Do you honestly think that it's fair to rate a quarterback based on ring/s?I know half or more of the fans do,but to me ,that is totally unfair and wrong,take for example,the ravens team that win their superbowl vs the giants,then take the dolphins vs the 49rs superbowl,then take the bucs vs the raiders in the superbowl,now,it should be clear now where I'm coming from! Trent dilford or whatever his name is,he got a ring,Brad Johnson,he got a ring,oh,and their backups AND Third string and everybody got rings right ? Now I don't think I need to say more right? What do you guys think??

I don't. I like to rate them on character,toughness and leadership.. and of course on their arm.

I never liked the Q.B ratings at all. Some QB's mad a career out of the short, high percentage passes, while others, in my opinion.. when out and threw the ball.. play the game, the way it should be.

I always liked the Jim Kelly type QB's

Cool dog,that makes MUCH more sense!!

Come on man, that's absurd. Many great QBs have never won a ring, a lot are in the hall of fame. Umm.....McNabb, Randell Cunningham, Dan Marino, Jim Kelly, Fran Tarkenton.

Exactly my point, Dan Marino alone is a perfect example!!

oh come on, you left Tony Romo off that list...

Lmao ,Tony a good quarterback,but I'll never let my cowboy friends hear me admit that though!

just in cowboy records, he is the best QB dallas has had... to bad he can't get to a superbowl...

Gata say though,if you guys end up with Adrian Peterson,they sure as hell get a good chance!

maybe, he's pretty used up now, tho... they need a powerhouse runner, we'll see what happens in the draft as well... on a side note, i think keeping dez bryant and trading demarco murrey was a big mistake...

Yep,should've NEVER let DeMarco go!

ELI manning is a good QB. But his brother is a legend.

i like peyton, but i can't stand eli...