Topic: What is an atheist?
no photo
Mon 10/12/09 11:32 PM
Edited by JaneStar1 on Mon 10/12/09 11:37 PM
What is an atheist?


--Someone who
has no one to praise/blame but her/him-self for her/his accomplishments/failures, who assumes total responsibility for her/his deeds, who does not rely upon any higher power (i.e. deity) for her/his well-being and success, But does rely upon one's own abilities -- phisical, intellectual, or Spiritual (i.e. confidence in one's own capacity for achieving any goal).

msharmony's photo
Mon 10/12/09 11:42 PM

JB - you raise a good point with your word choice. You feel that the word "atheist" paints a picture of non-spirituality - but this is not what the word actually means.

So who paints this picture? And should we accept their picture?

Ladylid drives this point home further, saying that she is also called a "Godless heathen". For many, the word "atheist' is used to connote a lack of values. Should we accept that premise?

All atheist really means is "lack of belief in a diety".

Now these people that are calling you 'atheist' JB - they may actually be mistaking you for something else, like a materialist, in which case you are right about them being wrong about you. But they may also just be using the word correctly and literally. If you lack belief in a diety, but are 'spiritual', then you are a 'spiritual' atheist.



Ding ding ding! someone brought out the actual definition...thank you

Atheist: a disbelief in the existence of deity b : the doctrine that there is no deity

Deity : one exalted or revered as supremely good or powerful


I dont go for calling people degrading names for their beliefs or lack of. I dont feel atheist should be seen as a put down for anyone who truly is, but then I am not so that is just a guess. I know good people who are atheist, they have a good spirit which makes them spiritual. I think that is why its so pc now to claim to be spiritual but not religious. It says "I have a conscious, but I dont necessarily want to be tied down to any specific set of morals'

The atheist denies the existence of a supreme creator and deity. The agnostic just says they arent sure one way or the other. Both types of people can still be spiritual.

no photo
Tue 10/13/09 09:20 AM
Edited by Jeanniebean on Tue 10/13/09 09:25 AM


JB - you raise a good point with your word choice. You feel that the word "atheist" paints a picture of non-spirituality - but this is not what the word actually means.

So who paints this picture? And should we accept their picture?

Ladylid drives this point home further, saying that she is also called a "Godless heathen". For many, the word "atheist' is used to connote a lack of values. Should we accept that premise?

All atheist really means is "lack of belief in a diety".

Now these people that are calling you 'atheist' JB - they may actually be mistaking you for something else, like a materialist, in which case you are right about them being wrong about you. But they may also just be using the word correctly and literally. If you lack belief in a diety, but are 'spiritual', then you are a 'spiritual' atheist.



Ding ding ding! someone brought out the actual definition...thank you

Atheist: a disbelief in the existence of deity b : the doctrine that there is no deity

Deity : one exalted or revered as supremely good or powerful


I dont go for calling people degrading names for their beliefs or lack of. I dont feel atheist should be seen as a put down for anyone who truly is, but then I am not so that is just a guess. I know good people who are atheist, they have a good spirit which makes them spiritual. I think that is why its so pc now to claim to be spiritual but not religious. It says "I have a conscious, but I dont necessarily want to be tied down to any specific set of morals'

The atheist denies the existence of a supreme creator and deity. The agnostic just says they arent sure one way or the other. Both types of people can still be spiritual.



Thats a good generic definition, but I don't think an atheist 'denies' anything. They simply do not believe in a deity of any kind. From the point of view of someone who does believe in a deity, they they might think an atheist is denying what is their truth.

In that sense, an atheist and an agnostic are very similar if not the same, except that an atheist may demand proof of the existence of a deity and even then, he may not accept that deity as someone to be worshiped. An agnostic seems to be a person who might be convinced that a deity exists ... by other than scientific evidence.

I am not agnostic. Any spiritual being who insists that he is a God to be worshiped and that he created me is under suspect. I simply don't believe him, even if I saw him, and even if he looked like the almighty God.

If your description is the proper one, then I have to say that I am an atheist. If my description is the proper one, then I am not.

I don't believe that there is a creator, I believe that "That which is" manifests "all that is", and I am "part of that." So if that is 'spiritual' then I am not religious, I am a spiritual atheist. :wink:





wux's photo
Tue 10/13/09 01:53 PM

I believe it was Jesus who said, "I say to you, if you have faith as a mustard seed, you will say to this mountain, Move from here to there, and it will move; and nothing will be impossible for you.”

But, now I forgot what my point was. So, I'll just post this and go have a glass of wine. flowerforyou



I rather suspect that JC was high when he said the above.

Or else nobody has been a mustard seed with faith.

Or else those who have, also have vested interest in NOT moving mountains.

All I know that there has been no mountains moved due to faith.

