Topic: real dumb question here
daniel48706's photo
Thu 09/03/09 06:21 AM
I am sure everyone knows that when a bill is passed it is not for just one subject. For example, the upcoming bill for medical coverage, ifit gets passed there will be major changes and such to other laws, regulations and such that have nothing to do with health care. Due to this, a lot of good ideas get scrapped because to get the good idea passed, you also have to pass the bad one.

My question is this: Why can't a bill be just that; A single subject? You want to pass a tax bill, then only discuss what is directly related to that particular subject, do not combine several issues into one bill.

This seems like it would make things a hell of a lot easier for people to understand, and it would also help keep things from being secretly done.

no photo
Thu 09/03/09 06:22 AM
at least now we have a line item veto

lilott's photo
Thu 09/03/09 06:33 AM
Mr president was supposed to stop that but......

InvictusV's photo
Thu 09/03/09 06:37 AM
The Line Item Veto was ruled unconstitutional in 1998.

The only way it can be implemented is through a constitutional amendment.


no photo
Thu 09/03/09 06:45 AM

The state governors have it...


The Line Item Veto was ruled unconstitutional in 1998.

The only way it can be implemented is through a constitutional amendment.



no photo
Thu 09/03/09 06:57 AM
yes..that one was struck down......newer versions have passed the house and in the Senate have been in held in committee for a couple of years..... I believe the President can with hold the funds( of earmarks) approved for 180 days.....at present.....????/

TJN's photo
Thu 09/03/09 07:37 AM
It's basically a way of buying votes in congress.

They don't like something about the bill instead of debaying it and finding a happy medium they say well put this legislation in and you have my vote.

SICKENING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

willing2's photo
Thu 09/03/09 07:44 AM
Me thinks it's called adding Pork. They get the meat and throw us a bone.

daniel48706's photo
Thu 09/03/09 07:44 AM
exactly



It's basically a way of buying votes in congress.

They don't like something about the bill instead of debaying it and finding a happy medium they say well put this legislation in and you have my vote.

SICKENING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!