Previous 1
Topic: Elderly woman left to die by UK's NHS, saved by daughter
raiderfan_32's photo
Mon 10/12/09 06:10 PM
Healthcare system modeled after the ones in Europe is what you want?

here's a peek at the future:




From The Sunday Times October 11, 2009

Daughter saves mother, 80, left by doctors to starve

AN 80-year-old grandmother who doctors identified as terminally ill and left to starve to death has recovered after her outraged daughter intervened.

Hazel Fenton, from East Sussex, is alive nine months after medics ruled she had only days to live, withdrew her antibiotics and denied her artificial feeding. The former school matron had been placed on a controversial care plan intended to ease the last days of dying patients.

Doctors say Fenton is an example of patients who have been condemned to death on the Liverpool care pathway plan. They argue that while it is suitable for patients who do have only days to live, it is being used more widely in the NHS, denying treatment to elderly patients who are not dying.

Fenton’s daughter, Christine Ball, who had been looking after her mother before she was admitted to the Conquest hospital in Hastings, East Sussex, on January 11, says she had to fight hospital staff for weeks before her mother was taken off the plan and given artificial feeding.

Related Links
Doctors say EU working week is killing patients
Families 'kept in dark' by doctors over dying
Ball, 42, from Robertsbridge, East Sussex, said: “My mother was going to be left to starve and dehydrate to death. It really is a subterfuge for legalised euthanasia of the elderly on the NHS. ”

Fenton was admitted to hospital suffering from pneumonia. Although Ball acknowledged that her mother was very ill she was astonished when a junior doctor told her she was going to be placed on the plan to “make her more comfortable” in her last days.

Ball insisted that her mother was not dying but her objections were ignored. A nurse even approached her to say: “What do you want done with your mother’s body?”

On January 19, Fenton’s 80th birthday, Ball says her mother was feeling better and chatting to her family, but it took another four days to persuade doctors to give her artificial feeding.

Fenton is now being looked after in a nursing home five minutes from where her daughter lives.

Peter Hargreaves, a consultant in palliative medicine, is concerned that other patients who could recover are left to die. He said: “As they are spreading out across the country, the training is getting probably more and more diluted.”

A spokesman for East Sussex Hospitals NHS Trust, said: “Patients’ needs are assessed before they are placed on the [plan]. Daily reviews are undertaken by clinicians whenever possible.”

In a separate case, the family of an 87-year-old woman say the plan is being used as a way of giving minimum care to dying patients.

Susan Budden, whose mother, Iris Griffin, from Norwich, died in a nursing home in July 2008 from a brain tumour, said: “When she was started on the [plan] her medication was withdrawn. As a result she became agitated and distressed.

“It would appear that the [plan] is . . . used purely as a protocol which can be ticked off to justify the management of a patient.”

Deborah Murphy, the national lead nurse for the care pathway, said: “If the education and training is not in place, the [plan] should not be used.” She said 3% of patients placed on the plan recovered.

http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/health/article6869646.ece


yellowrose10's photo
Mon 10/12/09 06:11 PM
OMG how sad. :cry:

TJN's photo
Mon 10/12/09 06:13 PM
It's only a shame that those will say it's not true.
I saw this article and just have a hard time with it because it makes me wonder if we do get national healthcare what will happen with my mother.

raiderfan_32's photo
Mon 10/12/09 06:17 PM
Edited by raiderfan_32 on Mon 10/12/09 06:18 PM
drinker drinker :banana: :banana: yea!!!!drinker :banana: drinker single payer health care!!!! :banana: :banana: drinker drinker

metalwing's photo
Mon 10/12/09 06:26 PM
The facts are that the proposed health care system is moving in this direction.

boredinaz06's photo
Mon 10/12/09 06:29 PM



Only the ignorant agree with this plan, perhaps we should euthanize the ignorantdrinker

Winx's photo
Mon 10/12/09 06:34 PM
That is a horrible thing to happen to a person.:cry:

We are not going to have death panels.slaphead




TJN's photo
Mon 10/12/09 06:36 PM

That is a horrible thing to happen to a person.:cry:

We are not going to have death panels.slaphead





No one called it a death panel.
But that is what there end of life counselors decided about her.

yellowrose10's photo
Mon 10/12/09 06:39 PM
I worry about my grandparents. My grandmother has had a mastectomy, back surgeries and recently small heart attacks and strokes. she has private health care from my grandfather working for Lockheed for as long as I can remember but also has medicare. My grandfather is just a few years behind her too

raiderfan_32's photo
Mon 10/12/09 06:40 PM

That is a horrible thing to happen to a person.:cry:

We are not going to have death panels.slaphead






you're oh so right.. because this gov't take over of the health care industry is NOT going to happen.. despite the Stalinist propaganda tactics on the part of The One!

Winx's photo
Mon 10/12/09 06:42 PM


That is a horrible thing to happen to a person.:cry:

We are not going to have death panels.slaphead


No one called it a death panel.
But that is what there end of life counselors decided about her.


It is against a counselor's rules to decide things for us here. They may suggest but they shouldn't ever decide.

Winx's photo
Mon 10/12/09 06:44 PM
Edited by Winx on Mon 10/12/09 07:04 PM


That is a horrible thing to happen to a person.:cry:

We are not going to have death panels.slaphead



you're oh so right.. because this gov't take over of the health care industry is NOT going to happen.. despite the Stalinist propaganda tactics on the part of The One!


It could very well happen.

In two days I hope to attend a "Public Option" Health Care Rally at my Senator's office.

There is nothing about death panels in the health care plan.

Insurances already do it in their own way.:angry:


no photo
Mon 10/12/09 06:44 PM
(quote)By now, Americans are familiar with the stories of Canadians who would have died because of their government's health care rationing had they not been able to get care in the United States. Perhaps just as troubling, however, are the less dramatic but much more common instances of minor indignities, inequities and inconveniences imposed by the Canadian health care system.
Nearly every Canadian has such stories. Even the experiences of those satisfied with the country's health care system show that residents have resigned themselves to accepting as "normal" the systemic dysfunctions that would deeply trouble most U.S. citizens.
For years the United States has served as a relief valve for the overburdened Canadian health care system.
A typical story comes from Tim Hodges of London, Ontario, who has been taking Ibuprofen for nine months to deal with pain in his arms. He made an appointment to see his primary care physician, who said that Ibuprofen should not be used consecutively for more than two weeks. When X-rays revealed no obvious problems, the doctor asked whether the pain was unbearable. Tim said no and was told to make a new appointment if it worsened — and meanwhile keep taking the Ibuprofen he'd been scolded for relying on!
A minor gripe, but vaguely disquieting given that the doctor is essentially a government functionary. Actually, Tim is fortunate even to have a primary care physician, because the inability to obtain one is among the system's most glaring shortcomings. These doctors act as "gatekeepers," and finding one is a critical first step for obtaining any care outside of emergency rooms or specialized clinics targeted at certain populations.
I'm from Windsor and am lucky not to be among the ranks of the 4.1 million Canadians (about 12 percent) who don't have a primary care physician. The reason I have a doctor and they don't, frankly, is because I have connections.
When my mother began working with a woman whose husband works in the same building as a large medical clinic, this colleague (via her husband) was able to get my mother an appointment with a doctor there. After about a year, my mom managed to get me a spot in the practice, too.
My doctor is a wonderful physician, but she's terribly overburdened. Like most Canadian doctors, she must limit patients to one problem per visit, in part to cope with the sheer volume, and in part because the Ontario Health Insurance Plan only reimburses her on a per-visit basis. This is an example of how government price controls that limit the compensation to health care professionals can create shortages among providers.
So even though I'm one of the lucky ones who has a primary care physician, except for emergencies I still can expect to wait two months or more to get an appointment.
What's troubling is that situations like mine are accepted as "normal" under Canada's single-payer health care system. Even as they defend their system, many middle-class Canadians recount similar tales of using social networks to secure access to timely care, while resigning themselves to long waits for "non-necessary" medical care and diagnostic medicine.
Even more disturbing is the impact of this system on people who lack the ability to use social connections to get around the queues - typically the disadvantaged members of Canadian society.
For years the United States has served as a relief valve for the overburdened Canadian health care system. If a patient's wait time is longer than the legislated maximum, then Canadians are allowed to seek care at American facilities — but only ones that government bureaucrats deem appropriate. This means that a person from Windsor might have to travel to Buffalo for a surgery that could be done in Detroit.
Backers of a single-payer system in the United States should never forget that "coverage" under a government plan is not the same thing as "access to health care." This leads to a disturbing thought. When the Canadians' system fails them, they come to the United States for health care. If a "public option" leads to a single-payer, government-run health care system in the United States, where will Americans go? (quote)