And it is hard to comprehend that things that don't have souls can have faith.

SkyHook5652's photo
Tue 10/13/09 02:35 PM
Edited by SkyHook5652 on Tue 10/13/09 02:36 PM
I believe it was Jesus who said, "I say to you, if you have faith as a mustard seed, you will say to this mountain, Move from here to there, and it will move; and nothing will be impossible for you.”

But, now I forgot what my point was. So, I'll just post this and go have a glass of wine. flowerforyou
I rather suspect that JC was high when he said the above.

Or else nobody has been a mustard seed with faith.

Or else those who have, also have vested interest in NOT moving mountains.

All I know that there has been no mountains moved due to faith.

And it is hard to comprehend that things that don't have souls can have faith.
Personally, I think the "vested interest" explanation makes the most sense.

I mean, if someone were so enlightened as to have that much faith, why would they even want to move a mountain? Just to prove that they could? That doesn't sound very enlightened to me. What good would moving the maountain do? Where would they put it? And what would be the overall effect of moving it? Might just as well move a city instead. It would truly screw up a whole lot if other people in a whole lot of different ways.

JMHO flowerforyou

Ruth34611's photo
Tue 10/13/09 03:40 PM
Edited by Ruth34611 on Tue 10/13/09 03:42 PM


Abracadabra's photo
Tue 10/13/09 05:13 PM
Theist = A person who's willing to believe in things with no proof.

Atheist = A person who must have proof before believing in anything.

Agnostic = A person who offers Theists and Athesits cognac, steak and potatoes. drinker




tohyup's photo
Tue 10/13/09 05:17 PM

Theist = A person who's willing to believe in things with no proof.

Atheist = A person who must have proof before believing in anything.

Agnostic = A person who offers Theists and Athesits cognac, steak and potatoes. drinker





drinker drinker

tohyup's photo
Tue 10/13/09 05:17 PM
Edited by tohyup on Tue 10/13/09 05:18 PM
Double post

SkyHook5652's photo
Tue 10/13/09 05:41 PM
Theist = A person who's willing to believe in things with no proof.

Atheist = A person who must have proof before believing in anything.

Agnostic = A person who offers Theists and Athesits cognac, steak and potatoes. drinker

Sutter Home??? sick

But the meal sure looks good. biggrin

jrbogie's photo
Tue 10/13/09 06:17 PM

Theist = A person who's willing to believe in things with no proof.

Atheist = A person who must have proof before believing in anything.

Agnostic = A person who offers Theists and Athesits cognac, steak and potatoes. drinker






like it. that's damn near as close as anybody i've seen explaining accurately what an agnostic is. we simply don't give the arguement between the two above a thought. after carefully drinkin i've reached the conclusion that neither will ever know.drinker

BYondLife's photo
Tue 10/13/09 07:13 PM
I'm hungry now....

no photo
Tue 10/13/09 08:01 PM
Edited by Jeanniebean on Tue 10/13/09 08:01 PM

Theist = A person who's willing to believe in things with no proof.

Atheist = A person who must have proof before believing in anything.

Agnostic = A person who offers Theists and Athesits cognac, steak and potatoes. drinker





Well I don't know what I am but I'll take the free meal. laugh

Yum that looks soo good.

wux's photo
Tue 10/13/09 08:08 PM





This picture reminds me of too much faith. Like the last supper, the second last supper.

no photo
Tue 10/13/09 08:55 PM
Edited by JaneStar1 on Tue 10/13/09 09:07 PM
I mean, if someone were so enlightened as to have that much faith, why would they even want to move a mountain?


Apparently, JC has realized it would be very difficult explaining WHAT TELEKINESIS IS -- therefore he substituted the word "faith" for it -- as a main ingredient of the former!
________________ whoa __________________

BYondLife's photo
Tue 10/13/09 08:57 PM

Apparently, JC has realized it would be very difficult explaining WHAT TELEKINESIS IS -- therefore he substituted the word "faith" for it -- as a main ingredient of the former!


rofl rofl

Ladylid2012's photo
Tue 10/13/09 09:08 PM


Theist = A person who's willing to believe in things with no proof.

Atheist = A person who must have proof before believing in anything.

Agnostic = A person who offers Theists and Athesits cognac, steak and potatoes. drinker





drinker drinker


Throw that hunk of meat to the dog and that plate would look real good!
Just the vegetarian opinion...:smile:

Viktorbaenre's photo
Tue 10/13/09 09:16 PM
a person that doesnt believe in god

jrbogie's photo
Wed 10/14/09 07:17 AM
an agnostic doesn't believe in god either.

no photo
Wed 10/14/09 02:30 PM

a person that doesnt believe in god


Okay... you asked for it. Define "God" please.