2 Next
Topic: Should Weight Impact Your Health Care Costs?
damnitscloudy's photo
Mon 10/12/09 07:03 AM
According to the calculator, my BMI is 42.0 Yet whenever I goto the doctor he says I'm healthy as a horse.

Ladylid2012's photo
Mon 10/12/09 07:04 AM
Tough one... I am a smoker, my rates are affected by that fact. Yet I am not overweight, I work out, I eat healthy. It would be challenging to determine who is carrying a few extra pounds and still healthy.
I have a sister who is 300 pounds and constantly eats pills for pain because her legs swell and can barely carry her weight...she is a heart attack waiting to happen.

However being thin is not a guarantee one is healthy. Look at a skinny drug addict...a rack of bones from smoking meth or crack...that person is not healthy just because they are thin.

I don't see how this could ever be passed...

A1CBob's photo
Mon 10/12/09 07:28 AM

Tough one... I am a smoker, my rates are affected by that fact. Yet I am not overweight, I work out, I eat healthy. It would be challenging to determine who is carrying a few extra pounds and still healthy.
I have a sister who is 300 pounds and constantly eats pills for pain because her legs swell and can barely carry her weight...she is a heart attack waiting to happen.

However being thin is not a guarantee one is healthy. Look at a skinny drug addict...a rack of bones from smoking meth or crack...that person is not healthy just because they are thin.

I don't see how this could ever be passed...


Socialist views is how. It's their way or the Highway.

meowzakat's photo
Mon 10/12/09 08:58 AM


Oct. 11: In an effort to reduce health care costs, North Carolina may require state workers whose body mass index exceeds a certain limit to pay more for their insurance. Former plus-size model Catherine Schuller and John Banz-Haf of George Washing University discuss the issue.

Find the video from Today Show 10/11/2009

http://today.msnbc.msn.com/id/3041426/ns/today-today_health

Can't wait for Obama Health Care?? Once North Carolina requires this, watch other States jump on, then watch your Employers jump on. If your 40-50 lbs over weight you will pay more.

Bob out


Thats ok, Weight is something that can be helped and managed, good incentive.

Dragoness's photo
Mon 10/12/09 09:00 AM

Tough one... I am a smoker, my rates are affected by that fact. Yet I am not overweight, I work out, I eat healthy. It would be challenging to determine who is carrying a few extra pounds and still healthy.
I have a sister who is 300 pounds and constantly eats pills for pain because her legs swell and can barely carry her weight...she is a heart attack waiting to happen.

However being thin is not a guarantee one is healthy. Look at a skinny drug addict...a rack of bones from smoking meth or crack...that person is not healthy just because they are thin.

I don't see how this could ever be passed...


:thumbsup:

EkkoLost's photo
Mon 10/12/09 09:50 AM
Fat people fall hard.

2 Next