Topic: Why do you .....?
Belushi's photo
Tue 07/08/08 08:35 PM
These two quotes epitomise why I think religion is a danger to society.

No man ever believes that the Bible means what it says; he is always convinced that it says what he means.
-- George Bernard Shaw (1856-1950)

"I do not believe in the immortality of the individual, and I consider ethics to be an exclusively human concern with no supernatural human authority behind it.
A man's ethical behavior should be based on sympathy, education, and social ties; no religious basis is necessary.
Man would indeed be in a poor way if he had to be restrained by fear of punishment and hope of reward after death. --Albert Einstein (1879-1955)

no photo
Wed 07/09/08 08:01 AM
Religion does not make sense to me from start to end and that is why I can not believe in it .
The world will be a better place without religion .

no photo
Wed 07/09/08 06:14 PM
Edited by sam53 on Wed 07/09/08 06:15 PM

I don't believe in a God who plays hide & seek and gets peeved at those who fail to find him. Especially one that would inspire doctrines written by men knowing full well that this would only cause conflict among men. After all, if you worship a religion that's precisely what you are doing. You wouldn't be worshiping God. It's not possible to worship a God who plays hide & seek games.

Other religions that are more spiritual in their nature and don't portray God as being an egotistical judgmental game-player with an agenda are certainly more attractive. I think there is something to be gained from the practice of meditation to calm the mind, and from an adherence to a well-thought-out set of moral values. Of course, these things can be done without religion, but some people prefer to have a religion as a guide. So it can be helpful for those people.

As for myself, I believe that our true nature is spiritual. I personally believe that we were spirit before we were born into the human form, and we'll continue to be spirit after we leave the human form. I believe it is open-ended at both ends of life, not just at one end.

I have my own reasons for believing this, and I confess that many of them are intuitive meaning that it just feels right to me. I'm well aware that just because something feels right doesn't make it true, so I'm ultimately agnostic (as I believe everyone must be whether they admit this to themselves or not) .

One thing to realize is that atheism is true, it's no big deal. Once you die you're not going to be around to worry about it or have an regrets that you didn't continue to live. laugh

So a life that terminates is nothing to worry about. It just seems like a big waste to me. But if that's the way things are then so be it.

As a physical being who is tired, and having physical problems the idea of pure death is actually an inviting idea to me right now. I think I'd almost be disappointed to wake up from this life and discover than I can never die. But then again, if I'm automatically rejuvenated into a pure spiritual form with not more tiredness and physical ailments then maybe it won't seem to bad.

In truth I often dream about going back and reliving this life again. Not the same way precisely. In fact, I would do at least a billion things differently. But then again, there would still be wars going on an all that crap. I'm not sure if I'd seriously want to bother re-living this life if the rest of the world was going to be the same old crap.

There, that wasn't concise or to the point. laugh

Just goes to show that I'm a rebel in spirit I guess. bigsmile



Thank you ABRA .
1 : I do not believe in all religions as they are all man made kind of politics .
They do not make much sense and they are not realistic to human nature .
Why on earth would a creator send one person as his messenger ?. Don't people have the choice to reject him based on logic?.
2 : I was created and I have no clue who created me . Is there one creator or loads of creators ?. I have no idea .
3 : How can anything starting from zero ( nothing ) create anything at all ?.
Let us put nothing in our hands and wait forever and see if nothing is going to create a thing ?.
4 : ............etc........etc.

alexiateigra's photo
Wed 07/09/08 07:04 PM
Although I have chosen not to believe in any God or Religion, allow me to play the devil’s advocate for both for a moment.

1st. Most religions in their teachings simply apply a basic guideline for a righteous path. Most value compassion and kindness, strong work ethic, respect and duties for family. Things that most people would probably agree are good things regardless of your personal belief.

2nd. Religion can provide a social network for those that crave and/or need a certain type of structure.

3rd. Religions have been created in most cases to make sense of life, death, and the world around us.

4th. If God does truly exist, I think he would approve of my approach to life of trying to be a good person. One of the major differences between me and some believers is that there is no absolution for my soul. Any sins that I have committed will forever mark my soul for an eternity.

Religion and God are not bad or inherently evil. It is how humankind has twisted them for his/hers/their purpose.

Milesoftheusa's photo
Wed 07/09/08 07:34 PM
Edited by Milesoftheusa on Wed 07/09/08 07:36 PM
I believe because the words of the scriptures come alive..Intricatly woven like fine linen. To precise to be man made. Just and reasonable not changing that man could never stand for. If it was written by men then a green light would mean it really is a red light.. Just look at the short history of this country and all we do is make new laws and change others. hard to ever know what is what. But Yahweh's word has stood the taste of time. They are Life giving...Shalom...Miles

Dragoness's photo
Wed 07/09/08 08:09 PM
Just like someone said in my UNreligion religious thread, man will take whatever doctrines created for peace and furtherment of humanity and make it into his own way to persecute those different or unknown.