http://mackinac.org/article.aspx?ID=10914

http://www.cato.org/pub_display.php?pub_id=2753

I pray we can stave off this horrible idea of socialized healthcare

yellowrose10's photo
Mon 10/12/09 06:44 PM
ok...I know I have gone scatter brained a couple of times lately....but explain this death panel thingy please

raiderfan_32's photo
Mon 10/12/09 06:44 PM



That is a horrible thing to happen to a person.:cry:

We are not going to have death panels.slaphead


No one called it a death panel.
But that is what there end of life counselors decided about her.


It is against a counselor's rules to decide things for us here. They may suggest but they shouldn't ever decide.


not if they're the ones scratching the check...

Winx's photo
Mon 10/12/09 06:46 PM




That is a horrible thing to happen to a person.:cry:

We are not going to have death panels.slaphead


No one called it a death panel.
But that is what there end of life counselors decided about her.


It is against a counselor's rules to decide things for us here. They may suggest but they shouldn't ever decide.


not if they're the ones scratching the check...


They have a moral obligation to suggest and not decide things to their patients. I know their rules.

raiderfan_32's photo
Mon 10/12/09 06:47 PM





That is a horrible thing to happen to a person.:cry:

We are not going to have death panels.slaphead


No one called it a death panel.
But that is what there end of life counselors decided about her.


It is against a counselor's rules to decide things for us here. They may suggest but they shouldn't ever decide.


not if they're the ones scratching the check...


They have a moral obligation to suggest and not decide things to their patients. I know their rules.


dangerous naïveté.. utterly dangerous..

Winx's photo
Mon 10/12/09 06:54 PM






That is a horrible thing to happen to a person.:cry:

We are not going to have death panels.slaphead


No one called it a death panel.
But that is what there end of life counselors decided about her.


It is against a counselor's rules to decide things for us here. They may suggest but they shouldn't ever decide.


not if they're the ones scratching the check...


They have a moral obligation to suggest and not decide things to their patients. I know their rules.


dangerous naïveté.. utterly dangerous..


Not naive at all. :wink: It's called experience. I've worked in that business.

no photo
Mon 10/12/09 07:03 PM
It's pretty naive to think these things don't happen in our current system. I say leave it the way it is and let the insurers bleed everyone from their wallets as they have for years, and now say they will continue to do no matter what comes out of the white house, yupper pretty bold, but what's new.

What the hell, I might as well join the ranks of the 'I could care less about anyone but myself' crowd. But hell if you can find something wrong anywhere in the world you can compare it to something we have never even had yet. What the hell...

Personally I think the whole health care things is getting so bogged down by bs and insurer demands we'll end up with something barely resembling what Obama wanted anyway.

I don't give a rats a$$ anymore, it's just become a circus.

Winx's photo
Mon 10/12/09 07:07 PM

It's pretty naive to think these things don't happen in our current system. I say leave it the way it is and let the insurers bleed everyone from their wallets as they have for years, and now say they will continue to do no matter what comes out of the white house, yupper pretty bold, but what's new.

What the hell, I might as well join the ranks of the 'I could care less about anyone but myself' crowd. But hell if you can find something wrong anywhere in the world you can compare it to something we have never even had yet. What the hell...

Personally I think the whole health care things is getting so bogged down by bs and insurer demands we'll end up with something barely resembling what Obama wanted anyway.

I don't give a rats a$$ anymore, it's just become a circus.


I wish that they would quit butchering Obama's public option plan.frustrated

Previous 1