There's extremes. Would I date someone overweight, possible, yes. Would I date someone who could crush me during sex..... proberly not....

just my take on it:

when you start dating someone you have very little ( if any) real mental connection, which is a emotion that take's time to build.

That then leaves physical attraction as the made reason of interest.

If you are not normally attracted to over weight people, I do not believe you would then date. If you are, then I think you would.

everyone has a type (or types) that they are initially attracted to.

If a mental connection is built over time, then that may very well override your lack of initial physical attraction.

Yes i would....initially it all depends on her personality and character and that same overweight Person could lose weight and be hotter then you ever imagined....just a thought...

Nice!... ...