any comments? totally torn with which one to go with

I have a Zune..like it pretty well!!

Ipod

zune totally, itunes sucks

how does the market place work with the zune? subcription and i download all i want?

well will a zune play AACs? if not then an ipod is better because an AAC can have the same quality of an MP3 with a smaller file size or a better quality with the same file size. Also can an ipod play Apple Lossless files? if so then there's no doubt its the better product

My father FOUND an Ipod along side the road Gave it to me. I love it but i wouldnt mind having a Zune like my friend.

aac?

neither! i have a Sansa Scandisk mp3 player...awsome! it does everything an video ipod does

iPod. Zune is way behind in the digital rights movement.
Apple is way ahead of any other digital music makers.

i love my creative zen nano. it is not video. but it will take a line-in input and compress the input to mp3, built in mic for voice recording, smaller than an ipod nano, uses a single AAA battery which will run for 20 hours continuous. built in radio and will record from FM also....just a great little mp3 recorder/player. have never tried their video player....

ive gotta 30 gig ipod and never had a problem with it, i like it, but i heard that the 60 gig ipods freeze up, thats my 2 cents

Can't complain about my ipod.

AAC is the Advanced Audio Coding

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Audio_Coding

Just picked up a new 3rd gen 4Gb Nano and wanted to chime in... I love it! It replaced a 1st gen Nano that I lost... maybe that was mine found on the side of the road??

One thing about the iPods.. the frequency response of the earbuds suck. Do yourself a favor and pick up a different set (I got a set of Koss that are far superior at Target for $30).

My ex has a Creative Zen (got it in the divorce LOL) and I liked it too but it seemed like the user interface was a lot clunkier.

S