Just like the organized modern religions of today do. Instead of love and understanding, tolerance and nonjudgement, the religions are discriminatory, prejudice, condescending and dangerous in the wrong mind or maybe the right mind, however you want to see it.

The religious right is named correctly, they believe they know who is right and who is wrong, they believe they have the right to punish those unlike themselves for not being like them or trying to be like them. The religious right through all of their "well meaning" actions have held this country back into the racist, prejudice, discriminatory mindset of old, instead of letting it grow and become better than it was. You hear them say it, "if only the world were like back in this day", which were the days of accepted racism, accepted prejudice, etc....

Religion needs to stay at home. People have the right to believe what they want in their homes, practice what they want in their homes, etc... it is when they are allowed to "extend" this "religious right" way of thinking to the masses of this country that we end up with problems in our government.

My personal opinion of course.


alexiateigra's photo
Thu 07/10/08 05:58 PM

Just like someone said in my UNreligion religious thread, man will take whatever doctrines created for peace and furtherment of humanity and make it into his own way to persecute those different or unknown.

Just like the organized modern religions of today do. Instead of love and understanding, tolerance and nonjudgement, the religions are discriminatory, prejudice, condescending and dangerous in the wrong mind or maybe the right mind, however you want to see it.

The religious right is named correctly, they believe they know who is right and who is wrong, they believe they have the right to punish those unlike themselves for not being like them or trying to be like them. The religious right through all of their "well meaning" actions have held this country back into the racist, prejudice, discriminatory mindset of old, instead of letting it grow and become better than it was. You hear them say it, "if only the world were like back in this day", which were the days of accepted racism, accepted prejudice, etc....

Religion needs to stay at home. People have the right to believe what they want in their homes, practice what they want in their homes, etc... it is when they are allowed to "extend" this "religious right" way of thinking to the masses of this country that we end up with problems in our government.

My personal opinion of course.




You have made some very valid points but, I am going to disagree ever so slightly about religion needs to stay at home.

I think to seperate oneself from spiritual and/or religious beliefs is unrealistic of people especially since people tend to use their spirituality and/or religion as a moral compass.

Instead, I suggest tolorence and understanding and acceptance of not only physical or ethnical or age differences but, of religion and spiritual beliefs.

As human beings, we must not fear the hot topic of religion and politics but, learn to discuss and debate. This in turn often leads to a better understanding of others and ourselves.

Quite honestly, there is no reason why a catholic, a muslim, a buddist, a wicca, an atheist, and/or any other person of faith cannot find common moral ground. Most people value kindness, consideration, and compassion, we simply need to remind ourselves and others of this.

----And yes, it is true, that some will misuse and abuse religion but, if there is any hope for humanity, we must continue try to find that common ground and practice patience even when we are faced with ignorance.

Take Care
Alexia

Redykeulous's photo
Thu 07/10/08 06:16 PM
Alexia said
You have made some very valid points but, I am going to disagree ever so slightly about religion needs to stay at home.

I think to seperate oneself from spiritual and/or religious beliefs is unrealistic of people especially since people tend to use their spirituality and/or religion as a moral compass.

Instead, I suggest tolorence and understanding and acceptance of not only physical or ethnical or age differences but, of religion and spiritual beliefs.

As human beings, we must not fear the hot topic of religion and politics but, learn to discuss and debate. This in turn often leads to a better understanding of others and ourselves.

Quite honestly, there is no reason why a catholic, a muslim, a buddist, a wicca, an atheist, and/or any other person of faith cannot find common moral ground. Most people value kindness, consideration, and compassion, we simply need to remind ourselves and others of this.

----And yes, it is true, that some will misuse and abuse religion but, if there is any hope for humanity, we must continue try to find that common ground and practice patience even when we are faced with ignorance.


In the kindest way possible let me tell you that your words are overshadowed with naivety. You seem to expect "logic" to rue the day, but it will not happen.

Religion can ONLY be a personal thing. By mass producing it with dogmas and magical, mystical occurances, by spirts and demons it becomes a fear, a need, dependence. Once that addiction takes hold one will go to many lengths to force thier rules on others.

