Topic: 4th idol judge
itsmetina's photo
Mon 08/25/08 08:46 PM
kara dioguardi will be added as 4th judge.What do yall think?

no photo
Mon 08/25/08 08:47 PM
dont know who that is,and dont care,besides,ive never watched the show.

isaac_dede's photo
Mon 08/25/08 08:48 PM
I think idol needs to put some new tricks up they're sleeve or they are going to die out very very soon...adding a judge(unless it's hugh heffner with his models) isn't going to help

no photo
Mon 08/25/08 08:48 PM
who's kara dioguardi? other than the fact she's the supposed 4th whatchamacallit judge, that is.

Enya's photo
Mon 08/25/08 08:48 PM
Edited by Enya on Mon 08/25/08 08:49 PM
who's kara?

what show?


huh huh huh huh huh huh huh huh

no photo
Mon 08/25/08 08:52 PM
If there is a 4th judge, then how will the tie breaker come about? ie: 2 for 2 against..?

MalenaC's photo
Mon 08/25/08 08:52 PM

kara dioguardi will be added as 4th judge.What do yall think?
[/quote this show become so boring . It was fan for the first 2-3 years but then,,,,,,,,,,,,,yawn yawn yawn yawn

Jules0565's photo
Mon 08/25/08 08:52 PM
I love Idol.. not sure why they needed another judge though ::shrug:: I thought the 3 of them did just fine.

isaac_dede's photo
Mon 08/25/08 08:55 PM


kara dioguardi will be added as 4th judge.What do yall think?
[/quote this show become so boring . It was fan for the first 2-3 years but then,,,,,,,,,,,,,yawn yawn yawn yawn

drinker drinker

Dangerous_Kitchen's photo
Mon 08/25/08 08:58 PM
what's american idol? blushing

Goofball73's photo
Tue 08/26/08 01:50 AM
I hate American Idol cause it gave us Ryan Seacrest.....and I will never forgive the show for that.frustrated frustrated laugh laugh

jasonl26's photo
Thu 09/04/08 11:45 PM
ryan ain't as bad as simon AKA mr. negetive

no photo
Fri 09/05/08 04:50 PM
I watch Idol all the time...don't kno who the new gal is, but I hope she's not a moron. I think they were trying to make a change to keep the show fresh, but idk if it's really goin to help...

isaac_dede's photo
Fri 09/05/08 05:08 PM

I watch Idol all the time...don't kno who the new gal is, but I hope she's not a moron. I think they were trying to make a change to keep the show fresh, but idk if it's really goin to help...

here's an idea to make the show fresh JUDGE ON TALENT!!!!!!!!! not the way someone 'looks' what is this america's next top model?...ummm NO!!! I think they should have the contestants all stand behind a wall, and let the CONTESTANTS chose what type of silhouette they want to be seen, then have them sing. Who cares if it is a person the size of a chevy....let her choose a slim silhouette or a slim person that doesn't want to get somewhere based on just there looks...like them choose an average or heaver set silhouette after all, when i buy a cd i'm not staring at the cover i'm LISTENING to the songs. looks shouldn't matter...but unfortunately in today's society that's all anyone cares about.

lilangel2's photo
Fri 09/05/08 05:13 PM
waving