we the US citizens would foot the bill, well that makes me upset.

WE have several people here, BORN here that need help and the government does little or nothing for them....
why does being born here matter?

and do you honestly think they aren't paying taxes?
If they aren't citizens or aren't here legally they shouldn't be eligible for any benefits.

I work in social services, and have been for over 10 years. In that time frame I've come across many illegals, and only two had social security numbers, and were paying taxes. You can't tell me that they are contributing members of our society.

come now kitteh, maybe one 2 had ss numbers but doesnt that just apply to payroll tax? they buy gas, have to pay tax, they buy clothes, also taxed, buy food, certain foods taxed, they buy toiletries, also taxed.

Just because one doesn't pay payroll tax does not make then a non contributing member of society, they are doing the jobs that most feel is beneath their status to do. I say, don't blame those that work hard, blame those that look for loopholes and tax evasion, blame corporate America who hire undocumented aliens.
As I just said I was referring to payroll tax because that's what was being discussed.

I call ******** on them doing jobs that most feel is beneath them to do, especially in this economy. Employers will hire someone who can be used to their advantage, and my stance is and always has been that the companies hiring them should be fined heavily because their jobs are one of the reasons why people are entering the country illegally. I also didn't place the blame on the illegal immigrants, and simply stated that I don't think they should be eligible for benefits, especially considering the system is strained, and there's not enough funding to go around. Furthermore, having done volunteer work in more than one Central American country for an extended period of time I'm well aware as to their motivations for coming here. And where do you think the majority of the money they're earning goes to- back home to support their families living there.

Kitteh_Kat's photo
Wed 10/28/09 12:13 PM





If every illegal immigrant got to stay here TAX free for prior earnings, free schooling, free medical, and the ones that got deported and came back can now stay or go home and we the US citizens would foot the bill, well that makes me upset.

WE have several people here, BORN here that need help and the government does little or nothing for them....
why does being born here matter?

and do you honestly think they aren't paying taxes?
If they aren't citizens or aren't here legally they shouldn't be eligible for any benefits.

I work in social services, and have been for over 10 years. In that time frame I've come across many illegals, and only two had social security numbers, and were paying taxes. You can't tell me that they are contributing members of our society.


I worked in social services for years and did not encounter a whole lot of illegals trying to get benefits illegally.


I guess you don't consider sales tax a tax then? Or utilities taxes? Phone taxes? etc...


yep...

and there are those that work under real social security numbers that just don't happen to be theirs. they pay in without a problem...and they can't ever draw it back out.

can't buy anything or use anything any more without paying some sort of tax.
You're really advocating identity theft?

Kitteh_Kat's photo
Wed 10/28/09 12:14 PM






If every illegal immigrant got to stay here TAX free for prior earnings, free schooling, free medical, and the ones that got deported and came back can now stay or go home and we the US citizens would foot the bill, well that makes me upset.

WE have several people here, BORN here that need help and the government does little or nothing for them....
why does being born here matter?

and do you honestly think they aren't paying taxes?
If they aren't citizens or aren't here legally they shouldn't be eligible for any benefits.

I work in social services, and have been for over 10 years. In that time frame I've come across many illegals, and only two had social security numbers, and were paying taxes. You can't tell me that they are contributing members of our society.


I worked in social services for years and did not encounter a whole lot of illegals trying to get benefits illegally.


I guess you don't consider sales tax a tax then? Or utilities taxes? Phone taxes? etc...
They can't get benefits at all anymore unless states enact legislation to do so, and the funding has to come from state funds. That sure worked out well for CA, didn't it?!?

I was referring specifically to payroll taxes as that's what was being discussed.


No, that is not the tax being discussed.
I was referring to lulu24's comment about paying taxes, and took it as income tax. My bad.

franshade's photo
Wed 10/28/09 12:16 PM

As I just said I was referring to payroll tax because that's what was being discussed.

I call ******** on them doing jobs that most feel is beneath them to do, especially in this economy. Employers will hire someone who can be used to their advantage, and my stance is and always has been that the companies hiring them should be fined heavily because their jobs are one of the reasons why people are entering the country illegally. I also didn't place the blame on the illegal immigrants, and simply stated that I don't think they should be eligible for benefits, especially considering the system is strained, and there's not enough funding to go around. Furthermore, having done volunteer work in more than one Central American country for an extended period of time I'm well aware as to their motivations for coming here. And where do you think the majority of the money they're earning goes to- back home to support their families living there.


those dayummm asterisks, can't tell the tone of your post with those :tongue:

Employers and myself in a managerial position will always and mostly hire to the benefit of the company, to do otherwise would not be too business savy.

Never said you blamed the illegal/undocumented immigrants (come now we too cool for that flowerforyou) I happen to agree with some of the things you said.

