Topic: Tear me to shreds! - Literary Criticism Room
perfect_punktuation's photo
Tue 10/26/10 12:54 PM
good call.

you should read my asterisky free-verse poetry and comment.

soufiehere's photo
Tue 10/26/10 02:50 PM
Edited by soufiehere on Tue 10/26/10 02:51 PM

deactivated at 5555 posts. ohwell
I hope he comes back.
Tribbles too.

Maybe they had a Mountain Dew recall.
And they got picked up in the sweep.

(((((((((((((Plastic_Pancakes))))))))))))))
(((((((((((((((((Tribbles))))))))))))))))))

RowBaby's photo
Tue 10/26/10 02:52 PM
Now I know why Fear quit drinking the Dew last week!!!

no photo
Tue 10/26/10 03:09 PM

deactivated at 5555 posts. ohwell
I hope he comes back.

Tribbles too.




quitters

soufiehere's photo
Tue 10/26/10 03:15 PM

Now I know why Fear quit drinking the
Dew last week!!!

He knew something!
Uh.
Seen him today?

RowBaby's photo
Tue 10/26/10 03:47 PM


Now I know why Fear quit drinking the
Dew last week!!!

He knew something!
Uh.
Seen him today?

Now that you mention it.... ?

perfect_punktuation's photo
Tue 10/26/10 03:57 PM
life's a terrible scam.

whose work should i rip to shreds, folks?

no photo
Tue 10/26/10 04:12 PM



Now I know why Fear quit drinking the
Dew last week!!!

He knew something!
Uh.
Seen him today?

Now that you mention it.... ?


He's been posting all day, where have you been?

RowBaby's photo
Tue 10/26/10 04:13 PM
laugh I was joking T. haha


no photo
Tue 10/26/10 04:15 PM

laugh I was joking T. haha




Women can't joke. Hence the confusion.

perfect_punktuation's photo
Tue 10/26/10 04:19 PM
i feel ignored.

this is only child syndrome.

except it's just boredom.

for real - what should i critique?

dig the pic, torgo.

row - you're cooler in focus.

RowBaby's photo
Tue 10/26/10 04:21 PM

life's a terrible scam.

whose work should i rip to shreds, folks?


Oh they all love that.
I agree with bastet though - you should all take a bow.

I do know that Tribbles really wanted someone to shred his story.

RowBaby's photo
Tue 10/26/10 04:24 PM
Edited by RowBaby on Tue 10/26/10 04:25 PM
Too slow. Always trying to keep up.
As the oldest of 3 I got a lot of the (negative) attention.
Women can to joke! :tongue:
Perfect - is my picture outta focus? I've been told that that pic doesn't look like me. It's only a couple weeks old.





no photo
Tue 10/26/10 04:24 PM

i feel ignored.

this is only child syndrome.

except it's just boredom.

for real - what should i critique?

dig the pic, torgo.

row - you're cooler in focus.


Thanks!

perfect_punktuation's photo
Tue 10/26/10 04:27 PM

The smell of pumpkin moonshine filled the air. Fall was offically on it's way. Melissa was sooo excited she couldn't sleep a wink. To calm herself visually, she even went as far as to paint her room pink! But it didn't work. Nope, nothing seemed to work.

She tried everything, and I mean EVERYTHING! Herbal teas, aromatherapy, meditation, and exercise. Hell, even her granny's world renowned Tryptophan Casserole didn't work. None of them worked. It started to feel like all was pointless, and Melissa was doomed to never sleep again.

Was it something she could live with? She often pondered this question, and one day finally realized, of course not. Nobody can live without sleep! The moment she came to this epiphany, if was almost as if a small weight had been lifted from the endoplasmic reticulum of her nether region. Feeling better, she decided to go out.

Now mind you, Melissa lived in a very small town, and there's really not a whole lot to do there. If you ever find yourself there, you have two choices -

1) Go to Buttcrack Bayou and grab a beer.

2) Go to Skeeterpeters Pornographic Get-N-Go, and you know...

Being the girl Melissa is, she obviously chose...

Dun Dun Dunnnnnnn

To find out the answers to these questions, and more...

... tune in next week for the exciting conclusion of;

Diaries of a Pornographic Puzzle Farter


If you're as smart as you tend to write you should be able to juggle impossible allegories with your fantastic stories; instead, left behind, is a chaotic mess with no ending or beginning and not even worthy of the terminology "in medias res".

Do better.

perfect_punktuation's photo
Tue 10/26/10 04:28 PM

Too slow. Always trying to keep up.
As the oldest of 3 I got a lot of the (negative) attention.
Women can to joke! :tongue:
Perfect - is my picture outta focus? I've been told that that pic doesn't look like me. It's only a couple weeks old.


you rock. don't be concerned.

