Previous 1 3 4
Topic: Afghanistan to fall to Taliban come September
jaish's photo
Sun 06/27/21 02:20 AM

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yNss9KSU4_k

A 4 minute video of lackadaisical soldiers movements in Afghanistan.

Rock's photo
Sun 06/27/21 02:25 AM
Biden is the one deserving of a thank you note.

jaish's photo
Sun 06/27/21 02:42 AM
Less than 2000 soldiers - as per video.

Rock's photo
Sun 06/27/21 02:53 AM
The non Taliban people are screwed.

jaish's photo
Sun 06/27/21 04:23 AM

The non Taliban people are screwed.



That's most Afghans.

Brief history: Taliban was created during the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan by the CIA, Saudi Arabia and the Pakistan Army to fight off the Soviets. Osama bin Laden of the Laden family in Saudi Arabia was then the CIA hand to support with his tiny Arab mercenaries, to recruit Talibs, students from the orthodox mosques in the provinces and consolidate them to form the Taliban.

So it's a little like the Russian Revolution. The army from the provinces taking over the cities. Except that the civilians in the provinces, the farmers, etc. are themselves under the guns of Taliban.

Kevin's photo
Mon 07/05/21 12:22 AM
As of today, as a freedom loving citizen myself, I'll be happy to see the Afghanistan people deciding there own future. Not any pseudo freedom giver. The location of Afghanistan is geo-strategically so important that the big brothers find it hard to refuse the temptation!

Toodygirl5's photo
Mon 07/05/21 10:48 AM
Troops should have been pulled out of Afghanistan long ago.


Taliban will continue to destroy people. There mission is evil.

motowndowntown's photo
Mon 07/05/21 01:54 PM
Alexander got his Azz handed to him in Afghanistan. So did the British. Then the Russians. And now the Americans. Let the Afghans figure their own way of government.

jaish's photo
Thu 07/08/21 01:46 AM
Edited by jaish on Thu 07/08/21 01:48 AM


When this thread started, 2000 troops were in Afghanistan
expected to leave by Sept. 2021, as per Biden
giving time for talks between Taliban and Afghan government.

Today, 7 July, 2021 - US troops in Afghanistan, around 100
Talks started in Tehran today --- 7/7/21

We may suppose that Iran Sanction is now lifted



jaish's photo
Sun 07/11/21 07:59 AM

Taliban leader speaks to a news channel in Doha, in English

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jXcy7FPN2T8

sounded reasonable to me.

jaish's photo
Thu 07/15/21 08:13 PM
How to wage war?
Rule 2: Don't declare, surprise the enemy.

How to retreat?
Rule 1: Like giving out a post dated cheque and rushing to the bank
to cash / clear your account immediately; then vamoose.

US troops have left Afghanistan, yes, completely

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sMke2bP9Cn4

Status:
Afghan government troops defending the cities.
Taliban controls surrounding provinces.

It's now a waiting game.


Bobby's photo
Sun 07/18/21 05:56 AM
It is not the fault of the U.S. or any other country for the collapse of Afghanistan to the taliban. They've had support, financially, equipment, and training for 20 years. if they can't establish some form of national defense in 20 years then the failure is on them, not us. blame your own government for sitting on their hands and letting the rest of the world fight their wars for them. one question tho: who in the Afghanistan government pockets the trillions of dollars they were given?

jaish's photo
Thu 07/22/21 07:58 AM

Strategic momentum appears to be with the Taliban," General Mark Milley, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, told reporters.

Milley said more than 200 of the 419 district centers were under Taliban control. Last month, he had said the Taliban controlled 81 district centers in Afghanistan.

It is not the fault of the U.S. or any other country for the collapse of Afghanistan to the taliban. They've had support, financially, equipment, and training for 20 years...
----
----




As per Gen. odds for 2 months to Kabul is 10 to 1

Likely a negotiated truce / take over.., say 4 months at 10 to 1



Timothy's photo
Sat 07/24/21 07:02 AM
That is the truth Booby.... for good or bad, it seems something in this universe would keep the area untouched by modern progress

jaish's photo
Tue 07/27/21 06:56 AM

It is not the fault of the U.S. or any other country for the collapse of Afghanistan to the taliban. They've had support, financially, equipment, and training for 20 years. if they can't establish some form of national defense in 20 years then the failure is on them, not us. blame your own government for sitting on ts heir hands and letting the rest of the world fight their wars for them. one question tho: who in the Afghanistan government pockets the trillions of dollars they were given?



Bare facts:
CIA / Pak Army trained Taliban for 10 years to resist Russian occupation.

Trillions sent to Pak Army to reinforce Taliban

After 9/11

CNN report / interview of Osama bin Laden was reason enough for Bush to send troops to Afghan.

Note: Osama had nothing to do with 9/11 - he had just laughed at being called the iconic figure for the 'might of Islamic whatever'; and for same reason, Pak Army could not oblige handing over ObL .......

Obama paid out another 9 billion to P army after Osama was killed.


-----

-----
On a positive note,

Geo survey found substantial quantities of Lithium in the mountains – potential export

China’s rail/roadie link to Europe runs thro’ Afghanistan

New UN chief is a Muslim from Turkey, pro Pak and pro Talib; likely to channel UN funds to Afghan




jaish's photo
Fri 08/13/21 07:59 AM

With Kabul in sight Taliban are asking maulvis to prepare list of girls and widows aged 12 to 45 so that they can be negotiated to marriage.

no photo
Fri 08/13/21 02:48 PM
Somebody correct me if I'm wrong here but didn't Russia give up there war in Afghanistan many moons ago when they realized they couldn't win in those mountains. I guess the U.S.A. finally learned from the Soviets.

Rock's photo
Fri 08/13/21 09:57 PM
And, Afghanistin fell to the taliban.

Game over.


Vivek's photo
Fri 08/13/21 10:27 PM
Yes, but they just won't stop if they are not confronted strongly

Vivek's photo
Fri 08/13/21 10:27 PM
That seems to be correct :thumbsup:

Previous 1 3 4