2 Next
Topic: your in the military....
burgundybry's photo
Tue 04/17/07 09:28 AM
firing squad??

MsTeddyBear2u's photo
Tue 04/17/07 09:30 AM
They shoot him? and send someone else through?

daniel48706's photo
Tue 04/17/07 09:32 AM
close burgundy... The commanding person (in this case the lietenant)
would be authorized to execute the disobeying soldier for acts of
mutiny, on the spot. He would end up in front of a review board in the
end, and have to prove that he was justified, but he IS capable of doing
so. For the simple fact that if hte solder will nbot follow orders whil
in war and refuses one that puts their paople in danger they are
unreliable and dangerous.

HOWEVER, even if they are in war, if they do have the time and
resources, they are required to have the mps arrest for mutinous acts
under war adn have them courtmartialled (where they can still recieve
the death penalty)

burgundybry's photo
Tue 04/17/07 09:34 AM
it happened, did it not....private ed slovik??

daniel48706's photo
Tue 04/17/07 09:34 AM
ok the buck sergeant is gone, for whatever reasons. You now have two
privates (the radio and the medic), you have a satff sergeant (squad
leader) and you have the lieutenant (commander). Who is next as guinnea
pig?

Jess642's photo
Tue 04/17/07 09:36 AM
Staff sargeant is next, then radio guy, the CO, last is medic, whether
he wants to be or not...

daniel48706's photo
Tue 04/17/07 09:37 AM
I dont know about recently burgundy, but I am sure it has happened in
the past. I have seen it happen in training scenarios (no the person
was not actually shot, lol. I mimed shooting him and went on to the
next person). And the ones that were "shot" received full article
fifteens (punishment). They were all reduced in rank, they all lost
pay, and they were all on extra duty and confinement for mutinous acts
during a training scenario (I did nt press the punishment; my battalion
sgt major did. he was standing behind me, dictating this specific
scenario with me as the one in command)

daniel48706's photo
Tue 04/17/07 09:38 AM
very close Jess, but one person is out of order.

Can anyone figure out who it is and why?

daniel48706's photo
Tue 04/17/07 09:38 AM
very close Jess, but one person is out of order.

Can anyone figure out who it is and why? go back and reread the scnario
:wink:

Jess642's photo
Tue 04/17/07 09:40 AM
Am making a guess here, but the CO is last, as he has the sesitive info?

daniel48706's photo
Tue 04/17/07 09:41 AM
dem, I dont know if this will apply with you as you are in canada, and
not the us. However, it will definitely make youthink things through
first. I would reccomend finding a veteran canadian soldier who you can
trust to not gloss things over and to tell you the truth about miliatary
life...

daniel48706's photo
Tue 04/17/07 09:42 AM
exactly jess...

Now can you explain WHY the privates were not chosen first?

Jess642's photo
Tue 04/17/07 09:44 AM
Radio, is important for radioing their position, for assistance when
they can be, and medic, goes without saying, can assist with injuries
and operate the radio.

burgundybry's photo
Tue 04/17/07 09:44 AM
i would say radio guy goes last, if he has sensitive info..(in order to
relay it to those that need it, in dire circumstance?)

Jess642's photo
Tue 04/17/07 09:52 AM
May I also add, in my understanding, both medic and radio,
communications are kind of guarded as imperative to the unit, and they
all have weapons, so can cover the others from enemy fire...

daniel48706's photo
Tue 04/17/07 09:53 AM
sorry bugrgundy sensitive information can notbe transmitted across radio
frequencies. Or at least it is not supposed ot be. Also for the
argument about the medic being able ot use the radio, so could the staff
sergeant and the buck sergeant, so why were they i line beforethe radio
operator? Andyes the two sgts would go before the radio operator.

daniel48706's photo
Tue 04/17/07 10:32 AM
porcelain hun, If it was long enough I would allow you to donate the mop
for use as a wand instead of a string and stick, but sorry to say it
aint long wnough, lolbigsmile

2 Next