2 Next
Topic: Alcoholism is not a disease
Ladylid2012's photo
Thu 02/18/10 03:49 AM

"Science may one day accomplish this.. BUT HASNT DONE SO YET."


The big book of alcaholics anonymous~


I dont care what they refer to it as...


They havent found a cure for it, and alcaholisim is not just picking up, or using a drink.


Yep, it is much more complicated than just picking up a drink...very complicated, not so simple as "using a drink".

Mikebert4's photo
Thu 02/18/10 05:05 AM


"I'm not an alcoholic. I'm a Drunk. Alcoholics go to meetings."


no photo
Thu 02/18/10 08:06 AM
"Alcoholism is a disease - but it's the only disease you can get yelled at for having." - Mitch Hedberg

msharmony's photo
Fri 02/19/10 01:21 AM
I doubt there will ever be a cure for alcholism simply because it isnt a disease in the traditional sense,, it is a symptom of individual emotional issues in which substances are used, or rather abused, to try to cope. Dealing with sexual, alcohol, drug or any other addiction is an individual thing that starts with dealing with the persons EMOTIONAL hang ups that lead them to abuse in the first place.

MiddleEarthling's photo
Fri 02/19/10 05:32 PM
Edited by MiddleEarthling on Fri 02/19/10 05:33 PM


The DSM now contains three times as many disorders as it did in 1952 and is more than seven times longer than that first edition. The jury is still out on whether the dozens of new additions hold up to scientific scrutiny. Robert Spitzer, editor of two previous editions, including the one that formally approved post-traumatic stress disorder, recently conceded that his colleagues must now "save PTSD from itself."

http://www.slate.com/id/2223479/



I dont exactly trust the field of psychology. diagnosis, I believe ,are merely created to appease the popular tastes and distastes of the time. I think if you are using a substance that isnt causing you to harm others or become unproductive, have at it and if you ABUSE it, so that you do harm to others or become useless, take responsibility for your choice and do something about it. The same with casual sex,, if you are of the opinion that casual sex is alright, its kind of hypocritical to limit how casual that sex should be for others,, whatever their particular fetish..

people choose to do what feels good to them, if it works out to do harm instead, and if enough people with money are doing it,,the medical field comes rushing in to absolve them of responsibility and make them victims,,,,sigh




Taking psych now, and I tend to agree with you. It's all as much of a fad and "in thing" as other things. I don't doubt for some there are actual problems, but I have MAJOR issues with it being allowed to let people off.

"Oh, s/he's an alcoholic, you can't punish him/her for killing someone in a car accident. It's a disease, and he/she has family issues."



Exactly, the AA's approach to alcohol addiction is to tell them that it's not their fault...sure some are predisposed to addictions but equally as many or more acquire it...and even those predisposed can stave off the harsher effects IF they were to be matured before drinking this drug....it's about prevention.

That's the issue..really, I mean whatever it is it's mostly preventable yet we push it on kids...eh, that's been posted on here already...the org's approach is to challenge the social and institutional norms that keep this addiction cycle going.

Average age of first use? 12 Years old...Cheers!

http://alcoholthenarcotic.org/









2 Next