2 Next
Topic: Is Opera only a Christain thing?
no photo
Mon 07/02/07 08:20 PM
Aida? -- It's set in Egypt and there are numerous references to Egyptian deities like Isis and Osiris. Definitely not a Christian storyline, although it was written by Verdi.

snowhunter9's photo
Mon 07/02/07 08:24 PM
Verdi is Italian but wrote about the outside world, Egypt, Sweden, ect. He is one of Italy's best.

Differentkindofwench's photo
Mon 07/02/07 08:38 PM
Opera has more singing in it than talking. Musicals have more talking with singing bursting out intermittently. Fiddle on the Roof is considered a musical.

Differentkindofwench's photo
Mon 07/02/07 08:39 PM
Whoops, Fiddler, not Fiddle.

no photo
Mon 07/02/07 08:40 PM
If I was a rich man dadda dad dad adad addaaaaaaaaaaaaaa!!!

Oi I love that song!:wink: laugh laugh

no photo
Mon 07/02/07 08:40 PM
geeeeeeez thanks for that spider..........

<-------singing fiddler on the roof songs in my head now grumble grumble laugh

heatherrae's photo
Mon 07/02/07 08:49 PM
ring of the nieberlung.it is a german opera based on the beliefs and mystsism surrounding the legend of the valkryie. and thats not christian by far. it is also my favorite opera.

Differentkindofwench's photo
Mon 07/02/07 08:50 PM
Geez, Gyps, I shoulda stayed outta here - those songs R contagious thanks a lot.....:wink:

no photo
Mon 07/02/07 08:51 PM
heheheeeeeeeee this is why I cranked up the tunes to kill the voices!!!laugh laugh laugh laugh

ajhagena's photo
Mon 07/02/07 10:25 PM
Opera came out of the Western European tradition.

The Western European culture has always been centered around Christianity (if not explicitly, then implicitly).

But Opera itself isn't instrinsically Christian. It just happened to come out of a Christian culture.

transientmind's photo
Mon 07/02/07 10:30 PM
Historically, opera was popularized at the time of the inquisition, some believe that it was to divert public attention from the bloodshed of the time...

...and technically it's a Roman invention but I'd say it can be enjoyed by anyone today.

heatherrae's photo
Mon 07/02/07 10:31 PM
u like them there 5 dollar words dont ya aj.drinker

ajhagena's photo
Mon 07/02/07 10:32 PM
it's how I get As on all my college papers. drinker

works too! When I bother to do them, at least.

2 Next