That's the reason why it was suggested that religion remain a private issue. If one wants to socialize with other like minded poeple, fine, but their area of socialization can not be extended beyond the boundaries of their group, or the natural tendency is to HOOK others into the addictions and condemn those who don't follow.


alexiateigra's photo
Thu 07/10/08 06:33 PM

Alexia said
You have made some very valid points but, I am going to disagree ever so slightly about religion needs to stay at home.

I think to seperate oneself from spiritual and/or religious beliefs is unrealistic of people especially since people tend to use their spirituality and/or religion as a moral compass.

Instead, I suggest tolorence and understanding and acceptance of not only physical or ethnical or age differences but, of religion and spiritual beliefs.

As human beings, we must not fear the hot topic of religion and politics but, learn to discuss and debate. This in turn often leads to a better understanding of others and ourselves.

Quite honestly, there is no reason why a catholic, a muslim, a buddist, a wicca, an atheist, and/or any other person of faith cannot find common moral ground. Most people value kindness, consideration, and compassion, we simply need to remind ourselves and others of this.

----And yes, it is true, that some will misuse and abuse religion but, if there is any hope for humanity, we must continue try to find that common ground and practice patience even when we are faced with ignorance.


In the kindest way possible let me tell you that your words are overshadowed with naivety. You seem to expect "logic" to rue the day, but it will not happen.

Religion can ONLY be a personal thing. By mass producing it with dogmas and magical, mystical occurances, by spirts and demons it becomes a fear, a need, dependence. Once that addiction takes hold one will go to many lengths to force thier rules on others.

That's the reason why it was suggested that religion remain a private issue. If one wants to socialize with other like minded poeple, fine, but their area of socialization can not be extended beyond the boundaries of their group, or the natural tendency is to HOOK others into the addictions and condemn those who don't follow.




I can understand why you may think that I am naive & I do realize that entire human race will most likely never live in harmony but, as human beings we have a responsibility to each other to continue to strive for that peace.

(What can I say, I am idealist through and through).

I can also say that I have been fortunate enough to be able to socialize and discuss religions with others who do not share the same beliefs as I do. This is done through simple respect. I have had friends that were devote catholics, muslim, lutheran, methodist, wicca, and so on and so on. Not only have I seen and partake in such events in a one on one conversation, but in small and large groups as well. Thus, I know through personal experience that it can be done. It is truly a matter of how willing are you as an individual to pratice tolerance as we all hope for.

Thanks for you response and feedback.
Take Care
Alexiawaving waving waving

Redykeulous's photo
Thu 07/10/08 07:42 PM
Thus, I know through personal experience that it can be done. It is truly a matter of how willing are you as an individual to pratice tolerance as we all hope for.


Idealism tempered with realizm is not a bad thing. I would so like to agree with you but for a few nagging truths.

Tolerance is ignoring a child who is not getting their way. Acceptence is picking up the crying child and walking with it until the crisis is past.

There are those who are most happy to allow you your beliefs as long as the law allows them to to remain bigoted and righteous.

Then there are those who want only to override your beliefs becasue your's are not correct and may subvert their children.

And there are those who fear OTHER religions to point a being justified in committing acts of atrocity.

We quickly digress from tolerance to violence but nowhere is there "acceptance", nor can there be as long as religions teach, that their way is the only way.

Jess642's photo
Fri 07/11/08 02:21 PM
I yam what I yam....it's enough for me.

The rest is so much justifying...:wink:

s1owhand's photo
Fri 07/11/08 02:26 PM

I yam what I yam....it's enough for me.

The rest is so much justifying...:wink:


PROVE IT[/b}

Jess642's photo
Fri 07/11/08 02:27 PM


I yam what I yam....it's enough for me.

The rest is so much justifying...:wink:


PROVE IT[/b}



laugh laugh :tongue: Come here and say that!!!!!!!!!!!devil devil

no photo
Fri 07/11/08 03:37 PM

Thus, I know through personal experience that it can be done. It is truly a matter of how willing are you as an individual to pratice tolerance as we all hope for.


Idealism tempered with realizm is not a bad thing. I would so like to agree with you but for a few nagging truths.

Tolerance is ignoring a child who is not getting their way. Acceptence is picking up the crying child and walking with it until the crisis is past.

There are those who are most happy to allow you your beliefs as long as the law allows them to to remain bigoted and righteous.

Then there are those who want only to override your beliefs becasue your's are not correct and may subvert their children.

And there are those who fear OTHER religions to point a being justified in committing acts of atrocity.

We quickly digress from tolerance to violence but nowhere is there "acceptance", nor can there be as long as religions teach, that their way is the only way.