RowBaby's photo
Tue 10/26/10 04:35 PM


Too slow. Always trying to keep up.
As the oldest of 3 I got a lot of the (negative) attention.
Women can to joke! :tongue:
Perfect - is my picture outta focus? I've been told that that pic doesn't look like me. It's only a couple weeks old.


you rock. don't be concerned.


I wasn't just curious is all.

Thanks, I assume Tribbles will like being critiqued if and when he returns.

Next do Soufie! I love her write.

perfect_punktuation's photo
Tue 10/26/10 04:51 PM

You KNOW I don't want to do this.
But I will, the once, for you P_P.

Some background..
I wrote this for a feller I met on M2.
He had asked me if I knew what his
nick-name meant..I had answered 'Is it
about dental floss?'
It had the word 'glide' in it.
He was appalled, apparently the first
motorcycle by Harley was the Electra Glide
so I wrote this to show I grasped it.

DETRIMENTAL
I never finished it as it was over before then
so, the syllable matches are off...
DETRIMENTAL

Outlaw

He glides with electra, into the night
they ride as one at the wind
The righteous shy away in fright
like the devil himself has sinned.

He thunders into the darkening bend
trails of his dust flying high
He knows what he needs to defend to the end
and he knows what he needs to defy.

He flaunts his freedom in weathered chaps
as he haunts the home of the brave
He smiles behind his shades of glass
because the road to hell is paved.




In the first line "electra" should be capitalized. I think the whole sentence would benefit from ending with a period after "night".

"The righteous ones shy away in their fright" is how I would have written the line. If you don't agree with it - rock n' roll - but that's how I truly feel.

"He thunders into the darkening bend
trails of his dust flying high"

Be more prosaic.

'As he thunders into the dark bend,/ Trails of his dust flying high"

There's a lot of room to move in on that moment. Don't ignore it. It could be the core of the piece.

"He flaunts his freedom in weathered chaps
as he haunts the home of the brave
He smiles behind his shades of glass
because the road to hell is paved."

Come on. You've brought me this far to give up on your own style?

Nothing matches. The piece is incomplete. Knowledge, as was supplied to me, was to rewrite it without a copy and see what you get.

"because the road to hell is paved" has excellent structure and is interesting in its visual nature. Don't quite being brilliant there. You waver off, diminishing the great knock-out of the final stanza, which is necessary.

"as he haunts the home of the brave" may be the truest sentence in the poem, but it doesn't communicate well and it is awkward. There is a lot of potential here for a GREAT (i hate all caps) piece, but it's held back by your personal connection to the lines.

cheers.

no photo
Tue 10/26/10 04:53 PM
PRESS 1 FOR MORE LIES

Platitudes for a thoughtless world,
Cliches for inertiads,
"There's someone for everyone"
"It comes when you're not looking"
More lies --
What next?
A man on the moon?

Generalizing, oversimplifying;
You say "I have the answer"
But it's an answer stolen
From thief after thief after thief,
None of whom ever had it to begin with
Because it's a lie
Think: 2+2=9

"This square peg fits in this round hole,
And if it doesn't,
We'll claim it does anyway --
Who can dispute us?"
Reality tells us otherwise --
Reality doesn't fit
In your
Box
Of
Lies

perfect_punktuation's photo
Tue 10/26/10 05:14 PM

PRESS 1 FOR MORE LIES

Platitudes for a thoughtless world,
Cliches for inertiads,
"There's someone for everyone"
"It comes when you're not looking"
More lies --
What next?
A man on the moon?

Generalizing, oversimplifying;
You say "I have the answer"
But it's an answer stolen
From thief after thief after thief,
None of whom ever had it to begin with
Because it's a lie
Think: 2+2=9

"This square peg fits in this round hole,
And if it doesn't,
We'll claim it does anyway --
Who can dispute us?"
Reality tells us otherwise --
Reality doesn't fit
In your
Box
Of
Lies



I don't believe you. The emotion of embitterment comes across more sternly than any message you are trying to convey (if any).

'Generalizing, oversimplifying;
You say "I have the answer"'

The greatest poetic lines in your poem, you continue to toy with them until they are almost unrecognizable amongst your ******** writing.

By not continuing the quotable theme of the first stanza you deny the possibility for personal identification to your words. If distance is what you want, then you've succeeded, but that's not what I believe.

Through your individual piece I don't like you enough to trust math equations you complete, whether or not you complete them - I become uninterested. Imagine what the ordinary, uninterested reader will feel.

You have, clearly, enough intelligence to write the ******** poetry you've more than begun to. Do you have the gall to stick to limiting styles?

Your words sing truer than your message, which is an essential **** up.

You've already written four or five books. If you can't write a poem about the girl that broke your heart I'm about to become bored.

Don't get emo. Do me a favor and write it - since you are a writer.