I kinda take a personal stance, I know plenty of people who will not work for McDonalds because they can make more money collecting benefits and staying home, but McDonalds has to fill that position. I know many people who will not work in the sun (for example: landscaping) because that's a ______ job and/or beneath them.

As to where they send the money - that also don't bother me - I spend more on gas than most send overseas, guess who is benefitting from my gas purchases it's not us (yes I said us and I mean Americans)

franshade's photo
Wed 10/28/09 12:19 PM







If every illegal immigrant got to stay here TAX free for prior earnings, free schooling, free medical, and the ones that got deported and came back can now stay or go home and we the US citizens would foot the bill, well that makes me upset.

WE have several people here, BORN here that need help and the government does little or nothing for them....
why does being born here matter?

and do you honestly think they aren't paying taxes?
If they aren't citizens or aren't here legally they shouldn't be eligible for any benefits.

I work in social services, and have been for over 10 years. In that time frame I've come across many illegals, and only two had social security numbers, and were paying taxes. You can't tell me that they are contributing members of our society.


I worked in social services for years and did not encounter a whole lot of illegals trying to get benefits illegally.


I guess you don't consider sales tax a tax then? Or utilities taxes? Phone taxes? etc...
They can't get benefits at all anymore unless states enact legislation to do so, and the funding has to come from state funds. That sure worked out well for CA, didn't it?!?

I was referring specifically to payroll taxes as that's what was being discussed.


No, that is not the tax being discussed.
I was referring to lulu24's comment about paying taxes, and took it as income tax. My bad.


(my best MJ voice impersonation)
Because I'm Bad, I'm Bad-
Come On
Who's bad
waving

lulu24's photo
Wed 10/28/09 12:31 PM






If every illegal immigrant got to stay here TAX free for prior earnings, free schooling, free medical, and the ones that got deported and came back can now stay or go home and we the US citizens would foot the bill, well that makes me upset.

WE have several people here, BORN here that need help and the government does little or nothing for them....
why does being born here matter?

and do you honestly think they aren't paying taxes?
If they aren't citizens or aren't here legally they shouldn't be eligible for any benefits.

I work in social services, and have been for over 10 years. In that time frame I've come across many illegals, and only two had social security numbers, and were paying taxes. You can't tell me that they are contributing members of our society.


I worked in social services for years and did not encounter a whole lot of illegals trying to get benefits illegally.


I guess you don't consider sales tax a tax then? Or utilities taxes? Phone taxes? etc...


yep...

and there are those that work under real social security numbers that just don't happen to be theirs. they pay in without a problem...and they can't ever draw it back out.

can't buy anything or use anything any more without paying some sort of tax.
You're really advocating identity theft?


not exactly.

i've worked with several illegals over the years, and one of the ways they were able to be employed was with a valid social security number. one man who was legal went back to his country and left the number for the rest. they rotated out, working underneath his number. the others had their own social security cards...looked very real, and at the time, as an employer all you did was check that they had such documentation. it was not an employer's job to verify that the papers put in front of them were true and real.

did i know that they were illegal? yep. but they had papers saying that they weren't.

they worked their heinies off, and were better employees than most.

i have no clue where they got their papers, but they were of good quality. i didn't even realize they were fake until the day their car was impounded and they asked me to pick it up because they were fearful of being caught.

no photo
Wed 10/28/09 12:38 PM
Edited by smiless on Wed 10/28/09 12:39 PM
I believe Americans should be outraged about alot of things

Coverage on health care for every American. The last time I checked 40 million Americans have no health care.

The wars that costs Americans alot of money. I think we are over 12 trillion dollars in external debt right now. No country has it that high like the US.

The infrastructure of the country is crumbling. Bridges, highways, clean drinking water, the use of energy, etc. etc. is below average and low maintenance.

The education system is being cut often in various states. See what Arnold Schwarznegger did in California for example outraging teachers.

I don't know about you, but I have noticed that food is more expensive. I get less but pay more lately. I wonder if this is just the case in Miami, but it seems like food and drinks cost more then they use to.


Our prison system are overwhelmed and full beyond control at the moment. Look up this on the internet for more details.

Jobs being sent overseas should outrage Americans.

Illegal Immigration, which is a sensitive topic that shows much disagreements and anger across the country.


So this is just a small list, but come on! The Americans should be upset and they should really try to figure out how to fix some of the problems on the table, because the government is doing a very slow job in many cases and at times stalling on purpose.

jrbogie's photo
Wed 10/28/09 02:31 PM

Take 2 minutes and watch this video. I pray this Amnesty Bill does not pass.

Situation keeps getting better.. This is unbelievable!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


I KNEW this was going to happen. (That way Obama wasn't lying when he said illegals would not be able to get medical coverage under his ObamaCare plan. His simple fix is to make them all legal first.)