The reality is that religion has never been a mere private issue . It always had a big hand in politics and laws . It started and stopped wars .
In other words religion has always been a heavy hand on people and nations . It will continue to be like this until people realize it is a man made politics and a simple mythology to control men and women .

baroosie's photo
Fri 07/11/08 04:08 PM

Why do you believe or why do you not believe in religion ?. Please be precise and to the point .
I've been VERY estranged from organized religion here in the "Bible Belt".... I've seen too many arrogant, self-righteous "Hypo-Christians" (clergy included),only following God's word in church, then disregarding it elsewhere, claiming to be "only human"....grumble

I'll continue to be very spiritual and try to be good to others and this earth...:wink:

alexiateigra's photo
Fri 07/11/08 06:58 PM


We quickly digress from tolerance to violence but nowhere is there "acceptance", nor can there be as long as religions teach, that their way is the only way.



I will agree with you on this part 100% but, from my own limited understanding of various religions, I suspect that when such a situation does arise that it is the result of when a person/group is abusing the power of religion to suit his/her/their own beliefs and/or needs.

As I have said before, I have been fortunate. I realize that many that have turned away from religion have done so from a bad experience and/or experience. This may not be true for everyone but, for some at the very least.

My mother, when she was pregnant with me, was treated very poorly by her church because she was unwed. This turned my mother off of organized religion but, thankfully she did not become bitter by her experience. She was an exceptional woman. She realized that her experience was not a true representation of her God but, of people abusing their power. She stopped going to church but, gave my brother and I the opportunity to experience different religions and to make up our own mind.

Later on in life, I attended a catholic college in which it was required to take theology. Thankfully, my professor, a devoted catholic, was also very open-minded. It was his class that solidified my decision that I would be an atheist. It was his class that allowed me to answer the questions that I sought within myself to make my decision.

Although, I have become an atheist, I can honestly say that all my direct experiences with any organized religion have been good.

Maybe because of this, I still find religion interesting. When I do discuss religion with my friends of various faiths. I do not expect them to "convert" and they do not expect me to "convert" so the atmosphere is usually relax. Sometimes, we do become a little passionate but, with smiles and hugs for each other at the end. (no hard feelings). Through these discussion, I can honestly say that I have learned so much more about my friends but, also about my own beliefs that do not center around any God.

Thank you. I have truly enjoyed your feedback.
Take Care,
Alexia

no photo
Fri 07/11/08 07:02 PM


Why do you believe or why do you not believe in religion ?. Please be precise and to the point .
I've been VERY estranged from organized religion here in the "Bible Belt".... I've seen too many arrogant, self-righteous "Hypo-Christians" (clergy included),only following God's word in church, then disregarding it elsewhere, claiming to be "only human"....grumble

I'll continue to be very spiritual and try to be good to others and this earth...:wink:


Did you notice how some preachers fool people and gather tons of monies ?.

alexiateigra's photo
Sat 07/12/08 09:51 AM
Edited by alexiateigra on Sat 07/12/08 09:54 AM

Did you notice how some preachers fool people and gather tons of monies ?.


I do not deny what you say has some merit but, these are not examples that religion is bad. It is an example of how people who abuse power.
If you choose not to believe in a God or any organize religion that is your choice but, please avoid over simplifying the benefits of religion to mankind. It is not always just a tool to control men and women even though the past has plenty of examples of this type of abuse of power (Waco, Texas). The true origins of all religions are a result of humankind trying to make sense of this world, life, and death but, also find a purpose and meaning to all.
We could argue whether there is any meaning or purpose to life and/or death but, that is another subject altogether. For now, I am only pointing out that Religion can have a positive impact on humanity as well. Thus, instead of arguing about whether religion is good or bad (which is entirely dependent on those that practice and worship a specified or non-specified religion), I suggest to try to understand how each of us has found our own path or those that are still searching. We can learn from one another.
shades


Allow me also add. I truly do enjoy these type of discussions & do not assume that anyone will simply agree with me. Sometimes, it is far more interesting when people of different opinions get together to talk. :)

baroosie's photo
Sat 07/12/08 10:07 AM



Why do you believe or why do you not believe in religion ?. Please be precise and to the point .
I've been VERY estranged from organized religion here in the "Bible Belt".... I've seen too many arrogant, self-righteous "Hypo-Christians" (clergy included),only following God's word in church, then disregarding it elsewhere, claiming to be "only human"....grumble

I'll continue to be very spiritual and try to be good to others and this earth...:wink:


Did you notice how some preachers fool people and gather tons of monies ?.
It's easy.... they know that most of their congregation IS STUPID!!!laugh

alexiateigra's photo
Sat 07/12/08 10:23 AM

they know that most of their congregation IS STUPID!!!laugh


It is not funny to watch others take advantage of those that are trusting and/or desperate.