Topic: Runaway Win Case Against Muslim Family
Lpdon's photo
Thu 08/05/10 11:11 PM
COLUMBUS, Ohio -- A juvenile court judge in Columbus, Ohio, has granted a runaway Christian convert's request to declare reunion with her Muslim parents impossible, paving the way for the girl to fight deportation.

Magistrate Mary Goodrich said Thursday that reconciliation between Rifqa Bary and her parents isn't possible before she turns 18 on Tuesday. Goodrich also said it's not in the girl's best interest
to return her to her native Sri Lanka.

Bary is an illegal immigrant. The ruling allows her attorneys to file for a special immigration status to allow her to stay in the U.S. while she continues medical treatment following recent surgery for uterine cancer.

Bary fled to Florida last year saying she feared harm for her conversion. Her parents deny she would have been harmed.The immigration status of the parents, who live in the Columbus area, is unclear.

Bary underwent successful cancer surgery in May and then was scheduled for 45 weeks of chemotherapy , which would give her an "80 to 90 percent chance" she'd be fine, Omar Tarazi, an attorney for Bary's parents, told the judge.

Instead, Bary stopped the chemotherapy after two or three rounds, deciding she'd been healed, Tarazi said. In a court filing last week, the girl's parents claimed she stopped after visiting a faith healer.

"The parents are feeling helpless," Tarazi said. "They feel like this is such a critical issue that it be in writing."

Goodrich said she understood why Bary's parents, Mohamed and Aysha Bary of suburban Columbus, filed the request. "I've never gotten the impression they didn't care very much for their daughter," she said.

A letter from Bary's doctor recommending the 45 weeks of chemotherapy indicates she is cancer free for now according to available imaging technology, Bary's attorney, Kort Gatterdam, told the judge.

The letter also says she suffers from a rare form of cancer for which there is no standard treatment.

Rifqa Bary stopped the treatment after becoming sick and in consultation with her doctor, Gatterdam said. He disputed the faith healer allegation, saying Bary had attended a prayer conference after which she continued with surgeries and other treatment.

"Rifqa's not saying she'll never do the treatment again, that she'll never do chemo," Gatterdam said. "She'll continue working with her doctor."

http://www.foxnews.com/us/2010/08/05/judge-reunion-ohio-convert-parents-impossible-deportation-best/

I applaud this judge in this case because he saved this girls life. Her family would have killed her.

This is one instance I hope and illegal gains citizenship.

willing2's photo
Fri 08/06/10 05:53 AM
Illegals don't automatically gain Citizenship status.

If she qualifies, she could claim refugee status or some other hardship.

It's sad, the chemo makes her sick. It does that with most everyone who takes it. Had a Mother-in-law who quit and just did Comfort Care. She had pancreatic cancer.

Sounds like this gal has a type of Cancer that's likely to take her. Hope she's able to stay comfortable and pain-free.

no photo
Fri 08/06/10 06:05 AM
Edited by Kings_Knight on Fri 08/06/10 06:06 AM

" ... Bary is an illegal immigrant. The ruling allows her attorneys to file for a special immigration status to allow her to stay in the U.S. while she continues medical treatment following recent surgery for uterine cancer. ... "


Having seen my father die of pancreatic cancer and a friend undergo treatment for uterine cancer, I know too well what this disease does to a human being.

That said, I can't help but wonder what the outcome would have been for an American citizen in a similar case. Call me cynical.

As to the disposition of her case - will she be deported once she's determined to be cancer-free ... ? The article says the ruling enables her to fight deportation.

There are too many conflicting elements in this story to make it possible to feel genuinely happy about any part of it.

Lpdon's photo
Fri 08/13/10 04:54 AM

Illegals don't automatically gain Citizenship status.

If she qualifies, she could claim refugee status or some other hardship.

It's sad, the chemo makes her sick. It does that with most everyone who takes it. Had a Mother-in-law who quit and just did Comfort Care. She had pancreatic cancer.

Sounds like this gal has a type of Cancer that's likely to take her. Hope she's able to stay comfortable and pain-free.


If they are born here they do, but Obama want's to give them all a free pass to become citizens.

Lpdon's photo
Fri 08/13/10 04:55 AM


" ... Bary is an illegal immigrant. The ruling allows her attorneys to file for a special immigration status to allow her to stay in the U.S. while she continues medical treatment following recent surgery for uterine cancer. ... "


Having seen my father die of pancreatic cancer and a friend undergo treatment for uterine cancer, I know too well what this disease does to a human being.

That said, I can't help but wonder what the outcome would have been for an American citizen in a similar case. Call me cynical.

As to the disposition of her case - will she be deported once she's determined to be cancer-free ... ? The article says the ruling enables her to fight deportation.

There are too many conflicting elements in this story to make it possible to feel genuinely happy about any part of it.



I don't care if she's illegal or not, there's a chance to save a life here. giver her the treatment and citizenship.