EVERY ONE--PLEASE TAKE TIME TO LISTEN TO THIS--IT TELLS ABOUT THE BILL GOING THRU CONGRESS RIGHT NOW REGARDING IMMIGRATION.
EVEN CNN IS GETTING UPSET ABOUT THIS!!!!!!!!!!
Pass this on after you watch it.
NOTICE THAT THIS IS FROM CNN, NOT FOX!!!
This from CNN news:

http://d.yimg.com/kq/groups/17260182/1610997888/name/ftc-vi26.wmv


This 2-minute video should be mandatory viewing for every US citizen. If you have never passed anything on before, pass this on! Every American should be outraged!





now why in the hell would i watch an internet video for "information"
when i can read the fvcking bill itself. jeez people. get off the internet and msm and learn something. you know, do your own thinking and get that cnnfoxmsnbclatimeswashingtonpost monster off your back. mandatory viewing for every american my a$$.

JustAGuy2112's photo
Wed 10/28/09 09:11 PM
OMG!!!

This is ridiculous.

It's very simple.

Illegals, while they may pay sales taxes and taxes on gas and other stuff, DO NOT ( in the VAST majority of cases ) pay ANY income tax at all. Income taxes make up the majority of what the government collects to pay for it's programs.

Most ( and by most I mean damn near ALL ) of the illegals in this country are working cash jobs. That means they get paid " under the table ". NO payroll taxes. NO Social Security taken out.

Are you seriously THAT freakin naive that you think the unscrupulous employers who employ these people in the first place are going to pay them BY CHECK???

Come on.

There is a dairy farmer in my area who has been busted THREE TIMES for employing illegals. He paid every one of them in cash so that HE wouldn't have to pay the payroll taxes either.

I really need to get myself a set of those rose colored glasses you seem to be seeing everything through.

Dragoness's photo
Wed 10/28/09 09:20 PM
Just make them legal and get off the damn fence with our immigration laws, either we enforce them or we don't and end the damn debate.

I get so tired of people talking about illegals like they are trash and unworthy of any human concern that I want throw up.

If they are not criminals and are living the American life make them legal, if they want to live a life of crime either imprison them or send them home and be done.

Then get off our ***** and enforce the laws or change them so we can enforce them or throw them out if noone wants to enforce them and be done.

TJN's photo
Wed 10/28/09 09:49 PM

I found this on youtube
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WCHVXzBo3qg

It say's some of the same things and is dated 2 years ago.

This news is over 2 years old.

no photo
Fri 10/30/09 07:05 AM
Hating criminals non American? You idiots gotta be kidding me!!! They are nothing more than theives, liars, and scammers, spare me any BS about how they are wonderful people who just want a better life. IF that were the case, they would clean up their own country instead of trying to steal ours out from underneath us.

We DO have laws. We DO allow immigrants, but illegals should simply be shot on sight by now.

jrbogie's photo
Fri 10/30/09 07:53 AM

Hating criminals non American? You idiots gotta be kidding me!!! They are nothing more than theives, liars, and scammers, spare me any BS about how they are wonderful people who just want a better life. IF that were the case, they would clean up their own country instead of trying to steal ours out from underneath us.

We DO have laws. We DO allow immigrants, but illegals should simply be shot on sight by now.


so the immigration laws are fine with you but laws against murder and assault should be ignored? you do realize that the bill of rights apply to everyone on US soil don't you? you don't think that only citizens are guaranteed due process do you? do you really think that? why don't you shoot one? see if you don't do some slam time?

no photo
Fri 10/30/09 08:45 AM


Hating criminals non American? You idiots gotta be kidding me!!! They are nothing more than theives, liars, and scammers, spare me any BS about how they are wonderful people who just want a better life. IF that were the case, they would clean up their own country instead of trying to steal ours out from underneath us.

We DO have laws. We DO allow immigrants, but illegals should simply be shot on sight by now.


"so the immigration laws are fine with you"


NOPE


"but laws against murder and assault should be ignored?"


NOPE But really hard to enforce them when the criminals just keep running back home, across the border, hiding out there til they want to come back and take another shot.

"you do realize that the bill of rights apply to everyone on US soil don't you? you don't think that only citizens are guaranteed due process do you? do you really think that?"


What I know is a lot of it is OPEN TO INTERPRETATION. Wanna go through the whole thing? LOL


"why don't you shoot one? see if you don't do some slam time?"

What about CRIMINAL are you missing? If I were to go shooting them, I would be as bad as they are now wouldn't I? What kind of reasoning/argument/logic was that supposed to be? LOL None of the above? LOL

markumX's photo
Fri 10/30/09 02:21 PM
it's wonderful seeing you so called Christians getting fumed over the government trying to help the less fortunate.

Ladylid2012's photo
Fri 10/30/09 02:46 PM

it's wonderful seeing you so called Christians getting fumed over the government trying to help the less fortunate.


drinker drinker